The Wire Season 1 Mafia: Baltimore Police and Omar Victory!

[zMuffinMan]

*shrug*

ask a dumb question, get a dumb answer

[ReallySexyDudes]

Right.

Vote: zMuffin

[zMuffinMan]

yeah, good luck with that

[Dr Pants]

the sheep shall sheep
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Muffin

[Slandaar]

@Slandaar, not insane really? I've said that meta only helps scum. Sit down and watch me operate and catch the scum.

lol.

Meta only helps scum?

Totally was. I would bet my game life on it being a slip or a horrible gambit. Zmuffin doean't gambit in games I have played with him in.

I've followed zmuffin's trail of bullshit. I can catch you too. You tend to be pretty one dimensional as not town (including SK and scum there).

Why are you talking meta here then?
(I could use more examples but everyone gets the point)

Very strange.

[zMuffinMan]

Vote: Titus

[ActionDan]

Pd

[Messiah Complex]

vote: theadrienc

this is the lynch we can believe in

[zMuffinMan]

desp? what's your read on titus?

[Messiah Complex]

scum?

vote adrien

[Messiah Complex]

never mind

vote: titus

[ToastyToast]

Vote Count #15

Dr. Pants

ReallySexyDudes

BBmolla

ActionDan

--mastin2 (L-6)

Titus

--Slandaar, zMuffinMan, Messiah Complex (L-4)

Slandaar

Messiah Complex

zMuffinMan

--Titus, Anatole Kuragin, ReallySexy Dudes, Dr Pants (L-3)

Xisiqomelir

mastin2

Sharpest-knife-on-tree

--

Anatole Kuragin

--Xisiqomelir (L-6)

TheAdrienC

--

Not Voting: BBmolla, ActionDan, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, TheAdrienC

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch! Deadline is on August 28th, 2014 at 7:30 PM PST

[ReallySexyDudes]

I've decided to stay.

Muffin wagon is comfy but I'm not convinced it'll end in a scum lynch.

[mastin2]

what do you think of titus's play?

If I'm completely, 100% totally and brutally honest?

It sucks. Her play sucks so badly that it's almost physically painful to watch to the point where part of me would wonder how anyone could possibly see her as being town with her overall attitude here and just how sucky it is.

...And yet, that specifically

because

of her god-awful play, I can't think of it as *actually* being scum-Titus. Yeah, yeah, I know, BoP for scumplay is a rather bad thing to use as a standard, but can't help that I feel that way.

Also, fair enough on Messiah, though I still am not sure 'bout Dan.

[mastin2]

I've followed zmuffin's trail of bullshit. I can catch you [Slandaar] too. You tend to be pretty one dimensional as not town (including SK and scum there).

what do you think of this?

Well it's BS; no doubt about that. Don't think it's SCUM BS, though.

[mastin2]

Oh, and totes getting MAJOR deja vu vibes between yesterday and today.

Weren't two of the major wagons yesterday vezok and zMuffinman?
And here today, it's Titus and zMuffinman?

Pardon me if I express my intense feelings that you guys suck.

[ReallySexyDudes]

Pardon me if I express my intense feelings that you guys suck.

Your logic really does completely escape me sometimes.

[mastin2]

Gonna do some VERY rudimentary VCA. By which, I mean, just making highly subjective callouts on wagon formations and what it could mean.

Dripping Goofball

--ActionDan, Slandaar (L-8)

Slandaar

-- Titus (L-9)

zMuffinman

--mastin2, Salamence20, (L-8)

Salamence20

--PeregrineV, Dr. Pants, Messiah Complex, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, DrippingGoofball, zMuffinman, ReallySexyDudes,
BBmolla, Anatole Kuragin, POWERFUL TOWNIE
Not Voting: vezokpiraka, Xisiqomelir, Antihero, TheAdrienC(replaced)

So I'm assuming scum didn't know who the traitor was. Thus, not towncred for being there.

The shadiest votes of those still living are SKOT and Anatole Kuragin.
Off the wagon, we have 1-2 scum.

Dripping Goofball

--Slandaar, Dripping Goofball, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, Really Sexy Dudes, TheAdrienC (L-4)

zMuffinman

--Dr Pants, mastin2, (L-7)

Anatole Kurigan

--Xisiqomelir (L-8)
Not Voting: BBmolla, ActionDan, POWERFUL TOWNIE, vezokpiraka(replaced), Titus(replaced), zMuffinman(replaced), Antihero, Anatole Kurigan(replaced)

Again, assuming scum didn't know there was a traitor, shadiest names here are SKOT and TheAdrienC.

