Mala
- I know I'm reaching a bit in the early game for this, but you had Anen as a scum read, and then randomly changed him to a town read. Mind explaining that? I'd also like some of your thoughts on tman - you voted him early on D1 based on RVS, then placed a naked vote on him later in the day, with the only post in-between saying he "feels fake".
Sthar
- Welcome to the game! Have anything to give us yet?
(OOG/OOC - I just figured out you can ISO more than one person at a time!!!!! That makes life so much simpler - and now, back to your regularly scheduled programming)
Here's some thoughts on the tman/Tammy feel I've got:
In
Post #45, tman becomes the only person to involve himself in the Tammy/Flames/Phok issue, other than the three of them. While innocuous in and of itself, it could be early buddying/soft defending.
In
Post #69, he brings up Tammy insisting she's town, and then just four posts later dismisses it because it looks like something she might normally do.
In
Post #90, he goes back to defending the Flames/Tammy voting from a post made 50 posts earlier.
↑ tman2nd wrote:Tammy: I don't see why she's been read as super towny. I mean, I read her as town, but she's not outstandingly so.
Something about this line in his reads list bothers me - there's nothing specific about it, but I just don't like it.
In
Post #231, he dissects Anen's reads list, but doesn't touch the read on Tammy.
In
Post #336, he singles out a line of Neil's post, where it appears that Neil wasn't reading Tammy's posts.
Tammy doesn't mention tman too much, but does question him in
Post #240 about why he dissected Anen's list, and then has this about him in her reads list in
Post #438:
↑ Tammy wrote:Tman's pointing out that I had called myself town several times does not in any way shape or form demonstrate someone who is reading the game and is pointing out motivations. It's a null tell. It's also something that scum can very easily do to look like they're scum hunting. Oh she called herself town too many times, that's scummy. And for Neil to be all "oh I didn't know if anyone would notice it" I mean what? Town and scum have come after me for calling myself town before. It's never stopped me from calling myself town! (What I think makes him look town from the affair is that it looks to me like Rack said this was my scum meta, not long after that Tman pulled up posts where I'm referring to myself being town and says it looks like a joke but do I do it often. Considering that was the most of what I did do, it makes sense that if someone says hey she's scum by meta, he'd go looking. It looks like he took Tman's accusation seriously and went looking for what could make me scum. That's something that I'd expect more from town trying to figure out the game than from scum who would know that Rack was lying.)
None of this is solid evidence, but it's what's pointing me in the direction of believe tman could have been responsible for Tammy's death.
