Open 560: Tit for Tat (Game Over, 4/12 alive)

[uctriton00]

Night Actions

Night 1:
Elmo TeH AzN uses Mafia kill on Julatorium (kill fails)
insanity uses Mafia Rolecop on Malakittens (returns as Town Jailkeeper)
xfdagentx42 uses Vigilante on Maruchan (kill succeeds)
Malakittens uses Jailkeeper on Julatorium (stops Mafia kill)

Night 2:
Not_Mafia uses Mafia kill on xfdagentx42 (kill succeeds)
insanity uses Mafia Rolecop on Justin Playfair (returns as Vanilla Townie)
xfdagentx42 uses Vigilante on Justin Playfair (kill succeeds)
Malakittens uses Jailkeeper on TSO (no action)

Night 3:
insanity uses Mafia kill on Malakittens (kill succeeds)
Malakittens uses Jailkeeper on Moonlight (no action)

[uctriton00]

Big thanks to Jackal711 for picking up the moderating and collecting night actions when I was gone! I hate it when I have to leave the game unattended due to work, and ironically I hosted the same time last year and it fell on Comic Con weekend as well.

Hopefully the moderating mistake is a one-time occurrence, it didn't even occur to me there was an error until it was pointed out. Don't let this defer you from participating in another one of my future games!

Big thanks to people who participated in my flavor! I've now finally gotten some ideas on what flavor to run next, and what works and doesn't work, so I appreciate you guys taking the time to humor me.

Thanks to those who also mentioned names of people who could be participants, that really did help. But extremely big thanks to those who actually checked the replacement game queue! As a moderator, not having enough players is a big stress, so thank you to those who came in and stepped up.

[uctriton00]

In-game thoughts:

I was fully expecting xfd to shoot insanity, and was shocked he didn't do it.

Not_Mafia's fake hammer on neil went a long way towards him winning this game.

I'm not surprised neil self-hammered. That's becoming part of his meta, as a guy who doesn't care about other people. It makes it hard to read him, so I probably would have put a wagon on him too if I were playing.

I was fully expecting Elmo to skate his way in the background of the game, along with Not_Mafia. Good job on town to catch him before he sailed his way through the game.

Poor Malakittens, you were making good choices, but you were found out Night 1 because I think your soft claim gave you up.

When notscience said that insanity must be town because she's voting him, I'm thinking that sealed notscience's fate and he would have been pegged as scum. If in a LyLo situation, if you are a townie, and someone votes you, and you don't get quickhammered, that means the person voting you is scum. I have no idea why notscience said insanity would be town.

[T S O]

I compromised d1, but I would have refused to compromise d2.

I don't think town were particularly sold on Elmo other than that I strongmanned it - ironically, for once, it was borderline irrelevant because insanity too was scum.

[Juls]

My other head really wanted Elmo.

As far as flavor, uctriton, I'm sorry to say we weren't really into it. I don't mean offense but I think for me, as a woman, having a female named "Tit" kinda turned me off right off the bat. I know why you did it but...yeah.

[Malakittens]

Lol juls. I played because it was fun to read, mostly, I just ignored the names of the people

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Jules I wanted you dead so yeah.

[notscience]

When notscience said that insanity must be town because she's voting him, I'm thinking that sealed notscience's fate and he would have been pegged as scum. If in a LyLo situation, if you are a townie, and someone votes you, and you don't get quickhammered, that means the person voting you is scum. I have no idea why notscience said insanity would be town.

me neither

lol

[Jackal711]

Big thanks to Jackal711 for picking up the moderating and collecting night actions when I was gone! I hate it when I have to leave the game unattended due to work, and ironically I hosted the same time last year and it fell on Comic Con weekend as well.

Glad I could help.

And congrats to Mafia on your win.

[LlamaFluff]

complete