Mini Theme 1616: Guardians of the Galaxy [STOPPED]

[SMP]

I'm being snippy?

You said Rocket is confirmed town if Math flips scum.

Who's Rocket?

Rocket Raccoon. Whoever is Rocket should be neighbors with Groot according to GreyICE's role.

Do you have any reads?

I agree with Grey, one of the players with very few posts are scum. kcdaspot is leading the group for me just based on his pop in quick vote on LLD, but nothing too concrete.

pedit - I'm going to let the thread settle down a bit before continuing too much more.

[Aronis]

It says fucking nothing about modkills for replacements. It says players who don't meet the activity requirement will be modkilled. Fuck this.

The implementation of the rule is to eliminate the need for replacements. I fail to see the difference in replacing out vs. forced replacement. Another modkill incoming.

[Aronis]

xRECKONERx, AKA Yondu Udonta - Leader of the Ravagers, 1-shot Bus Driver turned survivor has been modkilled.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Sigh.

[Primate]

It says fucking nothing about modkills for replacements. It says players who don't meet the activity requirement will be modkilled. Fuck this.

The implementation of the rule is to eliminate the need for replacements. I fail to see the difference in replacing out vs. forced replacement. Another modkill incoming.

It's fine if they knew that was going to happen and they were going to be modkilled when they made the decision. Otherwise you're dicking them over. I personally don't really care, this game could still be fun despite it, though I have downgraded it in my personal estimation as not really counting as a proper mafia game.

Anyway, I'm going to do to a bit of a reread with this in mind, though I don't think anything really changes with these reveals.

[Primate]

I guess we should probably lynch a scum then.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

There are so many players who aren't posting enough.

Scum is lurking in there somewhere.

[Primate]

Hilariously there are benefits now to a D1 NL, not that I'd recommend it. What a mess.

@BBT: Good on your lad jagielka. Also yeah, but which one? If you pick one based on inevitable shaky evidence, I'll try and do the same.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Well, we have Heph, Flames, kcda and SMP.

I just don't think there is enough from any of them to see which of them is scum.

[Primate]

I'd lump abr in there too before kcda and SMP. Which is half the game assuming you count those latter two.

Heph and flames are the most obvious "need to be giving reads"ers.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Yeah, thought I missed one.

[Primate]

Also, DukeC, who I missed, who hasn't even posted yet and will presumably be modkilled/replaced if he doesn't post in the next few hours.

I would also add I think SMP hasn't been especially inactive (he's probably said more of substance than I have).

[BlueBloodedToffee]

DukeC will get replaced because he hasn't posted.

So many inactive players.

Is that 6 now?

[Primate]

Yup.

So.

WRT scum, Mathdino and BBT *feel* town atm. smp *feel*s scummy and I dunno about KCD and BoL. Is what I'm currently thinking.

[The Burgers of Llamarble]

Are you fucking kidding me

[The Burgers of Llamarble]

DukeC will get replaced because he hasn't posted.

No, he'll get modkilled

[BlueBloodedToffee]

GreyICE and Lady Lambdadelta have requested replacement. Due to rule 3.7, a player who has posted may not be replaced/replace out. So they will be modkilled.

Duke hasn't posted. That should be a replacement.

[Primate]

On the flipside, if we dominate this game and get all the scums in a row now we'd probably be in with a shout for a scummy.

[The Burgers of Llamarble]

It says fucking nothing about modkills for replacements. It says players who don't meet the activity requirement will be modkilled. Fuck this.

The implementation of the rule is to eliminate the need for replacements. I fail to see the difference in replacing out vs. forced replacement. Another modkill incoming.

Except the rule

was not in the ruleset as it was presented to the players

.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I cba arguing about it.

[The Burgers of Llamarble]

GreyICE and Lady Lambdadelta have requested replacement. Due to rule 3.7, a player who has posted may not be replaced/replace out. So they will be modkilled.

Duke hasn't posted. That should be a replacement.

Read Rule 3.7. Also read post 276.

[The Burgers of Llamarble]

Could you at least put what their roles and alignments used to be in the OP?

[Primate]

TBF, if the mod was going to make up a new rule (like he did), he wouldn't include the caveat for non-posters (knowing exactly who that would relate to) unless he was going to replace DukeC.

[The Burgers of Llamarble]

I cba arguing about it.

2 or 3 dead townies for bullshit reasons doesn't bother you? wtf

[The Burgers of Llamarble]

TBF, if the mod was going to make up a new rule (like he did), he wouldn't include the caveat for non-posters (knowing exactly who that would relate to) unless he was going to replace DukeC.

276 says he wants no replacements whatsoever.