Mini 1626: Duck Tales Mafia (Game Over)

[Shiny Hydreigon]

why are you criticizing my ways before seeing if they bring results? will i still be useless when bulba flips scum?

R~

[DOMO]

I'd assume you got lucky.

[Shiny Hydreigon]

you think that i really have no reasons and im just putting random names into random piles?

R~

[DOMO]

Feels like it. I don't see where your confidence comes from, that's for sure.

[DOMO]

Your ISO is so hard to read. Despite you making a lot of posts using very few words, it's tough to get any kind of context because you don't quote people. This immediately makes you more anti-town than average. You admit yourself that you don't make cases, yet you're happy to accuse people of not scumhunting, and you expect people to sheep you. Tell me why we shouldn't lynch you?

[Shiny Hydreigon]

alright.

some homework if you're up to it:

Here are two ISOs of two Bulba games:

Chain of Command

Playing Card

Read just a few D1 posts from each, and without spoiling yourself, tell me what you think Bulba is in each game.

R~

[DOMO]

I'll have a look in an hour or two, I'm distracted now. I'll admit my initial reaction is to smile. I hope you've got something. I hope I'm gonna look really stupid.

[Shiny Hydreigon]

dont hope too much, i dont have anything. im just curious how accurate you will be

R~

[ArcAngel9]

Not sure if anyone have seen this before. But this is a must watch video. 21st century kids react to DuckTales

[Paschendale]

In my experience, it's most often an accusation to discredit someone who is pointing out very obvious flaws in a person's case. "White knighting" someone usually translates to "pointing out why you're wrong" about that person.

because obviously thats what happened here.

defend your buddy moar

I'm not defending anyone. I'm condemning you. Stop trying to misrep my intentions.

no, because hes scum. you just cant see it cuz you dont know how to see it

And we should just believe you... why?

and then after he has flipped scum you have these wonderful reactions to my push from Pasche and Pine to tell you who the buddies are

Yes, we should lynch the town players who call out bad cases. That's a great way to win.

[Shiny Hydreigon]

i love how you emphasize "town" players there.

each time you post you obvscum even more

R~

[DOMO]

So let's have a look at bulba this game and compare to the two linked above. Note that I have not spoiled bulb's role in either of the linked games, and won't until I'm done.

Ok there's a distinct difference between the two games through the opening stages, and that's his activity. I'm assuming this is what you're getting at shiny. Chain of Command, he's driving the conversation enthusiastically from the off. Playing Card, he makes his intro post then disappears. I'm gonna say based on scanning his ISO in these games that he's town in CoC, while PC he's scum, and if that's the case then my lean on him this game might shift in the direction of scummy.

[DOMO]

ding ding

[DOMO]

VOTE: bulba

[DOMO]

You've won my vote shiny. Well done.

[Shiny Hydreigon]

lolwat i really hadnt even noticed that

R~

[DOMO]

Well why do you think he's scum?

[Shiny Hydreigon]

dunno if your point applies but its interesting. ive played one more game with bulba-scum, ill go see if he was like that there too

R~

[DOMO]

It's the enthusiasm that stands out as the dinstinct difference. This game, he waits until last to post, makes a couple of posts, then he's gone while others drive the conversation. It's similar in PC. But CoC he's much more involved through the inital stages.

[Shiny Hydreigon]

but i dont think it does. the fact he was enthusiastic in one game does not mean that it defines his town game. play can depend on factors like mood and playerlist, after all.

the reason i gave you the games was because i expected youd struggle telling what he is in each game. he makes a lot of scummy looking posts as town and a lot of town looking posts as scum. so i wanted to prove my point that the fact you think one or more posts were town looking here means nothing for him.

but it amazes me you got them both correct and even found something that might be a tell for him

R~

[DOMO]

Got the both correct based on a glance through his first 30 posts or whatever. Maybe I got lucky. If he's scum here though then for sure that's a tell for him, and for sure he'll rectify it after this game.

[Shiny Hydreigon]

Push on Bulba feels off. I don't see much scumminess from Bulba, much less what Hydreigon is showing

I'm not seeing it. Disagreeing with you doesn't make someone scum. Now, if you have a point to make or a case on Bulba, please share it. Otherwise, if you're not going to do something constructive, just shut up and sheep the players who are.

Noting the two reactions to my Bulba push that I think are telling again. If Bulba is scum like he should, I feel at least one of those is scum with him. Pasche more likely than Pine, because Pine's post came right after my exchange with Bulba and I'm not sure if scum would dare to do that before seeing how town takes it: if town agreed, then Pine would look bad for doing this. Paschendale on the other hand is confident in doing it knowing that Pine has stated this and Kitty has agreed.

R~

[Bulbazak]

I really don't like this Kitty wagon.

Got a better one in mind?

I could go for one on you, TW, or Mastin.

note; when bulba flips scum, look at all those attempts to discredit my push on him

R~

How in the world am I discrediting you?

@Mastin: Remind me why Romi is scum again.

Because he is?

Like, his posting's not only faked but also not original.

Examples please.

note; when bulba flips scum, look at all those attempts to discredit my push on him

Definitely in my mind as well.

Seeing as how you were scum in Chain of Command,the other game where Wisdom ruthlessly tunneled me, this statement definitely stands out. Town Mastin should know better than to say this knowing that I seem to be perpetually on Wisdom's tunnel list. This looks more like you fanning the flames.

you dont make sense, mastin. Romi is town

Pretty sure Romi isn't.

I think that we'll overall work together well in spite of this disagreement, though.

Yeah, you're scum. That's some hardcore buddying.

Feel free to, expect me to scumread you for it if you're using it as an excuse to not scumhunt and/or discredit our opinions

~R

I don't think you know what the word discredit means.

It's the enthusiasm that stands out as the dinstinct difference. This game, he waits until last to post, makes a couple of posts, then he's gone while others drive the conversation. It's similar in PC. But CoC he's much more involved through the inital stages.

In Playing Card, I made an RVS vote shortly before leaving to see a movie. When I came back, I had to fight off a wagon. In Chain of Command, I had access from the very beginning that allowed for those early interactions. As for this game, I posted about 4 hours after the game started, and that was because I was spending some time with family and that was the earliest time I could read the game. My activity in any game is related to availability, not alignment. If you want to double check, I have a whole wiki full of past games that you can look through.

Unvote

Vote Mastin2

[Total Wreck]

VOTE: Bulbazak

Out of his three scum reads, he picks the one last likely to actually get a wagon on D1.

That and other stuff.

[Total Wreck]

Last = least