Newbie 1515: Old-Timey Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Maestro]

[Honey bee]

My suspicions are Jake, Thesp, and Brian. No specific order. I don't believe that both Thesp and Jake are scum though. Honey and Bins I have pretty strong town reads. And Gottemer...meh. He could go either way. Haven't looked much into it. For now, though, because of the reaction he gave to my first post of the day, which I was actually looking to see how the first person would reply to it as, I believe Jake is a safe bet to say is scum.

VOTE: Jake

If you really tracked jake and don't believe that both jake and thesp are scum together, Then why do you suspect thesp..

and why did you not wait until everyone posted their thoughts to claim?

No I do not have a counter claim, but this isn't making sense, and I'm not voting until it does.

[Boonskiies]

I didn't want to claim quite yet. Because if there is a 1 shot BP instead of a doctor in this game, I was going to be certain to be killed in the night.

[Jake from State Farm]

Notice he ignored the more important question.

[Honey bee]

I'm not even sure what that means boon.

[Bins]

Go Honey Bee!

[Boonskiies]

I was trying to get Jake to slip up before I claimed. And this is a slow paced game, and I was itching to say my findings haha.

[Jake from State Farm]

I didn't want to claim quite yet. Because if there is a 1 shot BP instead of a doctor in this game, I was going to be certain to be killed in the night.

If your intentions were to not claim, why did you? You didn't even see if lynching me without you claiming was even a possibility...

P. edit - I don't scum slip ever

[Boonskiies]

I'm impatient. You can check my other games.

[Bins]

I don't think Jake is scum, waaaaaaaaah.

[Honey bee]

I see.. so you really didn't have to claim, but you supposedly endangered yourself anyways.

Now answer the other question.

[Bins]

I really, really, really don't think Jake is scum.

[Bins]

So, Boon, why'd you track Jake if you had your vote on Brian before Boro?

[Boonskiies]

I had also voted Jake previously.

[Bins]

Oh, and, secondly.

My point from before that you said you didn't understand. Say Jake is scum. Doesn't matter who he's partners with. Jake had the biggest wagon on him except for Thesp.

Why the fuck would Jake submit the kill and not his partner?

Explanations?
- absent partner - which could be true if it's Gott
- it's Thesp
- Boon is lying

Pedit - Yes, I get that. But you had your vote on Brian. Did the flip change your mind?

[Jake from State Farm]

I don't think Jake is scum, waaaaaaaaah.

Cause I'm not.

[Jake from State Farm]

Oh, and, secondly.

My point from before that you said you didn't understand. Say Jake is scum. Doesn't matter who he's partners with. Jake had the biggest wagon on him except for Thesp.

Why the fuck would Jake submit the kill and not his partner?

Explanations?
- absent partner - which could be true if it's Gott
- it's Thesp
- Boon is lying

Pedit - Yes, I get that. But you had your vote on Brian. Did the flip change your mind?

Absent partner doesn't even apply cause anyone can put the kil in , even for the absentee partner.

[TheGottemer]

At this point, I am still figuring out where I stand.
My idea is that Boon's claim seems legit on top. There was no cc. But it also seems like he could just be scum trying to frame Jake.
I think we could lynch Jake today and if he flips town we know who our next lynch is.
If he actually is a VT, we aren't losing too much but we know who one scum is. On the other hand, he could actually be scum. So it's a win-win situation.

vote: Jake from State Farm

[Jake from State Farm]

I'm impatient. You can check my other games.

I didn't want to get killed in the first night, which is why I didn't fess up right away. And then Slandaar got lynched super easily. I pegged Chaoslord down as scum, as my vote showed.

My 2nd shot was a bust though. I completely risked it for the biscuit. I realized Josh B was scum after that, and I should have shot him. I just got scared in case he actually was a doctor.

Reinoe, you had me fooled completely....

You weren't impatient as vig seeing as you explain why you didn't claim. I can't check on my phone, did you ever claim?

[Jake from State Farm]

At this point, I am still figuring out where I stand.
My idea is that Boon's claim seems legit on top. There was no cc. But it also seems like he could just be scum trying to frame Jake.
I think we could lynch Jake today and if he flips town we know who our next lynch is.
If he actually is a VT, we aren't losing too much but we know who one scum is. On the other hand, he could actually be scum. So it's a win-win situation.

vote: Jake from State Farm

No it's not a win-win but as long as you lynch him tomorrow, I'm ok getting lynched. I'm not going to self vote though.

[Brian Skies]

Bins, why don't you think Jake is scum? I don't remember you ever having a strong townread on Jake.

[Jake from State Farm]

It's brian/boon

GG everyone

[Boonskiies]

Oh, and, secondly.


Yes, I get that. But you had your vote on Brian. Did the flip change your mind?

My vote on Brian was me leaning scum on him, and seeing how he was gonna respond to my pointlessness troll day 1 like playstyle, and i just had a bigger read on Jake/Thesp. One of them had to be scum, so I tracked Jake. And technically, I didn't even vote Boro. He hammered himself.

[Bins]

Oh, and, secondly.

My point from before that you said you didn't understand. Say Jake is scum. Doesn't matter who he's partners with. Jake had the biggest wagon on him except for Thesp.

Why the fuck would Jake submit the kill and not his partner?

Explanations?
- absent partner - which could be true if it's Gott
- it's Thesp
- Boon is lying

Pedit - Yes, I get that. But you had your vote on Brian. Did the flip change your mind?

Absent partner doesn't even apply cause anyone can put the kil in , even for the absentee partner.

Ay, learn something new everyday.

[Boonskiies]

Like if you were scum, you could make the kill for someone else?