Open 583: JK9++ (Game Over!)

[beastcharizard]

Vote: beastcharizard

Kindly explain why you think this.

VOTE: Wickedestjr

Name too hard to spell and OMGUS.

[copper223]

VOTE: Killapen

@Wicked
BBT jumping on things is more likely to be town and Mastin starting with a pseudo "confirm post analysis" on what I thought were syncs on confirmation time and words used (I missed the ready reference in the PM tbf.) is consistent with my mental image of her as a town player.

[beastcharizard]

VOTE: copper223

I like this one better.

[vettrock]

VOTE: dodgy


for being a little dodgy...code for scummy.

[killapenwin]

I see we have all just descended into throwing out random votes with no explanation, I was just about to vote on dodgy and with the same reasoning but that damn vettrock beat me to it. Either that or he is playing Jedi mind tricks on me, which would be rather devious of him. I am watching you little green dwarf.

[Tean Samargo]

A haiku with love:

I don't like penguins.
Go back to Antarctica.

Vote: killapenwin

[killapenwin]

A haiku with truth:

Once upon a time,
Tean voted for a penguin,
due to being scum.

[beastcharizard]

Mine was a real vote. I don't get the purpose of the second part of copper's post. It looks like they are try harding.

[Tean Samargo]

Mine is a real vote now too. I'm not liking any of killapenwin's posts so far!
If there's anything you want to mention in it speak up, since Im a bit busy at the moment.

[Tean Samargo]

Ignore that last part, editing errors.

[Wickedestjr]

@beast - The lightheartedness of your first post, while perfectly appropriate, felt out of place for some reason.

Tean voted for a penguin,
due to being scum.

Do you actually think Tean is scum?

I don't get the purpose of the second part of copper's post. It looks like they are try harding.

Are you aware that I asked copper for his reasons? (because I personally thought his post was fine )

[vettrock]

A haiku with truth:

Once upon a time,
Tean voted for a penguin,
due to being scum.

If Tean is scum, why are you not voting him?

[beastcharizard]

@beast - The lightheartedness of your first post, while perfectly appropriate, felt out of place for some reason.

Tean voted for a penguin,
due to being scum.

Do you actually think Tean is scum?

I don't get the purpose of the second part of copper's post. It looks like they are try harding.

Are you aware that I asked copper for his reasons? (because I personally thought his post was fine )

I figured that was a joke post and didn't think anything of it. Everything before the game start post is not game relevant so I don't see why you are trying to use it as such. That is like saying someone is scum because they posted in the sign-up thread at a specific time of the day in a specific spot on the player list. The game hasn't even started and you are deciding who is scum in what seems to be a serious way.

VOTE: Wicked

Back to this.

[dodgy56]

VOTE: dodgy


for being a little dodgy...code for scummy.

yep you got me, im that dodgy new bloke

[mastin2]

Who lives in a Pinapple under the sea? Sponge Bob Square Pants! What does SpongeBob always say on the way to work?
I'm Ready! I'm Ready!
Award for best post in thread goes to...drum roll please........ME!

/red 5 standing by

Town.

ready

Is probably gonna be impossible to nail down for sure, but I did get a minor scumvibe.

VOTE: davesaz.
I told you I was serious.

[Aneninen]

A haiku with inanity

I've just rolled my dice
Pigeons picked up all of them
VOTE: BBT now

[eyestott]

this game will be interesting for me. ive played mafia on forums elsewhere but this will be my first game here. so forgive me if i dont really understand your meta.

Hey dodgy, you should probably get an avatar.

[eyestott]

I see we have all just descended into throwing out random votes with no explanation, I was just about to vote on dodgy and with the same reasoning but that damn vettrock beat me to it. Either that or he is playing Jedi mind tricks on me, which would be rather devious of him. I am watching you little green dwarf.

So youre criticizing people for giving a lack of explanation in RVS, then say you were just about to vote dodgy for the same reasoning someone else gave?
VOTE: Killapenwin.

[Wickedestjr]

I figured that was a joke post and didn't think anything of it. Everything before the game start post is not game relevant so I don't see why you are trying to use it as such. That is like saying someone is scum because they posted in the sign-up thread at a specific time of the day in a specific spot on the player list. The game hasn't even started and you are deciding who is scum in what seems to be a serious way.

I get impatient when trying to scum hunt early on. When a game first starts, my initial strategy is always either A. say something weird to provoke serious discussion or B. vote based on my initial gut feelings. I chose B this time. I never said nor implied that I had strong evidence for you being scum - I was just voting based on my initial gut feeling. YOU asked ME for my reasoning, so I gave you my page 2 logic, never having advertised better.

You acknowledge that it's too early for me to strongly suspect somebody yet you vote me for not having strong enough reasons. Why can't I start trying now? Several other players have started developing reads but I am the only one you have issue with, and I just happen to be the one voting you.

I'm liking my vote more now.

[Wickedestjr]

Self correction: you had issue with copper also. But he wasn't the only other person to try developing reads.

[dodgy56]

this game will be interesting for me. ive played mafia on forums elsewhere but this will be my first game here. so forgive me if i dont really understand your meta.

Hey dodgy, you should probably get an avatar.

Cool, cool cool cool

[eyestott]

I see we have all just descended into throwing out random votes with no explanation, I was just about to vote on dodgy and with the same reasoning but that damn vettrock beat me to it. Either that or he is playing Jedi mind tricks on me, which would be rather devious of him. I am watching you little green dwarf.

this game will be interesting for me. ive played mafia on forums elsewhere but this will be my first game here. so forgive me if i dont really understand your meta.

Hey dodgy, you should probably get an avatar.

Cool, cool cool cool

I love it.
How are you finding MS style compared to Playdip?

[dodgy56]

I figured that was a joke post and didn't think anything of it. Everything before the game start post is not game relevant so I don't see why you are trying to use it as such. That is like saying someone is scum because they posted in the sign-up thread at a specific time of the day in a specific spot on the player list. The game hasn't even started and you are deciding who is scum in what seems to be a serious way.

I get impatient when trying to scum hunt early on. When a game first starts, my initial strategy is always either A. say something weird to provoke serious discussion or B. vote based on my initial gut feelings. I chose B this time. I never said nor implied that I had strong evidence for you being scum - I was just voting based on my initial gut feeling. YOU asked ME for my reasoning, so I gave you my page 2 logic, never having advertised better.

You acknowledge that it's too early for me to strongly suspect somebody yet you vote me for not having strong enough reasons. Why can't I start trying now? Several other players have started developing reads but I am the only one you have issue with, and I just happen to be the one voting you.

I'm liking my vote more now.

i see where youre coming from but run me through why its scummy? being a hypocrite doesnt make someone scum. unfortunately in my experience townies do it too (often not on purpose)

[eyestott]

Disregard 1st quote.
By the way, dodgy:
at the top of each post it says ISO.
If you click that, you can read through all of that users posts.

[dodgy56]

Disregard 1st quote.
By the way, dodgy:
at the top of each post it says ISO.
If you click that, you can read through all of that users posts.

hard to say much about how im finding it so far. ill let you know after this game

thanks for the tip!