Mini 1624: Joss Whedon Mafia: The Musical (Game Over)

[Murder of Crows]

Now we're talking about who we'd vote if alive tomorrow and knowing the other is town.

I'd probably want to vote boon if not nolynch.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I'd either no lynch or back up Antihero's push on Nacho.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

My two solid townreads are Anti and Metal. If you are town, it leaves Nacho, Boon, Egg.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

We agree that it's not Boon/Egg.

[Murder of Crows]

That's because you

have

no scumreads besides me. Your response to all of my suspicions and concerns is to say that they are town. Of Course we'll wash up on the rocks.

Not true.

My shakiest town read is probably the bodhi saatva simply because of how inactive they've been this game day. But, reading back through day 2 so far shores that read up quite a bit. AP's concerns weigh on me a bit.

[Murder of Crows]

We really don't think it's egg.

gah. I don't like where the PoE leads, if not to you. I think that's the crux.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

Nacho/Boon isn't actually that unlikely if you are town though.

[Murder of Crows]

If you are town.

[serrapaladin]

Now we're talking about who we'd vote if alive tomorrow and knowing the other is town.

I'd probably want to vote boon if not nolynch.

[Metal Sonic]

I hate to diss you guys or sound like I'm lazy but I think murder and f16 are both town

[Metal Sonic]

I mean

There is always a distinct possibility that both of them ARE the scum and have been planning scum theatre since day 1, especially with day talk,

But the conviction that both have makes it difficult to differentiate if one or the other is the scum or town

And I honestly think that it's either both scum or none at all

[Metal Sonic]

I am shit at this game especially when I'm regarded as the second conftown after serrapaladin

And he isn't being exactly a stellar excellent role model

And me being the 3rd party in the discussion makes me appreciate his point of view and I find myself agreeing with him and his stances

Or lack thereof

[Metal Sonic]

Specifically the -> mislynch f16 then kill egg and nacho

I think did I get that right

[Metal Sonic]

I'm pretty busy during the week due to real life commitments so I find it difficult to find the time to do a full dived analysis (and I'm lazy), for this game, which it requires to have the highest 100% confidence in finding scum

I do know that the problem is a multiple choice of a few players, given that I am town and there is another conftown,

But I cannot be sure of anything right now in this game

I mean I have antihero as strong town right now but anything can happen

[Metal Sonic]

Right now the easiest players are egg and nacho hydra, but should I think deeper?

[serrapaladin]

I could see both being town, actually.

I don't think these wall wars have ever given me a good read on people, and pushing this game north of 150 pages isn't really improving my motivation. That being said, if they're both scum, the volume of posts today seems a bit overkill, to say the least. If one of them is scum with Egg or boon, I could also see either one of them going this hard.

What do you think of mara's cancelled replacement request?

[serrapaladin]

And could you think of a good reason for eyestott's replace?

[Metal Sonic]

I could see both being town, actually.

I don't think these wall wars have ever given me a good read on people, and pushing this game north of 150 pages isn't really improving my motivation. That being said, if they're both scum, the volume of posts today seems a bit overkill, to say the least. If one of them is scum with Egg or boon, I could also see either one of them going this hard.

What do you think of mara's cancelled replacement request?

If both are scum, their strategy of scum theatre effectively *almost* guarantees them a win bar unusual circumstances. Because the other will ride the town cred to victory. They are good players, it is unlikely for them to fuck it up.


In other news, I think mara's cancelled request to replace out is scummy as all heck. SK's "fuck off" just literally makes me want to lynch the slot, yet I get cold feet or apprehensive, get what I mean?

[Metal Sonic]

And could you think of a good reason for eyestott's replace?

I didn't ISO my predecessor, because there is enough stuff to sift through without rereading a slot that I know is town.


According to what I've heard, he got replaced voluntarily for receiving outside info. That's what I have as headcanon. Probably someone talked about this game outside of this game, so eyestott requested replacement. Probably a dead player. That's my guess.

[Metal Sonic]

Wall wars confuse me. Unless I spend a lot of time to analyse the text or what is going on, I will not be able to discern much meaningful information, unless one of the players slips or says something strikingly scummy.


So far, I haven't seen anything from either of the two that says "I AM SCUM", which I can easily spot in other easier games. Maybe I'm just lazy. Or maybe they're just good. Or Occam's razor, they're both town. But that's what scum want us to think, so what the heck.

[serrapaladin]

Hmm, I get what you're saying about skrew's reaction being weird, but I refuse to believe they'd use that as a deliberate tactic, and I'm also not convinced scum!mara would replace out when moc and f16 are fighting it out. I guess if I was in a hydra and my other head had requested replacement without asking me, I'd likely react like that as either alignment.

[Metal Sonic]

I don't know. I've always read fake replace outs as scummy. (Anecdote) once, I caught scum by one of my "gambits", where I was a real dayvig and dual shot the scum and a town. The scum threatened to replace out, but after she didn't die, I immediately hard pushed a lynch on her (after much effort, town can be so darn stupid sometimes) and she flipped scum role cop



It depends on the context, but I generally have a bad impression to fake replace outs

[Metal Sonic]

Hmm, I get what you're saying about skrew's reaction being weird, but I refuse to believe they'd use that as a deliberate tactic, and I'm also not convinced scum!mara would replace out when moc and f16 are fighting it out. I guess if I was in a hydra and my other head had requested replacement without asking me, I'd likely react like that as either alignment.

I suspect whoever is coasting in the f16/murder fiasco is highly likely to be scum. Who appears to be riding on the waves, and not bothering to scumhunt? Boon and nacho slot.

Ffs, nacho hydra has 3 players, and since I replaced in they haven't posted shit.

[Metal Sonic]

I mean at least Egg has posted something that attempts to be remotely townie

I mean

A long post that is meant to look town

AT LEAST SOMETHING!!

[serrapaladin]

If ffery and f16 are scum together, I don't think their discussion would need to be this deep about each other's meta. They're covering way more ground than they'd have to to cruise this.

And regarding gambits, threatening to replace out is borderline okay, but actually cancelling a request like that would reflect incredibly poorly on them.

boon has been terrible today, and bulb's answer that regfan could also have taken a scum PR makes me think scum might well have a joat type role, which puts boon back in the mix.

Do you agree that either boon or egg is very likely scum?