757 really curious about where this goes.
774 suggests a pretty long term disconnect from the game. Whether there is scum in the PT or not, I think scum would be pretty focused on what's going on there.
I could do some major wifom but I want to take it at face value
674 Tammy this feels to me like you're positing a Cabd-level of ballsy gambiting scum in 5-off-scum here. Fair assessment?
Page 33 and here's the Csareo claim stuff. He's incredibly awkward with this and doesn't seem to understand how this could have been more useful to use later in the game. I don't like it. But, his slot was all but forgotten at this point. What would be the scum motivation in claiming at this point?
Csareo how did you go about choosing your 4 players?
↑ Csareo wrote: ↑ The Fonz wrote:
Terrible idea: it's not going to give away alignment to town, because that's game-breaking, but what it might do is give away power/non-power to scum.
I've played games where town won solely on flavor.
Sounds like poor game design.
843,
845 lolled.
The Ceph-posting on page 35 feels pretty town to me. I've been thinking Mara is town since early on and ceph hadn't really done anything to vastly add to or subtract from that. I like these posts.
↑ Baboon Pride wrote: ↑ Nashville Dreams wrote:I've searched the world and I know now,
It ain't right if you ain't lost your mind
Yeah, I don't want easy, I want crazy
Are you with me baby? Let's be crazy
which head do you think is sane?
Hayden
You.
On the other hand, not *that* sane.
-Ceph
886 this reads list pretty much agrees with my thoughts atm, though I'm backing off malatitus for now, and I'm not scumreading FT. but I feel like my reads are maybe too surface-level still, so it worries me a little that someone who had been more or less in the moment in this game didn't have a single read here that challenged my view of the game or surprised me. Then again, these reads feel consensusy so maybe it's a town-converging thing.
887 the observation about coming from a land of terrible mods resonates.
Page 36 and 37 - the working through things interactions between tammy and mala do allay some of my concerns.
↑ Baboon Pride wrote: ↑ Nashville Dreams wrote:I thought it was quoted already. I'm pretty sure she did quote it.
She's trying to crumb to ika too. We aren't taunting anyone.
~M is for Mala. (btw, I think you probably deff know that from 907, but now that knowledge is public)
Guess was off.
I thought you were nacho.
This solidifies you to top tier read.
That said, explaining town-read takes... effort, probably won't try to here, as I spent at least 30 minutes trying to explain it to ceph via skype and he still can't get a clear idea of the read.
I don't even
The interaction between Cutty and Anatole that starts in
942 is troubling. Anatole initiates the snarkiness and escalates it and the overall aggressiveness here looks out of place. Major scum vibe here.
957 bork I'm curious if this ever changed.
958 catches my eye given Anatole's complaints about hydras metaing each other. Trying to confirm and make sense of some of it?
963 buddying?
966 - I like this post. And
977
976 - I like seeing Mala push back on 963. Given the reaction to Tammy's sarcasm when titus thought it was buddying, I wanted to see something from them about Anatole's post here.
Page 40 is pretty frustrating to read. Evidently something about 5-off's first avatar caused a bunch of townreads, but I have no idea what the avatar was.
)
