Mini 1608--Mafia on the Air(Fin)

[Anatole Kuragin]

I don't know if choosing our lynches based on a list sorted from least to most charming is going to do a lot for the town, but I don't know enough about mafia to really refute the plan.

[5-Off]

Nashville, you made 5 posts in the span of 9 minutes not knowing what Tammy was going to say was her reason for voting you. It looks to me like you are covering yourself. If you're town, why do you care about one, emotional vote?

[Baboon Pride]

Alternatively, I could just move Csareo down a tier, since Ree is pretty much just basically null and Csareo is still lean scum, but I can probably replace those two with Trouble/AK/Ikabeast tier

[5-Off]

Gossamer
Nashville
Cutty
5-off
Lissa

Fonz
Bee

Ree
Csareo

F-16
AK
Ika

lets start here.

F-16 is a Gossamer head.

[Baboon Pride]

yeah, that's supposed to be trouble. It's early

[Anatole Kuragin]

I think the way Csareo so cluelessly and recklessly went about his role/claim kinda precludes him from being scum. There's no motivation to do that publicly when it can be done in the scum topic.

[Baboon Pride]

Gossamer
Lissa
Cutty

Fonz
ika
Bee

5-off
Ree

Csareo
Nashville
AK
FT

No, let's start here.

-Ceph

[Baboon Pride]

In anycase, I think the last tier defintely has scum in it, and I am pretty sure that it has all the scum in that tier, so I would prefer to have a lynch within those three people.

The only thing that bothers me, really is how little sense FT and Ikabeast actually work together as partners based off in thread interactions is somewhat unlikely. I also feel like he was using the neighborhood thing and the duel between me and trouble to maybe lynch through the neighborhood while ignoring the fact that there could have actually been a lurking member, despite it being said several times

pedit: nuuuuuuuu

[Baboon Pride]

also, gambit, and means to gain town-cred is possible.

[Nashville Dreams]

Nashville, you made 5 posts in the span of 9 minutes not knowing what Tammy was going to say was her reason for voting you. It looks to me like you are covering yourself. If you're town, why do you care about one, emotional vote?

Yeah no, not all of them were directed at Tammy actually. Two were to AK, one was me expanding on something because I forgot to complete my thought. I had just woken up from my sleep.

Surprising not everything in this game revolves around Tammy!

~M

Mara how is 5off a town read...?

[Anatole Kuragin]

Yo Nash Bridges, you still haven't responded to my questions about my super scummy AtE and flailing you saw.

[Baboon Pride]

somethingsomething role PM somethingsomething genuine something posts in game

[Baboon Pride]

Eg: not entirely willing to explain my town-reads, especially those already explained

from what it looks like, though our block currently excludes you and 5-off. I'll try and get that fixed, though.

[FourTrouble]

us
FT
Lissa
5-off (who is the one with the info)

Let me clear something up about this info:
5-Off said it was labelled as "rumors" that there was a "double agent." It wasn't a flat-out "there is definitely a scum intern."
And there is certainly still the possibility that he was gambiting.

Rereading to try and get better reads and see what else I need to respond to.

This is the post that gave me a scum vibe originally - I saw that and said "wow, if there's a scum intern this is probably her." Then I read Baboon, thought Baboon looked scummy too, then Lissa inexplicably has a townread on Baboon (though several people seem to now, so that doesn't mean a whole lot) and makes some really weak points to justify her RVS vote on 4t (basically just summarizing his posts - for example, her analysis for one of his posts saying Baboon doesn't seem town motivated is "scumreads baboon" as if that alone means anything to his alignment). She feels like she's going through the motions - townreading vocal players, scumreading easy targets, and just posting in a way that comes across as artificial and careful to me.

I don't see what's scummy about the post you quoted. Where are you now? Do you agree Lissa is town based on 919?

[Nashville Dreams]

Yo Nash Bridges, you still haven't responded to my questions about my super scummy AtE and flailing you saw.

