Mathdino, why would it be a townslip for GreyICE to make a mistake with the playerlist?
I like Mastin's first post. Those questions could be very helpful. Buuuut. Wouldn't Mathdino's so called townslip just be slipping that he was town in the last game? Or even scum who didn't get a chance to talk pregame? I don't think it's telling for this game.
Riabi's post about being scum the first time looks town
because of all of the details he gives
. However, it's easy to post for town points and change the way he crumbs. So it's weak town points. UPDATE: Ok, so the details were for the game that never happened. That diminishes this much more than the chance that he wanted town points diminished it. Maybe to the point of not even being a town tell anymore.
Scum vibes from Dragonspawn. GreyICE seems to have seen why, although he may not see it as being intentional. I do. lol 2birds too. And Mathdino. And Fink is finally the one to nail it.
Mathdino, why do you think the above about dragonspawn comes from town?
GreyICE, while I personally find everything in your post 26 to be obvious, others may not, And they may be scum. Why are you sharing optimal scum strategy?
Fink, you asked how often I'll check in. I'll try to make an appearance every two days at most. The amount of content I can post depends on the pace of the game.
Interested to see if Teen has reasons why Grey is scum. I'm sure it's been asked already, so consider this me noting it.
Mathdino, (post 50) telling scum who to shoot isn't so bad here because it benefits both town and scum for scum to try to shoot the other scum team.
Astinus (post 51), have you figured out dragon's stuff yet? If not, let me know when you do. And if GreyICE wanted to tell his partner how to play, why not make a post in their QT/PT? As for my V/LA, why would I lie in all of my other games and stop posting in discussion threads just to strategically lurk as scum here for the first time in roughly 300 games? Doesn't that seem like a stretch?
Mathdino (post 76), I actually think all of those possibilities exist. What do you think of his play outside of this tell? Do you see town thinking in his posts? I don't.
Fink's post 84 looks genuine and transparent. Town unless he is very confident in his scum play.
Astinus wrote:I self-voted because I had read in the wiki that it might be helpful
^This is why the wiki sucks.
Mastin, I think I know what you are trying to say about the Gullie wagon. I don't see a case. It seems like he's being voted for being a non-entity. Why not vote me in that case? Or anyone else who isn't active? However, the players on the wagon aren't overly scummy. It just seems like everyone is misguided. But in a game with two teams, most any mislynch will probably be more misguided than with ill intent. It's interesting to note the wagon, but I don't see anything specific I can pick out of it without more development.
Huh. Wanted to townread Fink until his Gullie vote.
So, right now my scum reads are weak at best, but:
Vote Dragonspawn
