We Didn't Playtest This | Game over, everyone loses

[Plotinus]

Remind me what plot claimed

I am town bulletproof. i have kevlar which means immunity to mafia kills. my only utility at this point is for narninian to redirect onto me if he wants.

[Plotinus]

BC, Really? We know Narninan redirected how?

If we had a doc circle, then the logical place for a kill redirect is on the unprotected mason. Then, it redirects to someone scummy. That didn't happen...

I redirected from trouser god to Bulbasaur
as always, no idea if it actually did anything.

[Narninian]

I feel like every-time my redirect theoretically worked out for town, I am suspected for it.

Night 1 -- I might have prevented a kill with a redirect
Night 2 -- I went for the 'Obvious' target House and it didn't do anything
Night 3 -- My redirect probably worked, and we got a confirmed DOC out of it
Night 4- We are missing both eviscerate AND incinerate, it may very well have been from my redirect. Eviscerate could be just because werewolves are wiped out, but what about incinerate?

2 confirmed docs is a *very* good position to be in. In many game doc protects only work for the first kill, so I figured that if there are multiple scum teams there would be decent motivation to stop the doc circle jerk.

[Narninian]

I agree that Narninan's lack of redirect is startling.

Toss in the lack of a redirect from House, it is off.

This is simply outright false.

There is evidence to suggest I redirected up to 3 times and I also redirected from house.

[Narninian]

**targeted house for a redirect

[Narninian]

Well ozgin at the time.

[Titus]

Then why is House dead?

[Narninian]

I don't know?
I just assumed because Nuked from orbit happens during the day, it can't be redirected at night.

but if we're assuming this day phase thing is affected by night phase then...
Ploticus is scum
there were 2 attempts on house
or I was roleblocked

I'm leaning towards the former though.

[Narninian]

I think that because it was a day phase kill my night phase action didn't do anything.

[Bulbasaur Commonwealth]

Then why is House dead?

We went over this yesterday, Titus. Nuked is a delayed kill, therefore normal doctors don't work on it.

Seriously, use your fabled logic.

Night 4- We are missing both eviscerate AND incinerate, it may very well have been from my redirect. Eviscerate could be just because werewolves are wiped out, but what about incinerate?

I already countered this. The missing kills are for different reasons.

[Drixx]

Drixx for today's lynch! Everyone vote Drixx! We need to deal the death blow to Titus' "fabled logic" as BC put it. I will gladly march to my death in the name of rationality and logic.

Let's do this folks. Drixx for Mafia Body President!

[Titus]

Drixx will you knock this shit off? I don't respond well to AtE.

[Narninian]

well if somehow titus is right and I am wrong and the day kill is affected by night actions, then plotinus is scum because thats who I redirected it to. (actiondan)
I don't think thats actually what happened, but plotinus is on my list anyway

VOTE: Plotinus

[Bulbasaur Commonwealth]

well if somehow titus is right and I am wrong and the day kill is affected by night actions, then plotinus is scum because thats who I redirected it to. (actiondan)
I don't think thats actually what happened, but plotinus is on my list anyway

VOTE: Plotinus

Wait, when was that?

[Plotinus]

Skimmed Bulba and Narninian's ISO's again (was reading more closely for a while but my eyes were kinda glazing over, i think i am readed out for the day after spending so much time reading oranje closely). still not really like liking bulba. I'm liking Narninian more now after skimming it more closely than my initial skim, so if my death will clear him that's good.

So, after I flip town, don't be mad at titus for being wrong about me because I wasn't that high up on the VCA list and I think she's misgiven, not scum. Narninian is town too.

pedit: probably night 2 since that's the only night he didn't spell out who he redirected to.

After a die, you need to focus on finding the nuke from orbit crew first thing, because I think they can ruin the doctor circle.

[Narninian]

well if somehow titus is right and I am wrong and the day kill is affected by night actions, then plotinus is scum because thats who I redirected it to. (actiondan)
I don't think thats actually what happened, but plotinus is on my list anyway

VOTE: Plotinus

Wait, when was that?

Night 2 I redirected from Ozgin/house) to actiondan/plotinus)

I believe that it didn't save house the next day because it was a night action and he died during the day.
but if I'm wrong about that its because my redirect failed because I redirected backed to the source.

[Cuttlefish]

Vote Count 6.01

Plotinus (5)

- Bulbasaur Commonwealth, BRantz, Titus, Narninian

Titus (2)

- Three-Pronged Trouser God, Drixx

Oranje Crush (2)

- deathfisaro, BBmolla

deathfisaro (1)

- Oranje Crush

Drixx (1)

- Plotinus

Not Voting (2)

: ChriVi, Boonskiies

With 13 votes in play, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline falls in (expired on 2015-05-05 13:56:04).

[Plotinus]

VOTE: Oranje Crush because I like death's explanation of where the new kill flavour came from. I'm still suspicious of bulbasaur commonwealth too.

[Drixx]

Are you spinning the wheel of fortune and just voting wherever it lands or something?

@Titus - I'm not appealing to emotion. I have rational reasons to feel that in the absence of a consensus scumread, I am a good information lynch. You have me rated as your most scummy read, but nary a vote from you on me can be found. Why is that?

[Plotinus]

No. Are you a jester?

[Drixx]

I am not a jester. I'm a town Argyrophilic {Link} with the ability

Silver Lining

which makes me permanently immune from werewolf kills.

As you can see just from this day's list of people's scum reads, I am a gigantic liability if left until the end game. I probably have no remaining utility from my role, and me showing up in so many scum lists makes my utility negative. Pretty much anyone who puts me in the scum column but then doesn't want to lynch me, should probably look up the term "Cognitive Dissonance" and should also be viewed as potential scum by people who are at least as sane as Kuribo.

[deathfisaro]

VOTE: Oranje Crush because I like death's explanation of where the new kill flavour came from. I'm still suspicious of bulbasaur commonwealth too.

The timing of this post though. I never considered you today's lynch but this post is asking for it.
5 minutes ago we were talking about how a kill redirect to you failed, and suddenly you jump the attention to OC.
I'm almost wanting to just let you get lynched and see what kill flavours we observe tomorrow morning.

[Titus]

Are you spinning the wheel of fortune and just voting wherever it lands or something?

@Titus - I'm not appealing to emotion. I have rational reasons to feel that in the absence of a consensus scumread, I am a good information lynch. You have me rated as your most scummy read, but nary a vote from you on me can be found. Why is that?

The only other person who wants to vote you is my second behavioral scumread at this point. That's a good logical reason not to vote you.

I do think you're scum, but there's more than one left.

Despite what you do think of me, I do observe reactions. Plotinus does bother me. Him lapping up what I say like a dog is worrisome. So is everyone wanting to tear me down. I'm looking for a middle ground. Good dialogue.

[Plotinus]

@drixx the jester comment was a joke, sorry.

@death I was waiting for a votecount to revote because i didn't want to hammer anyone by mistake.

[Plotinus]

+ I realised I was at L-2 and so I wanted to my vote to be accurate if I died.