Mini 1624: Joss Whedon Mafia: The Musical (Game Over)

[serrapaladin]

So I'm not sure if this will make any sense, but I have a problem with ffery trying to frame other people's reads on her in the specific context of the cohesiveness of her reads and the quality of her logic.

Hi anka.

[serrapaladin]

VOTE: antihero

[Ankamius]

I'd like to say Riddleton is town, but he fooled me last time I played with him.

I got a townread on LMP though, not actually sure where the wagon came from.

(Up to middle of page 6)

[Ankamius]

Townread on Riddleton vanished on page 8.

[Ankamius]

I suspect way too many people this game. Y'all should act more town-like.

So anyway, current scumread Bassists and anatole. MoC is null, and everyone else is town. I'll put cases on my scumreads now.

Am I dreaming this?

[Murder of Crows]

So I'm not sure if this will make any sense, but I have a problem with ffery trying to frame other people's reads on her in the specific context of the cohesiveness of her reads and the quality of her logic.

Hi anka.

I don't know what this means. I'd respond if I did.

[Ankamius]

I'm at the bottom of page 14 and I'm starting to not really get anything useful from these pages. Is there anything in particular after that that's useful?

[istott]

Hey guys, sorry I haven't said anything recently, I've been very busy. I'm going to make a post addressing the stuff that's happened.

[istott]

You're 60-40 town, but I'm not feeling you have a presence in this game. It might be an effect of your hydra partner, or the player list, but that's the vibe I get. I feel like your lynch is the most likely and part of me is getting the same sort of general feeling in the air as chef mafia.

I agree. I dont see Murder as scum, but unfortunately, I think their lynch is the most likely.

Cabd, it doesn't look like you're starting day 2 with a townread from conftown-ffery.

Please clarify this. I didnt understand XD

Istott

This is the only read where I think I may seriously disagree with AP, which is one reason I've badgered Cabd for a read here. His posts give me newb vibes, or at least new to forum mafia vibes. He seems to be trying to be transparent in a way that reminds me a little of Iece-town and maybe Deas-town. Anyway, I see why the istott appeal to serra bothers AP, and I may be discounting it too much as something I'm not surprised to see from a relatively new player.

Leaning town.

Who are Iece and Deas? I am new to Forum mafia. When you talk about my transparency, what are you referring to?

Istott is giving me feels like early lynx, as rough as that memory is. The newness feels calculated in a way I can't quite place.

What? Whos lynx? Youre saying you think I'm not as new as I seem?

Grey/serra/ist, can you guys explain the boonskies wagon?

I voted boon because of how he worded his post. Once I realised I had incorrectly inferred, I unvoted.

If Istott has any sort of real experience and awareness of his play, he may be very hard to read indeed. I'm still leaning town, but need further consideration.

Whaa? Why is everyone finding me hard to read? What specific part of my play are you referring to?

Ist feels off around the time Boon comes back. Not really sure why. I mean, maybe it's a little beetlejuicy and a littly appeasey. I dunno. My gut really doesn't like it though.

Please clarify who your'e referring to XD

If anyone has any questions, fire away.

[Bulbazak]

Does no one read the rules regarding confirmation and replace ins?! I don't like ghosts in my game people!

And Ankamius replaces HypotheticalBassists. Deadline is extended 72 hours. Enjoy your holiday.

I'm going to be busy for the rest of the night on another project. Vote count before I go to bed.

[Bulbazak]

As the day drew to a close, they each reflected on what they had to be thankful for. Some of them had suffered losses, yes, but they had all been granted incredible gifts. Dawn, for example, had been granted the gift of life, a form of consciousness and free will that she never had as a ball of energy. There was not much time for reflection, however. They still had a murderer to catch.

Vote Count

Medea the Alien (0):
Goblin (1): Antihero
Antihero (1): Serrapaladin
Anatole Kuragin (0):
GreyICE (0):
Egg (0):
Serrapaladin (0):
Ankamius (2): Mikuru, Egg
Boonskiies (1): GreyICE
Istott (1): Boonskiies
Murder of Crows (3): Anatole Kuragin, Goblin, Yoncé
Mikuru (0):
Yoncé (0):

Not Voting (4): Medea the Alien, Istott, Ankamius, Murder of Crows

It is day 1. With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day ends on Monday, December 1 at 1:15pm EST. Countdown: (expired on 2014-12-01 13:15:00).

