Open 560: Tit for Tat (Game Over, 4/12 alive)

[Not_Mafia]

So you think we as partners would stay voteparked on the same wagon?

[Krystal Bald]

Yep.

[Not_Mafia]

And we would be doing that why?

What do you think of his townslip?

[T S O]

Unvote
Vote: xfda

I'm not confident enough in any of my scumreads. This fucking game.

[Krystal Bald]

And we would be doing that why?

What do you think of his townslip?

No reason for you to not be doing it, and considering whom your votes are on I'm surprised you even asked.

The townslip looks manufactured.

[T S O]

He didn't fake drop the tell - the question is if you think it's concrete enough to -be- a towntell.

[xfdagentx42]

Whoever's voting me for inactivity IS CRAZY

Reality is really fucking me up right now. Seriously.

BTW, we really need a vote now.

[T S O]

Inactivity is a perfectly good reason to vote you. You haven't done one thing which would make me consider voting someone else to date.

Your cry of "We really need a vote!" would probably look better if you said who we should vote or why we should vote them. Because the way you phrased it, it might just come off to some people that you don't care who we lynch as long as it's not you.

[insanity018]

@Mod: Both the wine and chocolate please

The horrible hydra made a valid point. You were lurking oh and nice OMGUS please try harder

Seriously? Why is voting for a 'lurker' more important than voting for scum?

[Malakittens]

TSO I appreciate that ignore from me. I really do.

/sacarasm

[Wake1]

VOTE: HGH7193

Let's see what happens.

[T S O]

TSO I appreciate that ignore from me. I really do.

/sacarasm

well I kinda read it but didn't really but will again and reply!

[Not_Mafia]

And, I wonder if Scum can take control of Day as well. They'd talk about who to lynch secretly, then they go on together.

I don't see how this could be ambiguous

[Elmo TeH AzN]

@Mod: Both the wine and chocolate please

The horrible hydra made a valid point. You were lurking oh and nice OMGUS please try harder

Seriously? Why is voting for a 'lurker' more important than voting for scum?

Because you got your panties in a bunch. And look activity. Also
Gimme chocolate

[Malakittens]

Insanity I really want you to be town. I really think you might be scum though

[Julatorium]

First, UNVOTE: Malakittens. We feel the act of her watching/noticing that KB was online and not posting could be town and want to move our vote appropriately.

We looked into Elmo's assertion that he always gets voted or is on a scum list and found him to be telling the truth. Look in the spoiler for the raw data. This appears to be focused mostly on day one so it is our expectation that he becomes more townie as the game goes on. It's interesting to note that his only scum game since January 2013 was the only game in which he wasn't voted on Day 1. This was a shallow dive so results may not be completely 100% perfect but it is enough for us.

Spoiler: Elmo's Game History / Meta

Recent Elmo Games, RVS votes not counted.
-----------------------------------------------------------

Completed Open Games

- Open 446 Town: 0 votes D1, replaces out D1.
- Open 432 Town Hydra: 6 votes D1, 1 vote D2, 1 vote D3

Completed Large Theme Games

- Scummies Invitational 2012 Town: 6 votes D1, replaces out D1.
- Always On Town: Replaced in D6, game ends almost immediately
- Meta Playstyle Mafia Town: 0 D1, replaced out D1

Completed Micro Games

- Micro 109 Entire game is 5 pages long, skipped.

Completed Mini Theme Games

- Mini 1366 Scum: 0 D1, 0 D2, 0 D3, 0 D4, 0 D5
- Mini 1336 Town: 5 D1, lynched D1
- Mini 1329 Town: 5 D1, 1 D2, 0 D3,
- The League Mafia Town: 5 D1, 0 D2, 1 D3,
- Mini 1327 Town: 2 D1, nightkilled N1
- Mini 1354 Town: replaces in D2, 0 D2, 0 D3,

Completed Newbie Games

- Newbie 1320 Town: 1 D2, replaced out
- Newbie 1314 Town: replaces in D2, lynched D2,
- Newbie 1233 Town: replaces in D1, 3 D1, 0 D2,

However, 306 and 312 looks like a double bus and the interactions between Elmo and insanity are setting off our scumdar(s). Given that we want to give Elmo at least a day to "become more townie", we want to vote insanity who has become our strongest scum read. As we said in 273 her questions are very vanilla and inoffensive which comes off as trying to appear to be scum hunting while not drawing any attention.

