Corpse Party Mafia [WRONG END]

[pieguyn]

votecount 1.2

Thor and Loki (1) - White Narcissus

Not voting (13) - Ankamius, notscience, Zymf, Skold, ZZZX, SXTLHGaiden, Mikazuki, Shadowcat, lufan131, Taly, Witness Protection, Thor and Loki, ZeL1nK2

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch. Deadline is August 6, 14:00 GMT-7 or in (expired on 2015-04-11 14:00:00).

[White Narcissus]

Actually i just realized in the description of the mechanic it says that they can raise the darkening of

one or more

people.
Why did you guys even need to bring that up?
Also you've guys spent 2 pages already discussing deadlines and pseudovotes rather than actually scumhunting, save a couple, why? (Mostly directed at Zelink and Taly)
~Sakura

[ZeL1nK2]

i'm not used to this whole "pseudovoting"
Can't we just real vote to accelerate the fun?
that said,

p-vote: skold

i believe it is a valid question to see how many people scum can affect per night. it could be something like "You can raise darkness by x% across n players"

I mean, honestly, it's not *that* big a deal if people accidentally vote once or twice, it's just the small things add up over time. Even just 2-4 votes a day means the later the game goes, the more darkness people have for no good reason.

Have fun with it if you want. I'll count anything that looks like a pseudo-vote. You can bold the lyrics to your favourite One Direction song and add ": Thor and Loki" to the end of it and I'll add it to the pseudo votecount if you want. Be creative. As long as it doesn't get too crazy.

Not liking Zelink at all, while we're all here setup speculating no one has even started scumhunting at all, and Zelink decided to dodge the question i asked.

I answered it.

And if you're not getting reads from what's been said already, you're not doing it right. Unless your complaint is that two pages in there aren't cases. In which case, I do apologise.

Also,

New and improved and still putting pieguy out of work... Dey Terk Urr Jerbs

Pseudo-Votecount 2

Loki and Thor (2)

: White Narcissus, ZeL1nK2

Taly (1)

: Skold

Skold (1)

: SXTLHGaiden

ZeL1nK2 (1)

: Shadowcat

Not Pseudo-Voting (9):

Ankamius, notscience, Zymf, ZZZX, Mikazuki, lufan131, Taly, Witness Protection, Thor and Loki

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to Pseudo-lynch. We're aiming for a lynch within (expired on 2015-04-03 14:00:00).

Spoiler: PAST VOTECOUNTS

Pseudo-Votecount 1 - Post 25

Loki and Thor (2)

: White Narcissus, ZeL1nK2

White Narcissus (1)

: Skold

Not Pseudo-Voting (11):

Ankamius, notscience, Zymf, ZZZX, SXTLHGaiden, Mikazuki, Shadowcat, lufan131, Taly, Witness Protection, Thor and Loki

[White Narcissus]

And if you're not getting reads from what's been said already, you're not doing it right.

Then tell me, what reads do YOU have, since you have done nothing in this game that remotely resembles scumhunting.
~Sakura

[ZeL1nK2]

I have a town read on everyone that's posted outside of you, Loki and Gaiden.

[White Narcissus]

Why is Taly town?

~Wis

[ZeL1nK2]

His first post was town. I also don't mind his other posts.

[ZeL1nK2]

Actually, I also don't know why you're making a big deal out of Taly doing "setup spec" when there are others (like, oh, I don't know, Loki?) who have talked just as much or more about the setup than Taly.

Though I don't know why you're making a big deal out of it at all, really. It's two pages in and it's a mechanic important to the game. It was a necessary discussion.

[ZeL1nK2]

Also if you truly have misgivings about myself (or Taly), why are you keeping your vote on

Jekyll and Hyde

Loki and Thor?

[White Narcissus]

My issue isnt it whether it's a point worth discussing or not, my issue is when that's all that people are doing, like you could say "Oh yes I agree, BTW, why did you, or why that, why this, bla bla bla" you know ACTUAL scumhunting.
While I agree you're not the only one doing so, I'd expect you to have done something other than... keeping setup spec and counting pseudovotes, did you get anything from your pseudo vote on Loki and thor? You never followed up on anything with them, yet you somehow ended up "not townreading" them as opposed to everyone else?
~Sakura

[Thor and Loki]

I'd want to quicklynch notscience because I think that'd be pretty funny.

