Reads list as promised, later than I planned:
Agar
- Early and consistent town read. He's been pressuring people for explanations and motives, as well as consistent voting patterns. His tunneling of late has been offputting, but it's probably just me since that's his current target.
Anen
- Town read. Had a pretty weak D1, but was mostly a nulltell with a few scummy posts. D2 has been much stronger, with actual reasons and content in his posts.
BPC
- Currently leaning town on BPC, but will go through the slot. Riabi didn't really have enough content to go off of before his replace out, so was a null tell at the time. Oso's entrance was a bit odd, but I can't say I think it was scummy. IMO it would have been much scummier to come in and hammer off the bat, regardless of the flip. He then does get involved, and gives some pretty detailed answers and reasons to his posts. BPC came in with a substantial reads list pretty much off the bat, then some fluff interlaced with some more content.
DV
- Scum McScumfin. Please see my posts at
Post #618 and
Post #644 for my DV reads, and
Post #513 for where I read Elias as scum right after the replace.
implosion
- Scum. Was going to put reasons here, but ended up too long, so will do so in another post.
Mala
- Null. There's been a lot of joking/fluff mixed in with some thought. Not really getting a scum read at all, but not really a town read either.
ns
- Null, leaning scum on the slot, though I want to hear more from ns. I know I'm in the minority for this one, but there was just something about tman's posts I didn't like.
phok
- Null. Had a weird intro with the whole Flames/Tammy bit and has little content to speak of, but nothing that reeks of scumminess to me.
sthar
- Who? I'm leaning town on the slot, only because I started getting a town read on Rack D1. Grandi gave us nothing to speak of, and we've heard nothing of consequence from sthar.
ZZZX
- Leaning scum on the slot. chaos provided very little content, very weak arguments for the content he did provide, and two reads lists that were almost entirely inverse of each other with no reasonings for most of either.
My current scum pool is {DV, implosion, ns, ZZZX}. The first two are my strongest reads, and subsequent posting from the latter two will solidify my stance on those slots.