Dripping Goofball--Slandaar, Dripping Goofball, ActionDan, Sharpest-knife-on-tree
zMuffinman--mastin2, Messiah Complex, TheAdrienC, Really Sexy Dudes, BBmolla, Dr Pants, POWERFUL TOWNIE
mastin2--zMuffinman(replaced)
Sharpest-knife-on-tree--Antihero
Anatole Kurigan--Xisiqomelir
TheAdrienC
Not Voting: vezokpiraka(replaced), Titus(replaced), Anatole Kurigan

And here, on DGB, it's SKOT followed by Dan; on zMuffinman, we have TheAdrienC.

TheGottemer

--Sharpest-knife-on-tree (L-7)

Justin Playfair

vezokpiraka

--ActionDan, Messiah Complex, Dr Pants (L-5)

BooKitty

zMuffinMan

--Dr. Pants, BBmolla, TheAdrienC(replaced), POWERFUL TOWNIE(replaced), mastin2, (L-3)

Xisiqomelir

--zMuffinMan (L-7)

mastin2

--Xisiqomelir (L-7)

Sharpest-knife-on-tree

--vezokpiraka (L-7)

Here on vezok, Dan's the most suspicious.
On zMuffinman, it's TheAdrienC.

Justin Playfair

vezokpiraka

--ActionDan, Messiah Complex, Dr Pants, Sharpest-knife-on-tree (L-4)

BooKitty

zMuffinMan

--BBmolla, TheAdrienC(replaced), POWERFUL TOWNIE(replaced), mastin2, Titus (L-3)

Xisiqomelir

--zMuffinMan, vezokpiraka(L-6)

mastin2

--Xisiqomelir (L-7)
Not Voting: ReallySexyDudes, Slandaar, Anatole Kuragin

Here, the most suspicious on vezok is SKOT, followed by Dan.
On zMuffinman, the most suspicious is TheAdrienC.

Anatole Kuragin is the most suspicious not-voter.

Justin Playfair

vezokpiraka

--ActionDan, Messiah Complex, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, Titus (L-4)

BooKitty

zMuffinMan

--BBmolla, TheAdrienC(replaced), POWERFUL TOWNIE, (L-5)

Xisiqomelir

--zMuffinMan, vezokpiraka, mastin2 (L-5)

mastin2

--Xisiqomelir (L-7)

Sharpest-knife-on-tree

--ReallySexyDudes (L-7)
Not Voting: Slandaar, Anatole Kuragin, Dr. Pants

Here, it's still SKOT on the vezok wagon, with Dan as a second. TheAdrienC most suspicious name on zMuffinman; zMuffinman the 'most suspicious' name on Xisi (by which I mean the Xisi wagon looks clean), and Anatole the most suspicious Not Voter.

vezokpiraka

--ActionDan, Messiah Complex, Titus(L-5)

Xisiqomelir

--zMuffinMan, vezokpiraka, mastin2, TheAdrienC (L-4)

mastin2

--Xisiqomelir (L-7)

Sharpest-knife-on-tree

--ReallySexyDudes, Dr. Pants, POWERFUL TOWNIE, BBmolla, (L-4)
Not Voting: Slandaar, Anatole Kuragin, Sharpest-knife-on-tree

Here, it's Dan on the vezok wagon, AdrienC on the Xisi wagon, nobody on the SKOT wagon, and SKOT in Not Voting (followed by Anatole Kuragin).

(Speaking of which, kinda getting deja vu with the Xisi analysis, that I feel like I've done this exact analysis before. Not sure what game, though. Wasn't playing with fire, nor the Calc game; I was town in it. Ah, well.)

vezokpiraka

--ActionDan, Messiah Complex, Anatole Kuragin, Slandaar (L-4)

Titus

--zMuffinMan

zMuffinMan

--Dr. Pants, Titus, POWERFUL TOWNIE (L-5)

Xisiqomelir

--vezokpiraka, mastin2, TheAdrienC, Sharpest-knife-on-tree (L-4)

mastin2

--Xisiqomelir (L-7)

Sharpest-knife-on-tree

--ReallySexyDudes, BBmolla, (L-6)