I don't particularly have a town read on Shadowcat. Should I?

[White Narcissus]

It's the way Taly did it. He repeated lots of stuff already said or pretty obvious, like he wanted to share the town spotlight with the rest of the "cool guys". And then he mentioned stuff that nobody had paid attention to, like the fact scum can affect more than one people, or that they don't have a nightkill. This kind of stuff are more likely to stay in the mind of scum than town.

I'm townreading everyone that has posted other than Taly right now. Sakura is wary of you as well, but I don't think you are ill-intended.

~Wis

[White Narcissus]

^that was to ZeL obv

~Wis

[Thor and Loki]

It's too early to have a town read on us, I'd assume. It's not like I've really done anything particularly exciting as of late.

[White Narcissus]

your posts dont strike me as scum-nacho

you

are

nacho, right?

~Wis

[White Narcissus]

It's too early to have a town read on us, I'd assume. It's not like I've really done anything particularly exciting as of late.

Neither has anyone else, and you dont see the issue with this?
And still the only townread i have is the Zymf or whatever person, tho Wis doesn't seem to see the issues i see with Zelink.
We both dislike Taly.
Do you have any reads?
~Sakura

[White Narcissus]

Me and wis compromise on this for the time being

Pseudovote: Taly

~Sakura

[White Narcissus]

also UNVOTE: because the vc will look silly

~Wis

[Thor and Loki]

It's too early to have a town read on us, I'd assume. It's not like I've really done anything particularly exciting as of late.

Neither has anyone else, and you dont see the issue with this?
And still the only townread i have is the Zymf or whatever person, tho Wis doesn't seem to see the issues i see with Zelink.
We both dislike Taly.
Do you have any reads?
~Sakura

townreading everyone who has posted except shadowcat and gaiden

[Witness Protection]

Also you've guys spent 2 pages already discussing deadlines and pseudovotes rather than actually scumhunting, save a couple, why? (Mostly directed at Zelink and Taly)

But where is there to scum hunt (at the time of this post?), some casual conversation's a great place to start getting base line reads. Then we go from there.

But

I do want me some scum!

I gotta go play RISK. Later.

[Thor and Loki]

I'm maybe even scumreading gaiden.

I Knew You Were Trouble When You Walked in: Gaiden

[ZeL1nK2]

Asking questions isn't the only way to scum hunt - there are meaningful ways to produce and assess content that don't require me asking questions. Besides which, there are not many questions to ask this early in the game that have any meaning beyond

straining

to find a question to ask. You guys are trying way too hard. The questions you're asking look forced. It doesn't necessarily make you scum, but it's certainly not endearing.

I mean, asking me what I got from a random vote on Loki that I made clear was for humourous effect? Eh. Asking me how I "somehow" ended up not town-reading them? Eh.

It's the way Taly did it. He repeated lots of stuff already said or pretty obvious,

like he wanted to share the town spotlight with the rest of the "cool guys"

. And then he mentioned stuff that nobody had paid attention to, like the fact scum can affect more than one people, or that they don't have a nightkill. This kind of stuff are more likely to stay in the mind of scum than town.

Eh, I don't really agree with the interpretation bolded. Sometimes people say what you were thinking ahead of time, and you say it anyway. He's also not the first person to mention scum can affect more than one person (or that scum may not be able to raise darkness to 100% in one night). Skold did that in his first post.

[White Narcissus]

nacho why are you also townreading Taly?

~Wis

[Thor and Loki]

I'm maybe even scumreading gaiden.

I Knew You Were Trouble When You Walked in: Gaiden

Actually, Sakura:

The assumption that I'm making with Gaiden is that if he thought voting would "accelerate the fun", that he would vote regardless of whatever discussion was going on (maybe even a discussion against it would encourage him to vote more). Do you think I'm wrong to think this?

[ZeL1nK2]

Actually Skold didn't technically talk about spreading darkness to multiple players, but that was the underlying implication behind not being able to raise darkness to 100% for anyone reading between the lines. But I also don't think speculation in general is more likely to come from scum, anyway. It's null at best.