Newbie 1530 - GAME OVER!

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Did you or did not say that a vote implies a scumread? So you are voting Manx (thus, scumreading that slot), while saying the only thing close to a case for scumManx is the derp hammer, which you regard as neutral. Correct?

This is scummy as fuck to me. Along with everything else I don't like about your play here.

Yeah. I'm voting you. I think you're scum. End of story.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

And I don't think you're being a dick. I think you're being scum playing around with semantics in order to make me look bad. Everything I'm saying makes perfect sense to me.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Like, if you're town, do you realize how hard it is to deal with you like this?

I hope it is. I'm not just going to back down because you are wordy and have a reputation. Your experience does not scare me.

[notscience]

ETL if you aren't town I'm going to be more upset than I wasi n Dark Ages jsyk

I'll try to set aside time to finish reading tonight

[EspeciallyTheLies]

What does that even mean, ns? Just hurry up. I'm tired of waiting for my Thor flip.

[notscience]

You were scum

nacho was scum

I fucked up and townread both of you

And I will tonight or I'll selfvote, but atm I'm distracted

[EspeciallyTheLies]

You were scum

nacho was scum

I fucked up and townread both of you

And I will tonight or I'll selfvote, but atm I'm distracted

I don't understand the relation. But ok. Don't self vote. Just read at least the last like.. 10 pages or so. We've hashed out pretty much everything that's ever happened in this game 20 times over and gotten nowhere.

Day 1:
Flubber was being a scumbutt. Atum was being a scumbutt. Thor was voting flubber until he got to L-1. Thor unvoted and voted Atum. I replaced in, voted Atum. Ghost voted Atum. Manx (you) quickhammered without a claim.

Day 2.
I voted Vic like a derp. Thor voted me for "end of day posts" which he STILL has not explained. Thor switched to Ghost. Ghost got to L-1, claimed town doc. I unvoted. Voted Thor. ETL v Thor all day every day. Ghost, Flubber, ZZZX waved their hands around and stuff. TTH being all townie and shit. Manx lurking up a storm. Then you replaced in. More ETL v Thor.

The end.

Thor is scum. Flubber is scum. Ghost might be scum but we're not lynching him today. TTH is town. ZZZX is prob town. You are unknown. So this is where I'm at.

[Thor665]

Did you or did not say that a vote implies a scumread? So you are voting Manx (thus, scumreading that slot), while saying the only thing close to a case for scumManx is the derp hammer, which you regard as neutral. Correct?

Oh dear gawd.

This is scummy as Smurf to me. Along with everything else I don't like about your play here.

Yeah. I'm voting you. I think you're scum. End of story.

You have no case on me - the case is a joke made out of misreps that you're either blind to being misreps or are willfully ignoring as misreps.
Describe the case on me.
The best i can do is "wagon analysis based on a presumption taht Waffle is town while admitting that you don't think Waffle is town and also placing a vote that doesn't make sense when ETL misreps the reasons, but, oh, let's sort of admit that's a misrep and then complain that you're scumhunting the Manx spot and act like that's shocking and weird to do after a lurk useless slot gets a new player in it - no town motivation to that at all!"

Seriously.
Describe the case on me.
Now.

[Thor665]

Thor is scum. Flubber is scum. Ghost might be scum but we're not lynching him today.

You think Ghost is scum. You think Manx is scum. You think I'm scum. Anyone else?

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Seriously.
Describe the case on me.
Now.

yes massa

Why is Thor scum?

Alright so, I explained mostly in post 400. Here is the condensed version:

1) Thor derailed the Flubber wagon in favor of an Atum wagon who flipped town as a counterwagon to Flubber. Of those on the wagon, Thor, Manx, and Ghost are the only unknowns, and Ghost is an un-cc'd PR claim, leaving only Thor, and Manx's hammer.

2) Scum not pushing manx for the hammer at the beginning of D2 suggests one of two things: Manx is scum, and her partner doesn't want to bus, OR, one of the scum is familiar enough with scum tells to avoid doing so. Again, the only one who fits this position is Thor.

3) He is a logical NK choice, but instead, the

town cop

was killed, which suggests a very competent player in a scum slot, and the only one who fits that level of skill is Thor.

