We Didn't Playtest This | Game over, everyone loses

[Boonskiies]

take a guess.

[deathfisaro]

So is people voting without much reasoning/argument attached a trend in larger games?
I don't know if I want them to get away with such, it'd be too easy for scum?

pedit: My vote's staying there, but it's no longer a random vote.

[Boonskiies]

So is people voting without much reasoning/argument attached a trend in larger games?
I don't know if I want them to get away with such, it'd be too easy for scum?

pedit: My vote's staying there, but it's no longer a random vote.

Yes. Also, you obviously don't know me. Hi, I'm Boonskiies. I randomly quickhammer on Day 1's when someone is put to L-1, I make pointless-tunnelly cases, don't back up my reasonings, and tend to make everyone want to rip their skin off. Oh, yeah. I'm town most of the time. People who push me are usually scum.

[Oranje Crush]

VOTE: Boonskies
If what you say is true I want you policied.

[BBmolla]

Danny read my posts ffs

[Boonskiies]

Danny read my posts ffs

oh, a scumbutt is someone i'm town reading, but I get why people are voting them.

[Boonskiies]

My role makes it highly likely that what you are claiming is actually in the game.

[Boonskiies]

VOTE: Boonskies
If what you say is true I want you policied.

This is a really bad vote, and not only because you are voting me. I checked his ISO, and Oranje has been posting random pointless stuff all game so far. They actually have a good amount of posts so far too. I thought the Vig-charge up shot theory was really weird, and that caught my attention earlier. It was way too opportunistic for my taste. I wouldn't have liked it even if someone else was the one posting instead of me, and then they voted that person. I don't really see anything that would garner a vote in my recent postings, but I really don't care about that. I really had no scum reads before, and was just trying to do random stuff until something clicked for me to get into the game. Looks like it's here.

VOTE: Oranje

[Boonskiies]

VOTE: Boonskies
If what you say is true I want you policied.

Also, it's never anti-town. People are just nitpicky and dumb. You considering a PL so soon and early in this game is ridiculous.

[Boonskiies]

VOTE: Boonskies
If what you say is true I want you policied.

A horrible vote; I'm responding to it with a self-explanatory vote.

[Boonskiies]

Actually, you haven't really done anything besides ask pointless fluff questions, make random weird theorizing some scum charge up vig shot (wtf?), vote without reason, and trying to start a wagon for a policy lynch. Yeah, I'm happy with my vote.

[Boonskiies]

So is people voting without much reasoning/argument attached a trend in larger games?
I don't know if I want them to get away with such, it'd be too easy for scum?

pedit: My vote's staying there, but it's no longer a random vote.

Yes. Also, you obviously don't know me. Hi, I'm Boonskiies. I randomly quickhammer on Day 1's when someone is put to L-1, I make pointless-tunnelly cases, don't back up my reasonings, and tend to make everyone want to rip their skin off. Oh, yeah. I'm town most of the time.

People who push me are usually scum.

Lol, scum hunting 101, Boonskiies Style. I drive scum insane because I catch them even when my logic is crap, it becomes pretty undeniable, and pretty damn accurate. BOOM, BABY!!!!!

[Drixx]

So is people voting without much reasoning/argument attached a trend in larger games?
I don't know if I want them to get away with such, it'd be too easy for scum?

pedit: My vote's staying there, but it's no longer a random vote.

First day in a large game starts out random, at least so far in my experience. Unless something unusual happens or someone makes a bad slip, the day one lynch wagon usually rolls on whichever townie has the misfortune to say something awkward that gets latched onto like a remora on a shark.

[Drixx]

Also ... I was wondering when you were going to bring your brand of bizarre into the game Boonskiies. Good to see you again!

[ChriVi]

Oh gooood this game is moving by so fast. Shit.

I'll come back when it's not 2:30 AM.. I'll read some of this during class tomorrow.

[Soren]

@Ice
You yourself said you did not intend to ask for the pairs in the neighbourhood to out themselves 275, only that you needed to know who claimed to have a neighbourhood, which is different from your initial claim and request so let's not pretend you have been consistent this whole time and a bunch of us just randomly decided to go ham on you, that's problem number 1 I have with your claim.

In 275, I acknowledged that part of my initial claim, and retracted it partially. But as I said it was an implication that I assumed was obvious: if you're a neighbor and you claim but your partner(s) doesn't, you should reveal it because a neighbor trying to stay hidden in light of a claimed neighbor day cop is antitown as hell.

You then made a post on how knowledge of the pairs and members of a neighbourhood can be used to help town 288, although you say you don't want it anymore in 275 and just now in 329 which is an inconsistency I did not much care for and that's number 2.