[Murder of Crows]

AP also is feeling less critical of Anti right now than I do, so the consensus there also softens.

Actually I just woke up (yes its 4:00am, my sleep schedule is wack) and was considering asking if you wanted to wagon there right now. After further consideration of his ISO, I wouldn't really be opposed to just voting him Today.

[Murder of Crows]

And why does Arc's replace out confirm that slot?

Its just the way she replaced out. Look at the emotional implications behind everything she did. If she was scum, she was blatantly using emotions and replacing out to look town on her way out, which is sort of low and I ultimately doubt she would do. At the least, its unlikely. What makes a lot more sense is that she was town, got pissed off that people couldn't see that, and then replaced out because she was so mad about that. I guess it helps to know AA9 a bit (not sure if you do), but everything in my intuition tells me this is most likely townrage.

[Murder of Crows]

You make a decent point. Ask Cabd about the game where I declared a scum player the towniest of towns for putting down a full, detailed summary of his thoughts about the game - reads as well as suggestions about where to go next - in NY165.

Was that my slot? Domo? Also way back in the day, Sharizah replaced out in the middle of a wall post (mykonian took her place) and mykonian got tons of towncred because of the effort and reads she put in IN HER REPLACE OUT POST. Mykonian and I endgamed Nero, Jason, and pidgey that game.

[Murder of Crows]

As for why I'm giving out reads, it's mainly so my replacement has a conftown thought process to hear

Was your reads/thoughts throughout the rest of the game NOT something your replacement would benefit from reading? I mean why does it matter that you do it now?

The question on the table is whether GreyICE rages like this as scum.

I vaguely recall MindReader Mafia which was a mini theme in the days before uberninja got banned. I'd have to read it again, but GI was scum there. Basically I don't see his emotions in this game as alignment indicative either way. The main reason I'm leaning town on him is the same thing you mentioned - that he expressed opinions that resonated with how I felt at a couple points.

I think I would be most comfortable with an antihero or boon lynch today, thoughts?

I could probably do either of these TBH.

Can we murder crows someone already?

And I feel like yours (and just about everyone's) vote/push on me is lazy and limp. No fire. No ah ha! Just an occasional drive by 'yep still scum' for the most part.

[istott]

Hey guys, just gotta let y'all know: I'm gonna be abit less active for the next week or so, as I have auditions for uni courses (music theatre auditions) in the next few days, so I have to spend more time on that. I'll try to keep up, but just know that Its not an alignment reason. For the next few days, I won't really be able to do much other than stay up to date, and comment on the especially important stuff. If you want me to do something, tell me.
Also, I'm switching to a new user, to prevent confusion (around how experienced I am.)
This new user is "eyestott"

[Murder of Crows]

Also, I'm switching to a new user, to prevent confusion (around how experienced I am.)
This new user is "eyestott"

Cheeky scumbutt.

[yoncé]

V/LA until Saturday.

[istott]

Also, I'm switching to a new user, to prevent confusion (around how experienced I am.)
This new user is "eyestott"

Cheeky scumbutt.

Whaaa?

[Ankamius]

Does no one read the rules regarding confirmation and replace ins?! I don't like ghosts in my game people!

And Ankamius replaces HypotheticalBassists. Deadline is extended 72 hours. Enjoy your holiday.

I'm going to be busy for the rest of the night on another project. Vote count before I go to bed.

The ruleset didn't say anything except having to confirm your role PM before posting, which I did. :/

Fair enough, though. Sorry.

[Murder of Crows]

Sorry about that scum PM, Ank.

[Ankamius]

Sorry about that scum PM, Ank.

[Antihero]

VOTE: antihero

you have done nothing

but vote townies

all game

don't get pissy when someone calls you a shitty ic.

[Murder of Crows]

Since when are you town reading us? And you think boon is town? I described your iso as a graveyard to ffery on skype. Do you think your posts meet your own standards?

Also consider us tentatively voting ankamius. It's thanksgiving so hopefully we will talk after that.

[serrapaladin]

VOTE: antihero

you have done nothing

but

vote townies

all game

don't get pissy when someone calls you a shitty ic.

?