MS and I have played a fair amount with each other. in general, I think most of what you're accusing him of is playstyle as opposed to alignment-related. the first thing is
↑ elusive wrote:2. Your reaction to light pressure was bizarre. You basically did a combo of frenzied posts, AtE, fixating on a newbie\possible mislynch bait, and claiming\fake claiming a character at a point when you weren't in deep danger. Honestly, the possibility of your claim being true and no cc is the only reason I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt.
I think this was done primarily due to conviction as opposed to anything else - he thinks Yukari is scum and thinks by claiming the main character it will give him credibility to lynch him/stop people from wanting to lynch him instead. I also think *if* he's scum here, he was going for this as opposed to doing it for strategic reasons (i.e. he's either town, or scum faking it). the claim itself is null due to how theme games work - often flavor isn't tied to alignment or major characters are left out of the game and provided to scum as safe claims - but the way he did it was also null.
I think the way he was "flailing" here is also playstyle. he generally reacts very strongly as town in situations where a lot of players wouldn't - which leads to people thinking he's flailing and lynching him as a result. I also think he thought he was in more danger than he is (he's the leading wagon and a lot of other people seem to be questioning him) - I buy that he saw the wagon on him and saw the "writing on the wall", so to speak.
↑ elusive wrote:4. If you are staying in the game, stop pulling these shenanigans and engaging in theater. No one listens to, except maybe scum, to people who are screaming\etc or don't provide logical and sensible cases. Not only that I find players who scream scum and give weak cases or don't do their research to be scummy. Stagnant reads is also scummy.
if you're asking MS to do research to confirm/deny his scum reads, you're asking the wrong person
I don't think stagnant reads are, by nature, scummy. if nothing is happening to change your reads, you shouldn't have to change them. I get accused of that all the time (both by town, and alternatively scum trying to discredit me by claiming I'm "tunneling") and my reaction is always the same - that nothing happened to make me second guess/question my reads. in MS's case, I don't think he had much of a reason to reevaluate the Yukari read so far sans the meta you're linking him.
I don't think there's anything off about it. why does it strike you as off?