I thought I did. You gained two votes on you and then you super soft claim and you are like I want a night to live. Like there's no town motivation to do that. None. None what's so ever. It felt like scum flailing to me.

~M

[Baboon Pride]

Yo Nash Bridges, you still haven't responded to my questions about my super scummy AtE and flailing you saw.

I thought I did. You gained two votes on you and then you super soft claim and you are like I want a night to live. Like there's no town motivation to do that. None. None what's so ever. It felt like scum flailing to me.

~M

Hint: that's because it is.

[Baboon Pride]

^-Ceph

[Nashville Dreams]

To be fair I don't have any willingness to be in a block that's not willing to work with me. It's not fair plus I'm too confident on my non town reads and before that's sorted I don't want to be in a block because go forbid I'm wrong again (like I was in xmen) I rather not let it come bite me in the ass.

~M

[Nashville Dreams]

Fuck I'm not too confident*

[Anatole Kuragin]

Yo Nash Bridges, you still haven't responded to my questions about my super scummy AtE and flailing you saw.

I thought I did. You gained two votes on you and then you super soft claim and you are like I want a night to live. Like there's no town motivation to do that. None. None what's so ever. It felt like scum flailing to me.

~M

What part of my posting uses any appeal to emotion, and for flailing, why is the tone consistent with the rest of my posts?

You're being dense if you can't imagine any scenario where there is no town motivation to "soft claim." Soft claim in this situation meaning being intentionally vague to avoid implicating other towns and giving away my own.

[Anatole Kuragin]

town roles*

[Baboon Pride]

VOTE: AK

from what it looks like, ATM though, the two people who are most likely to get lynched is Trouble and AK, though I would much rather have trouble lynched over AK. soft PR seems legit, and if anything, we could just lynch him tomorrow. Trouble on the other hand, is just...

[Baboon Pride]

To be fair I don't have any willingness to be in a block that's not willing to work with me. It's not fair plus I'm too confident on my non town reads and before that's sorted I don't want to be in a block because go forbid I'm wrong again (like I was in xmen) I rather not let it come bite me in the ass.

~M

the only person who would matter is me. And Ceph, but mostly me. I am willing to work with you, figure out where you stand, and find a compromise that fits with all members

[Nashville Dreams]

I'm not even sure why you have me as a town read. You are usually paranoid of me before throwing me into the town read list. Unless I'm wrong and you found something you can read me with without having to go paranoid.

@Ak:

This is going to be fruitless to explain to you. Obv you won't see what I'm seeing because you have to argue that I'm wrong. A soft claim is one, but why was the OTT 'I need a night to live' needed? It wasn't.

Scum flailing.

~M

[Anatole Kuragin]

us
FT
Lissa
5-off (who is the one with the info)

Let me clear something up about this info:
5-Off said it was labelled as "rumors" that there was a "double agent." It wasn't a flat-out "there is definitely a scum intern."
And there is certainly still the possibility that he was gambiting.

Rereading to try and get better reads and see what else I need to respond to.

This is the post that gave me a scum vibe originally - I saw that and said "wow, if there's a scum intern this is probably her." Then I read Baboon, thought Baboon looked scummy too, then Lissa inexplicably has a townread on Baboon (though several people seem to now, so that doesn't mean a whole lot) and makes some really weak points to justify her RVS vote on 4t (basically just summarizing his posts - for example, her analysis for one of his posts saying Baboon doesn't seem town motivated is "scumreads baboon" as if that alone means anything to his alignment). She feels like she's going through the motions - townreading vocal players, scumreading easy targets, and just posting in a way that comes across as artificial and careful to me.

I don't see what's scummy about the post you quoted. Where are you now? Do you agree Lissa is town based on 919?

I don't see how 919 is indicative of any alignment, I guess I'm missing something?

Where I am now - I'm pretty sure gundam wings is town and I want to think fonz is. I'd vote basically anyone but them, cutty, or csareo tbh.