VOTE: insanity

Our mala read has been improved somewhat and our Elmo read is unchanged and contingent on a insanity flip. We worry that HGH is going to slip through the cracks and would prefer a replacement to get a better read on the slot.

Mod: Please prod Justin Playfair

[Krystal Bald]

And, I wonder if Scum can take control of Day as well. They'd talk about who to lynch secretly, then they go on together.

I don't see how this could be ambiguous

[T S O]

I don't get N_M, explain por favor? Mucho gracias.

Pointing out townslips isn't something scum do to town, so they're either partners or he's clean.

Julatorium's readlist is quite accurate, actually. Either he's bussing, I'm giving bad townreads, or he's not scum.

Nope, only thing accurate in the scum reads is maybe Insanity. Elmo don't have a deff read, but right now in the null area. Your KB scum read is wrong, your read on me is wrong. I think it's possible both Justin and likely N_M townread is wrong.

Explain why Justin's scum.

hgh and xfda are lurking like fuck and need prods up their holes.

Scumbloc is Mala, Krystal. Very slight town lean on Elmo. I need to look at Infinity, as well as the lurkers.

Confirmed not scum with Insanity~

On a serious note. Your scumbloc is wrong, wrong, wrong~

comment on the lurkers.

I cannot find anything indicative of town whatsoever in any of their ISO's.

Look harder.

tried, failed, show me the light?

Mantis has a pretty damn transparent scum game to her town game. She's screaming bloody town as of right now.

she is, yeah, but there's just little bits every so often that make me question if she's not just faking it well.

It's like Mala is just forcing her play and I don't like it.

... Or I'm just trying to hunt.

Does your hunting usually look forced?

[Julatorium]

Mala, Wake, TSO, Juls and probably insanity and Elmo as well are town.
xfda and N_M are still scum together, probably with Justin, but it could be with Riddleton as well.
No read on HGH for obvious reasons but it looks like he's getting replaced anyway so yay for that.

Forgot to ask about this. KB, you are going to have to explain your town read on insanity and Elmo cause....we....don't....get....it.

[T S O]

I really want a lurker lynch because I have loads of townreads atm.

I don't really think Mala's scum anymore.

[T S O]

I have no opinion on Elmo, he can be sorted at a later stage, and insanity is going to be kinda hard to read but I still think he's town.

idk Jules apologising could be the way he plays as scum but it's certainly not something I've ever seen scum do.

[Malakittens]

mod: I'm going V/LA for two days. Need to clear my mind a bit for RL things.

Noted for 2 days + weekend

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Mala, Wake, TSO, Juls and probably insanity and Elmo as well are town.
xfda and N_M are still scum together, probably with Justin, but it could be with Riddleton as well.
No read on HGH for obvious reasons but it looks like he's getting replaced anyway so yay for that.

Forgot to ask about this. KB, you are going to have to explain your town read on insanity and Elmo cause....we....don't....get....it.

I wonder why you don't get it. Its simple really at least from my pov.

On a lighter note:
T S O Which lurker bothers you the most?

Aside the person with ADHD.

And Mala is town anyone who votes her is yeah. I'll let you all figure it out.

VOTE: Jules
Do I really need a reason?
I think I've made myself clear numerous times and Insanity did exactly what I wanted him to do. Flail like a fish

[Krystal Bald]

I hope everything's ok in Malaland.

Juls: idk they just look like town to me. Elmo's arguments are super shaky but I think he actually believes what he's saying.

[T S O]

I can't decide, they're all so useless and bland.

I just decided to vote xfda for no reason, essentially.