Newbie 1519 : Murder in the Barracks (Game Over)

[burn_209]

Wait. We're seriously considering doing something other than No Lynching today? That seems absurd. At a bare minimum, if we are lynching today then the Tracker (if we have one) should probably be claiming unless I'm missed something. But I think the better play is to NL without claims.

Lol scum detected.

VOTE: Math

[singersigner]

The reason why a No Lynch today is completely unnecessary is because we still have 6 players, with only one scum leaft, meaning the numbers are in our favor to gain more information now. Provided we lynch town today, scum successfully kill tonight, that leaves us with 4 players D3 (3 town, 1 scum), so

then

we would NL to leave the most accurate decisions to town in LyLo (Lynch or Lose) on D4.

[Bullish]

Though in hindsight, I think any logic might just be wasted on you.

Yup. I think I'm done trying to reason with you.

You're right. I am the pinnacle of rationality, and having a 3-year old scumbag lecture a logician is quite pointless and a waste of energy, not to mention patronizingly insulting.

[Juls]

Official Vote Count

[L-1] mathbandit (Trinitago, singersigner, Bullish, burn_209)

[L-5] Yukari ()

[L-5] Trinitago ()

[L-5] burn_209 ()

[L-5] Bullish ()

[L-5] Flubbernugget ()

[L-5] aphix ()

[L-5] singersigner ()

Not Voting :

Yukari, mathbandit, Flubbernugget, aphix

Votes needed for lynch :

5

Deadline for Day 2:

(expired on 2014-07-31 22:30:00)

[Trinitago]

Though in hindsight, I think any logic might just be wasted on you.

Yup. I think I'm done trying to reason with you.

You're right. I am the pinnacle of rationality, and having a 3-year old scumbag lecture a logician is quite pointless and a waste of energy, not to mention patronizingly insulting.

This isnt epic mafia. We dont no lynch here.

Claim plz.

[Bullish]

...

This isnt epic mafia. We dont no lynch here.

Claim plz.

Me?

[burn_209]

vote: bullish

Not going to lynch claimed pr. Will be interesting to see who gets nked. If some1 else is real doc, prolly best to wait until 2moro to call elmo on bs.

Yukari why did you make this post knowing that the lynch had happened and the day was over? Why would you have taken your vote off Elmo in the first place? He was clearly counter claimed. Would you have rather us sat there and debated for the next 4 days who was the doc between Elmo and Trin? Seems pointless and redundant as we would have been given the answer to who is scum or not the moment Elmo flipped town. I dont know why but this post seems like it was post just for the fact to save face.

[burn_209]

...

This isnt epic mafia. We dont no lynch here.

Claim plz.

Me?

Bullish are you L-1? No? Then why the fuck would he be talking to you?

[Bullish]

Bullish are you L-1? No? Then why the fuck would he be talking to you?

Because he quoted me and I wanted to sound like a smartass.

[mathbandit]

If no one else is going to support a NL today, then way too much discussion has already been done. Hopefully the odds are in our favour tonight, and I wasn't TrackerCleared last night.

Vote: Math

Good luck Town.

[Juls]

At lunch, you will have to wait a bit for the flip

[Juls]

Final Vote Count Day Two

***[L-0] mathbandit (Trinitago, singersigner, Bullish, burn_209, mathbandit)***

[L-5] Yukari ()

[L-5] Trinitago ()

[L-5] burn_209 ()

[L-5] Bullish ()

[L-5] Flubbernugget ()

[L-5] aphix ()

[L-5] singersigner ()

Not Voting :

Yukari, Flubbernugget, aphix

Votes needed for lynch :

5

Deadline for Day 2:

Lynch Achieved

You all agreed that the remaining rogue soldier (aka mafia member) must be mathbandit. Even he pointed the finger at himself...yeah, I did it! But did he?

A lynch has been reached.

mathbandit, Vanilla Townie

*

was lynched Day 2

Important Note

*

I am checking with Vel-Rahn Koon, the Newbie List moderator, to determine if mathbandit's self-hammer constitutes as playing against his win condition and thus breaking the rules. Night will begin once this is resolved. Stay tuned.

[Juls]

Vel-Rahn Koon is looking into it and will get back with me. In the meantime I don't see any reason not to proceed to night. Night Two begins now. If you have night actions, please send them to me.

Day will being in:

(expired on 2014-07-21 22:30:00)

[Juls]

After a quick day you all lay down for a nice relaxing rest. As the drill sergeant blows his whistle you all rush to the foots of your bed and stand at attention. You look up and down the line and notice that one of you is missing. Private singersigner does not move and then you notice the pool of blood on the floor. Yep, another private has been murdered!

singersigner, Vanilla Townie

was killed night 2

It is now day three. With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch

Official Vote Count

[L-4] Yukari ()

[L-4] Trinitago ()

[L-4] burn_209 ()

[L-4] Bullish ()

[L-4] Flubbernugget ()

[L-4] aphix ()

Not Voting :

Yukari, Trinitago, burn_209, Bullish, Flubbernugget, aphix

Votes needed for lynch :

4

Deadline for Day 2:

(expired on 2014-08-05 06:30:00)

Note:

mathbandit will remain a Vanilla Townie in death and will win/lose with the town

[Trinitago]

Bullish are you L-1? No? Then why the fuck would he be talking to you?

Because he quoted me and I wanted to sound like a smartass.

I don't know why I did quote you btw...

Anyways my only guess is that mafia feared I was JK'ed. Tracker plz give us a guilty.

But singer just recently won me a game a few days ago, so I owe it to her to win this one.

[burn_209]

Lets start off with a VOTE: Bullish shall we? Ill write an actual post when I get home from work but this will have to so for now.

[Bullish]

The tracker should claim. With 6 players alive, a tracker claim could potentially confirm 3 more people in addition to Trin. That would be 4 confirmed town, which means we can lynch our way to a win. All the better if the tracker was able to track somebody to singer.

[Bullish]

Also apologizing to math for making him angry.

[aphix]

VOTE: burn

[Flubbernugget]

Whoah. Okay, I don't think I've posted in over a week, so I guess I need a bit of a catchup post, right? On a side note is IC still allowed to explain stuff to us? I have a few questions.

Does anyone have a little theory on a good catchup post?

Is it a game throw not to cc a pr in any way?

Can the mafia choose not to kill anyone on a given night?

[Flubbernugget]

Also, what do you think caused Math to just flail around so hard until he basically choked and gave up?

[Flubbernugget]

On policy lynches.... Loljk

[Flubbernugget]

Why are people suspicious of a bus on d1? That seems incredibly stupid that early in the game.

[Flubbernugget]

Does this even count as a catchup post? I'm not finding very many suspicions. How much does a day "refresh" what has happened previously? With one confirmed and two dead a lot of reads from before are now moot. At least I can't find reads anymore.

I tried reading the thread front to back. Everything blurred. I got nothing from it. Suggestions on how to properly reread a thread?

Also I think I'm posting very stream of consciousness. Can mod clean my handful of posts into one post with a few small paragraphs? Or is the several double posts no big deal here?

Bullish do you really think the tracker should claim and have that be the end of it? Instead of saying only claim if you have x clears or whatever? I don't like it.

Was the apology a joke or did I miss something?

I read one of the essays here before the game on the importance of charisma and tried to pull it off and looked like a shithead. Now what?

Is inconsistency in tone scummy to you guys?

Do you think I should have trimmed the fat in this post?

OK ok I'll stop. I'm good for now. I think.

[Yukari]

Wow.. we missed day 2..
Isn't it against the rules to hammer yourself like that?