The Wire Season 1 Mafia: Baltimore Police and Omar Victory!

[mastin2]

Dripping Goofball

--ActionDan, Slandaar (L-8)

Slandaar

--Tituslot (L-9)

BooKitty

--mastin2, Salamence20, (L-8)

Salamence20

--PeregrineV, Dr. Pants, Messiah Complex, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, DrippingGoofball, zMuffinman(slot), ReallySexyDudes,
BBmolla, Anatole Kurigan(slot), TheGottemer
Not Voting: Justin Playfair, Xisiqomelir, Antihero, Jackal711

If there's scum Not Voting, we know it has to be Xisi. (All others are town.)

If there's scum off the wagon, it'd be Dan in all likelihood.

Scum is therefore going to be on the wagon.
SKOT's scum. But there could be one more. The only candidates are Anatole and zMuffinman, really. Both could even be scum, actually. (But not likely.)

Still going through things.

[Dr Pants]

Anatole has been under the radar this game

which is different from what ive seen

[zMuffinMan]

btw if skot is actually a scum roleblocker, then it wouldn't surprise me if his partners were absent at the end of yesterday when a skot wagon could have gone through

[mastin2]

VOTE: Muki

@Muki

:

I think Messiah Complex is scum.

(Just closed my eyes and pointed at the screen..)

Sala defending himself way too much

, but who wouldn't at this point? He did role claim after the 'slip' so I'm not too sure I trust his arguments.

How much defence is "way too much" defence?

Xisi and Anatole I'm guessing aren't scum together, though it's difficult to be sure.

it doesn't. Sorry Mastin, but Sala was a derp.

General aura around Dan just seems like he's scum right now. (Molla also looks town for what it's worth.)

Like, of the seven to-be-sorted names, most town to least I'd say something like,
Slandaar (I guess? Need more in-depth look)
BBMolla
BBT/Titus
Bookitty/zMuffinman
Xisiquomelir|AD
ActionDan|Xisi
Muki/Anatole Kuragin

But this doesn't really feel that right.

[Dr Pants]

slandaar was right on dbg, wrong on vezok

if a scum rb flips i kinda believe xisi's claim

problem is that the need to be sorted names are mostly lurkers

[zMuffinMan]

the skot wagon was rsd, me, tac, mc, pants, APika (l-2)

so

yeah

if skot is a scum roleblocker, scum were either not there or feigning absence when it could have gone through

[mastin2]

Anatole has been under the radar this game
which is different from what ive seen

btw if skot is actually a scum roleblocker, then it wouldn't surprise me if his partners were absent at the end of yesterday when a skot wagon could have gone through

Good points.

SKOT scum.
Anatole prob-scum.
Good place to start, no?

[Dr Pants]

yeah im cool with that

we need to hear skots claim, but he'll probably get lynched regardless of what he claims

[mastin2]

My tentative scumteam callout for the record is SKOT-Anatole-Dan, but still fact-checking.

(It SHOULD be 3+traitor, since 4+traitor seems strong.)

[mastin2]

(Butyeah, lynch SKOT. We'll be on a better track after that to get things rolling again.)

[Messiah Complex]

My tentative scumteam callout for the record is SKOT-Anatole-Dan, but still fact-checking.

(It SHOULD be 3+traitor, since 4+traitor seems strong.)

no. 16v4+traitor is fine especially with all of the claimed town power

also fish and I both agree that something is off here

we just don't know what it is yet

adrien might be bussing

[zMuffinMan]

i don't think adrien is bussing since he coulda just let me get lynched off the pants thing (which was almost guaranteed to happen if he didn't claim - btw the way in which he claimed was pretty town, too)

plus claimed watcher with a dead doc = it'll resolve itself

[zMuffinMan]

though for safety's sake we're waiting for a skot claim before lynching, even if it's extremely likely he's scum

[Dr Pants]

yeah the watcher is the only town pr left that does anything

[Dr Pants]

assuming of course that we only have whats been claimed

[mastin2]

vote DGB...

independent of DGB's alignment these votes are trash

thanks

okay, looking it over I would bet on there being scum sitting that whole bit out. I think we will find the scum there looking at action dan, bbt, and mastin. There has to be one scum there at least.

mastin seems town to me, genuine there
Action dan.... ug
BBT has really not engaged anything

Vote BBT

Definitely looks like there's something in these SKOT-Dan interactions, for what it's worth.

[mastin2]

yeah the watcher is the only town pr left that does anything

I wouldn't so hastily reach that conclusion. A weak investigative is a near-assurance to give the town some offense. Doctor, watcher, and commuter are all more defense. Vig's offense, but it's killing, not investigating; there's no getting innocent results with bullets.

[TheAdrienC]

It doesn't help I can only use my powers on odd nights.

[zMuffinMan]

you shouldn't have claimed that part

[mastin2]

It doesn't help I can only use my powers on odd nights.

You weren't supposed to tell them that.


Btw, on the seven-remaining list, Molla steals the top spot. Both from Molla awesomeness and Slandaar eyebrow-raising. (But still have Slandaar as more town than scum.)

I basically think that continuing up the list right now is best. SKOT, then Anatole tomorrow, and so on and only stopping if we hit town at which point we reconsider.

[TheAdrienC]

Oh...sorry...

[mastin2]

(By the way, all our roles so far except the doctor have been limited: X-shot mostly, and the odd-night watcher. That weakened town power again means less scum is more likely.)

[mastin2]

Dripping Goofball--Slandaar, Dripping Goofball, ActionDan, Sharpest-knife-on-tree,
BooKitty--mastin2, Messiah Complex, Jackal711, Really Sexy Dudes, BBmolla, Dr Pants, The Gottemer
Sharpest-knife-on-tree--Antihero, (L-8)
Muki--Xisiqomelir (L-8)
Not Voting: The Gottemer, Justin Playfair, BlueBloodedToffee, Muki,

Concern of mine: Obviously, we can (and likely do) have at least one scum in the Not Voting section, but I see not a single person on zMuffinman's slot's wagon that could be scum, and a lynch on DGB that seems scumdriven.

But again, think a SKOT-then-Anatole lynch is best for figuring this out.

[mastin2]

Ok, we can infer that Antihero was a threat to someone, given the fact that there were plenty of kills that would be more useful to a scumteam if they didn't want to change the gamestate (meaning me or one of the other replacements).

No reason why, but this thought from Titus looks

really

town to me, btw. Bump her above zMuff, even. (Doesn't really mean anything bad for zMuff*, just that Titus is more town.)

*Not until I do my thinking on him. I'm specifically avoiding it, if you couldn't tell. He, Slandaar, and Dan are the reads I find the highest importance in sorting overall.

[zMuffinMan]

i'm town

for real