Inorganic Chemistry [GAME OVER, SCUM WIN]

[Lying Cat]

Are we ready for massclaim? The person who got masonized needs to claim it first, but then I think we're set.

I'm pretty sure there's scum between TSO/cerb, and right now I think it's T.

I'm still working the POE from town angle, but my gun-to-the-head scumteam is TSO, Wicked, PV. That's assuming all three inventors are town, which is very possible at this point.

Need to talk to Jingle re:math

[PeregrineV]

Quickread of Mac/Aristophanes has Contantine probably town, since for Shakira to hard tunnel on a scumbuddy would seem unlikely.

Probably read Bins next.

Anyone have any suggestions for who to read after that?

[PeregrineV]

Greetings all! I'm replacing some other player. I'll get started today by looking over the game.

Titus tracked you to the kill last night. Explain yourself.

Assuming my role PM was complete, this makes it pretty easy.

Vote: Titus

[PeregrineV]

Greetings all! I'm replacing some other player. I'll get started today by looking over the game.

Titus tracked you to the kill last night. Explain yourself.

Assuming my role PM was complete, this makes it pretty easy.

Vote: Titus

Titus has 2 post- I guess you mean Sonic Boom?

Vote: Sonic Boom

I'll read them next, then Bins.

[Wickedestjr]

^ I don't like that reaction.

[Cerberus v666]

^ I don't like that reaction.

Wicked, why aren't you scum with TSO, and is there any reason why we *shouldn't* lynch TSO to confirm you?

LC: I've got nothing to hide now.

[PeregrineV]

Greetings all! I'm replacing some other player. I'll get started today by looking over the game.

Titus tracked you to the kill last night. Explain yourself.

Assuming my role PM was complete, this makes it pretty easy.

Vote: Titus

Titus has 2 post- I guess you mean Sonic Boom?

Vote: Sonic Boom

I'll read them next, then Bins.

3 pages worth. Looked at the last one. Didn't see anything resembling that.

Vote: Lying Cat

[PeregrineV]

^ I don't like that reaction.

Expand on that.

[Sonic Boom]

I will be looking at VCA in a bit. Carry on with this.

I am not confirming or denying what I did or didn't do unless an issue arises where the sole thing is the claim getting them lynched (we're talking L-1, L-2 here) and it's wrong or right. I strongly agree with Sonic on Mastina being scum here, but for different reasons. I do make a supposition that Shakira is indeed town though.

~Titus

[T S O]

I don't have any intention of getting lynched here, to be honest.

[T S O]

Why would I investigate Cerb, when it's obvious I was going to investigate Wicked if I got it?

Hmm. I'm not sure it was wholly obvious. I disagree. There were definitely a few different options you could have investigated. You even said you were waffling between some choices yourself. If YOU were uncertain who you were going to investigate, it's disingenuous to say it was obvious to everyone else who you would target.

This is true, but Wicked was far more likely to be a target than you, since I had been clearly considering Wicked-scum, but never really you-scum.

I find it curious that you ask why I didn't investigate you when you seem to already know the answer, but maybe that's just the common sense in me talking.

[T S O]

Oh, LC? If you're actually going ahead with calling me scum, then lay your cards out on the table. I hope you're packing some good ones.

[Lying Cat]

Oh, LC? If you're actually going ahead with calling me scum, then lay your cards out on the table. I hope you're packing some good ones.

I might not have said it recently, but you are just my favorite.

[PeregrineV]

a no lynch day 1?

Reading Bins it was between him and hiplop?

Was he (Bins) vigged?

Since hiplop was lynched day2, somebody had to be pushing the Bins/hiplop scum dichotomy.

Anyone want to volunteer who that was? Make looking for the answer easier.

[Cerberus v666]

Why would I investigate Cerb, when it's obvious I was going to investigate Wicked if I got it?

Hmm. I'm not sure it was wholly obvious. I disagree. There were definitely a few different options you could have investigated. You even said you were waffling between some choices yourself. If YOU were uncertain who you were going to investigate, it's disingenuous to say it was obvious to everyone else who you would target.

This is true, but Wicked was far more likely to be a target than you, since I had been clearly considering Wicked-scum, but never really you-scum.

I find it curious that you ask why I didn't investigate you when you seem to already know the answer

, but maybe that's just the common sense in me talking.

That's easy. At the time i first asked, it was purely off the cuff, a reflexive question as it were, since I was operating off the assumption that the cop inventor preferred the chain confirming plan, as evidenced by giving me the cop, and so figured whoever they gave it to would be someone they felt was likely to investigate me. The fact that you hadn't surprised me, so I asked why you didn't. I then went and read your ISO once you said it should have been obvious, and found some mention of wicked, but nothing that made it seem obvious to me who you would target.

In any case, as far as sorting people go, it's way better that you targeted wicked, given that the cop inventor died last night and I have faith that Sonic Boom will be able to understand why I both must be the inventor as claimed, and why it's extremely unlikely that i'm scum, given my choice of recipients, which altogether combines to make targeting me something which would have been a bit redundant.

[Cerberus v666]

a no lynch day 1?

Reading Bins it was between him and hiplop?

Was he (Bins) vigged?

Since hiplop was lynched day2, somebody had to be pushing the Bins/hiplop scum dichotomy.

Anyone want to volunteer who that was? Make looking for the answer easier.

Bins was killed N1, presumably by scum. The primary reason why hiplop was lynched wasn't so much a bins/hiplop dichotomy as how suspicious it was that hiplop was SO CLOSE to being lynched for quite a long while, but nobody actually pushed him over the edge. It felt like there was a good chance of scum resistance to his lynch combining with town inactivity, when it would appear it was really just town inactivity. Well, I don't know if that was the primary reason overall, but it was the primary reason for suspicion on my part. I felt that he was nullscum, but that even if he was actually town, he would be easy mislynch bait and it would be far better to sort that situation sooner rather than later.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

We lost an inventor. That's great...

[Cerberus v666]

Oh hey thanks for checking in. Have you had a chance to catch up on the thread at all/ And yes, it's pretty bad. We lost an inventor...and arguably the most useful one. Nothing to do about it now though. Any thoughts?

[St Constantine the Hermit]

No thoughts at the moment, I am just trying to process it all. I will probably sit and observe while all you hounds bash it out.

[Sonic Boom]

PereV is strong town for me

[Sonic Boom]

Although replacing Kari..... Agh

Titus... Counterwagon on scum == town?

[mastin2]

Ran out of time today; agreed to work and will be getting ready for it soon, so catchup will have to wait a bit.
Sorry.

[Nachomamma8]

I would not clear Kari.

[T S O]

I would!

[T S O]

Oh, LC? If you're actually going ahead with calling me scum, then lay your cards out on the table. I hope you're packing some good ones.

I might not have said it recently, but you are just my favorite.

Back at you, my dear.