Page 10, mara's reacction, in some cases relayed by Ceph, to four trouble picking up stuff she said in the neighborhood and stating it like it's his idea, this feels like town Mara.
246
↑ Baboon Pride wrote:almost guaranteed to have scum in the 1 of 4, or, in my perspective, 1 of 3 FT being the most likely of the three. Aside the fact, both Lissa and 5-off have been newb-town, mostly from the neighborhood and Lissa's in thread content has been, as well. As far as "gambit" goes, it's unlikely to come from newb-scum.
pedit: yeah, mostly. What about FT do you not get, and what has he even done that's town?
Mara I don't get why you're calling 5-off newbtown. I thought he had offsite experience and four trouble and f-16 discussed that he gambits there.
Post
336 by Anatole doesn't jibe all that well with my thoughts reaching this point in the game. Based on the game, I have Tammy and Baboon town and Lissa null. I also think the way he takes four trouble's side immediately in the Mara/FT stuff looks bad. I think there's some validity to the points she brings up about FT. The conclusion is in doubt.
FT's comment that he's engaging F-16 as a means of reading F-16's alignment is of note, given Tammy has been towning all over the thread at that point. Anatole's comment that Lissa's (rvs?) vote on FT being sticky is a good catch, though.
This is what I hate about neighborhoods - the he said she said in the game thread - and the fact that some players are developing reads and cases based on stuff the rest of the players can't see or evaluate.
I'll just go ahead and ask if there has been anything today that has looked like a non-neighborhood player was aware of comments made in the neighborhood that weren't disclosed in the game thread?
Fonz'
341 is mostly good, but there's something formulaic about it that troubles me a little.
344 is also good.
Anatole's
347 has a strong "thinking what I'm thinking when I'm thinking it" feel. At this point in my catch up, it's something I've been wondering about the neighborhood.
Anatole's
361 gives me slight whiteknighting vibes.
368 and
369 posted in the same minute. Not sure it's relevant but the "My vote wasn't random"/"His vote was random" could be scumbuddies steppeing on each other, but I kinda doubt it (doubt both are scum - one at most).
376 I kinda don't like anatole's opaqueness here, but I know I do this sometimes to draw out other players' thoughts and reactions. "not necessarily" though, that sounds kinda hedgy. Post
380 - I like this one, and overall I like how he and Mara have interacted about her FT read.
393 this is a pretty good sum up of where I stand regarding FT.
On page 17, with some 5-off posts at the top, it occurs to me that I can't remember much he's done besides state a few times that "it wasn't a gambit". I know there was other stuff but it didn't stick with me at all. hmm. A couple of times I've wanted to write "he's pushing tangential stuff" but I'm not really sure that's accurate. It's just that he blew up the neighborhood apparently, but it doesn't look like he's put much into using what transpired to develop reads. And yet, I like
401, and I wonder if I've glossed over earlier posts that had similarly good observations. Need to review.
Oh and 5-off confirms level of experience. Still want to know why Mara had that impression.
426 made me laugh. So did
427.
449 is p much the opposite of my reaction to MaraCeph.
451 is so
nice
. I don't like nice in mafia. :/
457 I agree with bork's thoughts at this time. If he hadn't already been his town self as much as he did, this post would probably have sealed it.
This puts me at the bottom of page 20.