And here, it's Anatole Kuragin on the vezok wagon near or at Dan's level. Nobody suspicious on zMuffinman, I'll admit, but both AdrienC AND SKOT on Xisi.

vezokpiraka

--ActionDan, Anatole Kuragin, Slandaar, Xisiqomelir, Titus, Dr Pants, ReallySexyDudes, POWERFUL TOWNIE(LYNCH)

zMuffinMan

--Dr. Pants, POWERFUL TOWNIE (L-6)

Xisiqomelir

--vezokpiraka, mastin2, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, BBmolla (L-4)

Sharpest-knife-on-tree

--zMuffinMan, TheAdrienC, Messiah Complex (L-5)

And here we have the final lynch. Anatole Kuragin stands out. That being said, there really needs to be scum elsewhere.

An unthorough look would tell me another scum on the wagon. Dan comes to mind. Slandaar probs-not, Xisi depends but not if other scumspects are correct, Titus I feel isn't, Pants is annoyingly prob-town, RSD is town and so is POWERFUL TOWNIE. Soyeah, there needs to be scum there.
But there also needs to be 1-2 scum off. SKOT on Xisi comes to mind, as does AdrienC on SKOT.

ActionDan

--mastin2 (L-6)

Titus

--Slandaar, zMuffinMan, Messiah Complex (L-4)

zMuffinMan

--Titus, Anatole Kuragin, ReallySexy Dudes, Dr Pants (L-3)

Anatole Kuragin

--Xisiqomelir (L-6)
Not Voting: BBmolla, ActionDan, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, TheAdrienC

And here, on Titus, no sketchy names I'll admit, but on zMuffinman, we have Anatole.

Overall, time being, 'til I do some digging,

Vote: SKOT

.

/might not be good but at least I didn't mislynch the doctor.

[mastin2]

Your logic really does completely escape me sometimes.

Ah.
Common error, I assure you!
Let me help you out:

Your mistake is in using the word "logic" in application to me.

[Dr Pants]

Oh, and totes getting MAJOR deja vu vibes between yesterday and today.

Weren't two of the major wagons yesterday vezok and zMuffinman?
And here today, it's Titus and zMuffinman?

Pardon me if I express my intense feelings that you guys suck.

I know I revoked my right to make decisions but I'm starting to read Mastin as scum.

for one thing, despite taking on the town leader role day 2 and part of day 3, none of Mastins pushes have gone through
but instead of continuing to push those scum reads, Mastin moves to new scum reads
and now the reason we've mislynched is because we suck, and not the total lack of commitment from Mastin, who apparently has the game solved

[ActionDan]

I still think mastin is town.

Just like the following list

BBM
Slardar
Xis
pants
Venjiffy

[ActionDan]

Messiah also.

[Slandaar]

I will go through your post entirely at some point today but let's just start at the beginning.

So I'm assuming scum didn't know who the traitor was. Thus, not towncred for being there.

There is towncred for being there because it shows legitimate scumhunting and reading actual scummy actions as scum. Obviously one is me but Dan deserves much more credit than you seem to give him.

[Anatole Kuragin]

18. Muki/Anatole Kuragin<--I dunno, just haven't liked what he's presented, but kinda have a feeling he's not scum anyway? Near-assuredly not scum with AdrienC, but otherwise...

How did you go from pretty sure I'm not scum to me being the "most suspicious vote/non-vote/breathing player?"

[zMuffinMan]

...And yet, that specifically

because

of her god-awful play, I can't think of it as *actually* being scum-Titus. Yeah, yeah, I know, BoP for scumplay is a rather bad thing to use as a standard, but can't help that I feel that way.

i was more asking about the angles she's been taking this game than the standard of her play.

for example, the quote i highlighted with what she just said to slandaar is something i think is more likely to come from scum-titus than town-titus - she's not only posturing to set up a later vote on slandaar, but it implies she hasn't got a read one way or the other off slandaar's posts already (rather than actually taking a stance on him, she leaves her options open, because she can "catch him later", or something) which is awful - slandaar isn't the most prolific poster in the game but he's got far more content than a lot of other people and i don't think that sort of thing is likely to come from titus as town (like especially the lack of stance thing).

the push on me for the slip was just as bad, and yeah, ok, she's playing awful regardless of her alignment. i don't see how you think that makes her less likely to be scum, though.