Mini 1637- Pokemon Generation I uPick (Game Over)

[Flames682]

That doesn't tell us anything.

[TierShift]

I'm sure all mons are equally likely to be PR's.
I still don'tsee reasons for flavourclaiming, though.

[Espeonage]

I'm sure all mons are equally likely to be PR's.
I still don'tsee reasons for flavourclaiming, though.

How about it's a reasonable assumption that the game is balanced and that my role is part of that equation and that if I end up just being a Tourist because of an uncooperative town that takes away from town's pool of resources.

[Espeonage]

Remember Nati ok'd the game. Like he would approve of a straight ability strength to pokemon strength.

[Egg]

I am a power role. I need to know even more than your flavour claim to even function. I am asking for much less than what I need here.

Pidgeot

Okay, let's say I claimed I'm Exeggutor (I'm not). What would you gain or infer from me saying that?

Rolefishing.

[Not_Mafia]

Okay I can understand your reasoning. But a 1 in 27 chance of you catching scum isn't exactly tantalising, we random lynch with better probably than that

[Not_Mafia]

Why so willing to flavourclaim Egg? Do you think we all should and why?

[Espeonage]

I'd like to try and get an ability through before lategame where I'm much much more useful.

I will be asking for what I need later.

[Flames682]

I am a power role. I need to know even more than your flavour claim to even function. I am asking for much less than what I need here.

Pidgeot

Okay, let's say I claimed I'm Exeggutor (I'm not). What would you gain or infer from me saying that?

Rolefishing.

Actually I'm asking how the hell it would benefit town.

[Egg]

Why so willing to flavourclaim Egg? Do you think we all should and why?

He's right that it probably doesn't hurt and I doubt he's lying about his role this early. I can't answer for everyone else.

Preview edit: i doubt he can answer that without claiming based on what he's said so far.

[Keybladewielder]

Watashi wa makeru wake niwa ikanai!

weeb

VOTE: keybladewielder

I hate anime. So calling me a weeb is extremely offensive.


It's a quote from the only Pokemon who can talk, Mewtwo.

funfact: pokemon in one of its most popular forms is an anime, scum
CHECKMATE

Funfact: I only play the fucking games, douchebag

CHECKMATE2

[Egg]

You don't seem to be playing THIS game

[Not_Mafia]

Espeonage considering the loaves of bread you've been dropping about being PR it doesn't seem like making lategame is a prority of yours.

Kbw do you have even an inkling of a read on a single user?

[Egg]

He'll be fine if there is a protective role. I have a feeling there is

[Espeonage]

He'll be fine if there is a protective role. I have a feeling there is

This. There is enough protection wifom that I could get either protected or not shot at because I am out as a power role and thus am a protection target.

[Not_Mafia]

There are at least dozen things that can completely mitigate that, it's just an almost irrational level of confidence for a high risk seemingly low reward situation

[Espeonage]

There are at least dozen things that can completely mitigate that, it's just an almost irrational level of confidence for a high risk seemingly low reward situation

[REDACTED]

I will be fine.

[TierShift]

Was gonna voice support for flavourclaim when I saw esp's super awkward 114.

[Not_Mafia]

Okay Espeonage is a strong townread, still not convinced to flavourclaim though

[Egg]

Not mafia, why is it high risk? Hell, why is it even low reward. Flavor doesn't necessarily show what kind of role I have and if someone has a role where it helps to know it, I'm cool with that. Like I said, I doubt he's lying at this stage of the game.

[Not_Mafia]

Not mafia, why is it high risk?

We don't know exactly how flavour interacts with roles. PRs etc...

Hell, why is it even low reward.

I go from my ability working 1 in 165 times to working 1 in 27 times.

Flavor doesn't necessarily show what kind of role I have and if someone has a role where it helps to know it, I'm cool with that. Like I said, I doubt he's lying at this stage of the game.

I'm not arguing with either of these things, but the "not necessarily" part is the the important part

[Egg]

Eh. No point discussing it. I've already claimed mine and I don't care if you claim yours and I don't want accidental tells about either of our roles.

[Bert]

not claiming only because i dont know what info is available to scum, so not taking that risk this early in the game. play the game out first, then do other things if needed

[Bert]

since the subject is how this game is a "Nati game," i will also say that in my Nati past game experiences, almost everyone had a "power" of some sort (whether nerfed or not, a high number of them looked useful or interesting on the surface).

that is what makes Nati games exciting

[Bert]

gonna head out now but

even listing your submissions in no particular order wouldn't give as much info as a pure flavor character or whateggver claim.

tl;dr i came home, and i saw that a person (espeonage) claimed PR and said he needed a flavor claim, and he also eggsplained why he claimed

that is the summary for myself to follow along with

youre welcome, loves <3