Mini 1630: Edgar Allan Poe uPick GAME OVER!

[CaskOfAmontillado]

Well you two outed and investigative for absolutely no reasons when you didn't need to.
Excellent work!

[Faster Than Light]

Put yourself in my shoes.
I just wasted my vig shot on someone who very clearly didn't die.

[Faster Than Light]

You weren't exactly the bastion of towniness either. I didn't think you'd get protected from a kill.
I still don't think you're town.
Boo's hop on the wagon is kinda totes suspect, so I'm taking a step back to think over this one.

You outed yourself. Remember that. Don't pin that on anyone but your own play.

-V

[BRantz]

Assuming you aren't lying, at least you are still alive? Getting upset that we both had a read on you and acted on it seems completely irrational though.

[copper223]

Let's leave all this to post game and focus on making the best out of the situation.

[CaskOfAmontillado]

You outed yourself. Remember that. Don't pin that on anyone but your own play.

No, I'm pinning it on you. Make no mistake.

[Faster Than Light]

Show me where I told you to claim.
You're being irrational.
You claimed at 2 votes deep.
I hadn't even revealed the interaction that caused me to believe you were scum (on top of your play).
I fail to see how this is my fault.

[Faster Than Light]

Assuming this whole faux pas leaves us with me, Brantz, and CoA confirmed for today, shouldn't we lynch out of Tier, Medea, and Krystal?
So, shouldn't we lynch Medea?

[Faster Than Light]

VOTE: Medea the Alien

[Faster Than Light]

Tier says he can confirm himself and people are saying Krystal's Post Restriction/play is town, so Medea?
Right?

[copper223]

The fact the sensor play failed indicates scum had a strong hold on the game yesterday and Medea was lurking, so not able to influence the outcome in any way, I have yet to see a hardcore lurker that does not get replaced turn out to be scum.

[CaskOfAmontillado]

VOTE: Madea

The fact the sensor play failed indicates scum had a strong hold on the game yesterday and Medea was lurking, so not able to influence the outcome in any way, I have yet to see a hardcore lurker that does not get replaced turn out to be scum.

So do you think Krystal is scum?

[copper223]

It is definitely possible, I still rail to understand how Krystal could be leaning scum on Lynx late D1.

My focus however is on the scum that infiltrated town yesterday, they are more likely to have dropped an association.

[CaskOfAmontillado]

I'm back from my weekend adventures, and I was gonna catch up tonight, but the post wound up being almost entirely Four Letter Words.

So I'll try again tomorrow, and for now I'll just say that I support Madea votes.

sthar8

[Faster Than Light]

Varsoon is not a four letter word. :3
-V

[Bookitty]

I'm going to call a Copper on the wagon and Cask-Faster than Light off the wagon scumteam. I'm sure I'm not 100 percent right, but I want that pointed out since they all three jumped on my wagon. Since I'm town, my flip will verify this. Copper is ESPECIALLY suspect here.

@Copper: Why are you ignoring the events of yesterday and Policy Lynch's final words?

Just because Cask didn't perform the kill doesn't make him town. It's common practice to have a less suspected member of the scumteam perform the kill.

@Mod: Is your wording meant to indicate that there is more than one scum on the wagon? You said one initially and then amended it to "at least one." The role PM you gave Lynx indicated that it would tell EXACTLY how many scum were on his wagon. Was this flavour? If you cannot answer, please say so.

@Tiershift: Whatever could have happened that could have triggered another power did not for me, anyway. I guess it was another event. Like I said, mine was vague and I didn't do anything last night.

[Bookitty]

@Faster than Light: I have a host of questions for you.

1. Why did you think that a failed vig shot made Cask for certain scum?
2. Why would the fact that Brantz jailkept Cask last night negate that read?
3. Did you consider bulletproof when consulting with Metal Sonic?
4. Why did you say that it was a guilty, more or less?

@Ghato: Can you ask Lynx to tell me why it was I never lynched him in that game we were in together and then pass on his reply? Thanks!

[Bookitty]

One, at least one! There are at least one non-Morbid betrayer involved in my demise!

I've seen a lot of speculation here, but no one has provided information direct from the mod or has indicated that they've even asked her. If they were really concerned about it, why wouldn't they have asked her in thread or via PM?

Why the focus on speculation rather than on finding out the truth?

The whole wringing hands and speculating seems like scum theater to me. Why not just ask?

[TierShift]

Well, okay.
Brantz is town, unless coa is scum. I don't believe coa is scum, so brantz is town.
I'm going to reread, but I think I'm ending up on bookitty today.

I think we have no evidence of there being two scum on the wagon. At least one scum means that one scum is probably unscannable, bit we do not know if that scum was on or off the wagon. Yesterday's lynch was just wasted...

[TierShift]

Also, since no one's claimed responsibility for the night happenings, I'll just go ahead.

I started the game as a treestump. Couldn't be voted, couldn't vote, couldn't be killed. My role did say my abilities could change based on unspecified game events. In the hopes of getting nightkilled, I said I would be cured of my treestumpness and that I couldn't claim 'X' because of my other PR.

Because the unspecified game event was very positive (gaining a vote, probably), I tried to convince others to make it happen. And now it did!

So this is what I can give on why I'm town. It should match completely with my play, because I did it on purpose. It also doesn't make much sense as a scum play.

I'm claiming now because I realise it's not the strongest of townclaims and I might just be voted for it if I coast on the 'I can prove I'm town' till lylo

[Bookitty]

Brantz is town, unless coa is scum. I don't believe coa is scum, so brantz is town.

Can you walk me through this, please? I'm with you on Brantz is town. How would CoA being scum make Brantz scum, though?

[Bookitty]

Because the unspecified game event was very positive (gaining a vote, probably), I tried to convince others to make it happen. And now it did!

Your role PM said it was a positive thing, or you assumed it?

[TierShift]

Brantz is town, unless coa is scum. I don't believe coa is scum, so brantz is town.

Can you walk me through this, please? I'm with you on Brantz is town. How would CoA being scum make Brantz scum, though?

Not implied. Coa being town would make brantz 100% town, coa being scum would have no effect on brantz.

Because the unspecified game event was very positive (gaining a vote, probably), I tried to convince others to make it happen. And now it did!

Your role PM said it was a positive thing, or you assumed it?

I start the game as a fucking treestump. How can I not assume it's a positive thing?

[Bookitty]

Okay. I've decided to respond, because I have a same text in my role PM and I think you are town.
I know more or less what the thing is that is going to be caused by the action and I strongly advise for you to do anything you can to make the 'something that could happen' happen.

I asked because of this. My own role PM is really vague and whatever it is that might happen hasn't happened yet. I thought you were saying you KNEW what would happen. Now you're saying you assumed it.

Just thinking about it.

[copper223]

@Boo
Are you calling me scum because I am wrong?

Your flip or my flip, if you are telling the truth they would both be town flips, both are also useless information for the other party as of now.

You have a point about asking the mod, I doubt it's going to help though, but where were your concerns when Ghato said it ment 1 end of story after Catastrophe questioned the wording? Why are you still assuming there was 1 instead of considering the worst case scenario that scum got what they wanted yesterday?