4) His push on Ghost. I believe Ghost's claim, and thus his consistent push on the slot despite the claim tells me he wants him dead. There's no town hesitation in the face of an uncountered claim.

5) His push on me. He still hasn't bothered to explain his reasoning for his initial vote, nor his suspicions, and everytime he's been asked, he tries to find anything else he can to add to the reasoning, while still neglecting to produce the foundation of the read (because none exist).

Plus the manx notscummyderphammerscummyenoughtovote nonsense.

tada

[Rob14]

Vote Count #2.10:

Flubbernugget:

ZZZX, notscience (2)

Thor665:

EspeciallyTheLies, Flubbernugget (2)

notscience:

TellTaleHeart, Thor665 (2)

Not Voting:

WaffleGhost

With 7 people alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

V/LA:

None.

Deadline:

(expired on 2014-08-23 20:50:00)

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Did you or did not say that a vote implies a scumread? So you are voting Manx (thus, scumreading that slot), while saying the only thing close to a case for scumManx is the derp hammer, which you regard as neutral. Correct?

Oh dear gawd.

So uh... who's dodging now?

Quote tags fixed. ~Rob

[Thor665]

That case is a painful joke. I especially love #1+2 combined to today - it just doesn't even make sense. What the hell?

Also, allow me to walk you through a second time about the point you think I'm dodging.

"then complain that you're scumhunting the Manx spot and act like that's shocking and weird to do after a lurk useless slot gets a new player in it - no town motivation to that at all!"

Again, oh dear gawd.

[Thor665]

I mean, I feel like you need a fething IC wall to explain how painful bad this is as both a case and an issue - that's how terrible it is.

[Thor665]

You're basically calling me scum for multiple Catch-22 reasons (plus suspecting you - how scummy! and please ignore the misreps that I've even admitted to doing while refusing to change my views) and then adding on 'oh, and he's scumhunting'.

Then you're expecting rebuttals?

The rebuttal is - that's a joke case, and the only person supporting it is your claimed top scum read, and you're apparently okay with that.
I mean - am I even remotely supposed to consider you pro-town at this point?

[EspeciallyTheLies]

"That's a joke" is not a defense to my valid points.

Voting someone who, according to you, has no scum points against him, is not "scum hunting", and it is contrary to what you've been saying.

[WaffleGhost]

Thor I expect more from you as defense than calling the case a joke. It is not a valid defense.

@ETL, I think you may have said previously but things are kinda melding together for me. Why do you consider me as possible scum?
Thanks.

[notscience]

ETL, you say my name a lot. I wish you'd stop.

I laughed so hard at this

oh my god

Lmfao

the hammer is real

what the fuck lmfao

(b t dubs I totally disagree with the atum wagon as a whole)

(Also I think it's weird because iirc Anti was so laid back and his sister feels so srsface it's so weird)

[notscience]

Wait a minute

We have a doctor claim

And yet noone's pushing the claim and thought "Hmm, maybe there are 2 goons and 1 knew they could fakeclaim?"

[notscience]

Would also like to hear from other people... that is if Thor is finished dominating the thread...

pffft

This made me laugh

[notscience]

I keep glazing over trying to read this

atm I have tho

Flubber
ETL
Maybe YYYW

As townreads.

Flubber sounds like newbtown

ETL because she sounds like town ETL with the intensity and the seriousness and the reactions and the slipping

YYYW is more gut than anything

[notscience]

Thor sounds really different from the past games we've played together, but it's eben a while so it might just be time decaying my memory of it

TTH is interesting. She just feels cold. Like, I want to get the warm fuzzies but I just get shivers

Waffle's claim makes me raise an eyebrow

[WaffleGhost]

TTH is interesting. She just feels cold. Like, I want to get the warm fuzzies but I just get shivers

Waffle's claim makes me raise an eyebrow

LOL to the warm fuzzies XD people are looking at me funny at this sleek dinner party:/

Would you clarify as to why my claim makes you raise an eyebrow? 0.o

[notscience]

Wait a minute

We have a doctor claim

And yet noone's pushing the claim and thought "Hmm, maybe there are 2 goons and 1 knew they could fakeclaim?"

[WaffleGhost]

*Ignore the sleek part in my last post that was auto correct.

Ah. Thanks. I can't really say anything to that that I know of at this moment but I have to drive back to my house so I'll be back. Or maybe I won't.