As. I. Just. Said. If you have a neighbor claim. It is only natural. That the neighbor's partner(s) will be revealed soon as well, either of their own accord (which will allow them to keep secret who they're partnered with, though I doubt this will happen because people like you are so opposed to the idea of a neighbor claim, which gives scum neighbors room to get away with not claiming) or by force (which will be done by a fellow neighbor, and surprise, to know someone's a neighbor you have to be partnered with them).

You can't just have one neighbor all on its own. Wtf is the point of the role then?

Problem number 3 is I don't see your claim as strictly necessary if you are town, whereas BBmolla should claims as a miller so it's something I would expect and I was prepared for, so yes all in all I tend to believe BBmolla over you, with good reason.

I can't believe I have to explain this again.

When I got my Role PM, I realized I had two options.

Either I could stay silent and try to find a neighbor day 1, most likely only find out that they're not a neighbor and I can't cop them night 1, do the same day 2, get the same result night 2, and so on with the risk of not having any results for a long time...

or I could claim, get neighbors to claim, and maximize the utility of my role from the start.

I chose option 2. There's more benefit to having neighbors claim early so we can get confirmed alignments early and corner scum early. It's risking scum nightkill me right away, but taking that into account with the likely scenarios presented above, it's either:

1. force scum to decide to kill me, potentially revealing just how scared they are of my role, or
2. have my role be completely useless the whole game and then having to say sorry, I could have gotten some results, but I decided to fucking hide in the corner all day and be a scared piece of shit, my bad.

I like this a lot.

[ChriVi]

2. pirate ika (pirate mollie & ika)
7. Three Pronged Trouser God (Untrod Tripod & kuribo & T-Bone)
8. Bulbasaur Commonwealth (Bulbazak & mastin2 & Voidedmafia)
13. PeregrineV
20. VysePresident
22. Om of the Nom
25. BBmolla

Loving this playerlist though

[Soren]

As a miller I'm probably going to be lynched eventually just by nature of my role, why in the fuck would you lynch me before using my

fucking confirmable ability

.

How stupid can you be like holy fuck

I like this too.

[Drixx]

As a miller I'm probably going to be lynched eventually just by nature of my role, why in the fuck would you lynch me before using my

fucking confirmable ability

.

How stupid can you be like holy fuck

I like this too.

Confirmation bias. Rationally there's no reason to believe his claim until it's tested. Since it becomes more valuable the more information we have, we'll be tempted to wait and use it. TDT suggests at least keeping open the possibility that the claim is false.

[Reubus Swagrid]

The lurk in this game is strong, that much is clear to me.
I feel like I could well be wasting time on most of these cases (there's so much sh*t to sieve through), it feels like there's a shitload of baiting going on and I'm still confused about what to make of this. I refuse to scumread anyone till more of these lurkers come out of hiding. Things will become more clear with the progression of time (that's almost a guarantee) but for now I think lynching anyone who hasn't got a massively convincing case against them would be a safe move, then again 12 days is a lot of time for scum hunting (which some will know that I'm not a complete god at yet).

And Soren, I like your ISO

[Om of the Nom]

The lurk in this game is strong, that much is clear to me.
I feel like I could well be wasting time on most of these cases (there's so much sh*t to sieve through), it feels like there's a shitload of baiting going on and I'm still confused about what to make of this. I refuse to scumread anyone till more of these lurkers come out of hiding. Things will become more clear with the progression of time (that's almost a guarantee) but for now I think lynching anyone who hasn't got a massively convincing case against them would be a safe move, then again 12 days is a lot of time for scum hunting (which some will know that I'm not a complete god at yet).

And Soren, I like your ISO :D

lol

[Reubus Swagrid]

The lurk in this game is strong, that much is clear to me.
I feel like I could well be wasting time on most of these cases (there's so much sh*t to sieve through), it feels like there's a shitload of baiting going on and I'm still confused about what to make of this. I refuse to scumread anyone till more of these lurkers come out of hiding. Things will become more clear with the progression of time (that's almost a guarantee) but for now I think lynching anyone who hasn't got a massively convincing case against them would be a safe move, then again 12 days is a lot of time for scum hunting (which some will know that I'm not a complete god at yet).

And Soren, I like your ISO

lol

Thankyou

[Om of the Nom]

please tell me u understand why i said that tho bc i dont want to have to explain it

[Reubus Swagrid]

please tell me u understand why i said that tho bc i dont want to have to explain it

Sorry but I don't. Feel free to explain

[Drixx]

Irony. Reubus is new but he shows promise.