Mini 1724: Gameboy Advance Mafia (Abandoned)

[Knuckles]

Game Day or real world day?

Game day

Yes.

[Vedith]

Game Day or real world day?

Game day

Yes.

So if you don't, I think that we should lynch you.
Agreed?

[Knuckles]

So we are going with a town dayvig and a town vigilante?
And we are going with Random actually being BP? (Which he isn't)

I'm going with town dayvig and town vig, sure. I'm limited, he's unlimited, if any one made more sense as scum it would be me but that's clearly problematic from our perspective

I will continue going with Random actually being BP until someone who knows something shares their knowledge.

[Knuckles]

Game Day or real world day?

Game day

Yes.

So if you don't, I think that we should lynch you.
Agreed?

No.

[Vedith]

I will continue going with Random actually being BP until someone who knows something shares their knowledge.

And this is why I think that you are scum too. XD

Dav, kill Knuckles tonight please.
And lynch Random with me.

[Knuckles]

I will continue going with Random actually being BP until someone who knows something shares their knowledge.

And this is why I think that you are scum too. XD

Dav, kill Knuckles tonight please.
And lynch Random with me.

Is there a reason that I shouldn't believe Random is BP?

[Knuckles]

Or are you telling me I should just trust your knowledge, whatever it is?

[Sound of Silence]

I think it's kinda obvious what he's implying at this point, no?

[Knuckles]

I think it's kinda obvious what he's implying at this point, no?

It wasn't until now!

[Sound of Silence]

In post 25 he sounded ambivalent about the idea of role claiming. Then it looked to me like he was the first player to srsclaim a few posts later.

What do you think of my Nosferatu point?
I don't mind the early ambivalence because it read less like he was genuinely conflicted and more like he just didn't give a shit.

I can see that.

I had hoped to poke the game with a page one read bu not much came of it. Nosferatu did respond to that, with some non-specific agreement. I kinda expected someone to push me for reasons or tell me they disagreed or something.

[Knuckles]

What do you think of Pepto now?

[Vedith]

Okay look, lets just say I can give something out which I also have. Lets just say, Random wouldn't need one at this stage apparently... Unless we think 2 of each role with a modification?

[Knuckles]

Actually, would like to here thoughts on all of ASP/Nosferatu/grapes/Pepto/Starbuck/AJ. I think RM is gonna be a town read no matter how much Vedith complains about it, but this is the group that dissatisfies me.

[Sound of Silence]

I think RM is gonna be a town read no matter how much Vedith complains about it

[Sound of Silence]

With that said

Actually, would like to here thoughts on all of ASP/Nosferatu/grapes/Pepto/Starbuck/AJ. I think RM is gonna be a town read no matter how much Vedith complains about it, but this is the group that dissatisfies me.

did your grapes read shift or is it just because it's in town(?) category?

[Sound of Silence]

What do you think of Pepto now?

w

I haven't absorbed the last 3 or so pages and probably won't until things calm down tonight. Yesterday I thought that he hasn't really done anything else I particularly liked.

[Xtoxm]

In post 25 he sounded ambivalent about the idea of role claiming. Then it looked to me like he was the first player to srsclaim a few posts later.

What do you think of my Nosferatu point?
I don't mind the early ambivalence because it read less like he was genuinely conflicted and more like he just didn't give a shit.

I could see a couple of his posts re:massclaim being in a 'please believe me' kind of way, but generally don't feel like he'd have claimed what he did as scum.

[Sound of Silence]

w

netbook?

[Vedith]

Yesterday I thought that he hasn't really done anything.

I corrected your sentence for you.

[Knuckles]

Okay look, lets just say I can give something out which I also have. Lets just say, Random wouldn't need one at this stage apparently... Unless we think 2 of each role with a modification?

I didn't blink at two vigs.
Not really blinking at two bulletproofs either.

[Xtoxm]

Knuckles what are you seeing in davesto?

Vigilante claim.

AJ, is there something wrong with this position?
Can you tell me why he claims vigilante as scum?

So we are going with a town dayvig and a town vigilante?
And we are going with Random actually being BP? (Which he isn't)

Nacho sounds serious, it's only one shot, I see no reason to disregard the possibility that both exist as town. I don't know if Dav's claim was real, but if it was it's quite provable. I like him for town either way.

[Knuckles]

Give them a flavour claim.
Leave the role behind it to the player.
As claiming is a pretty big part of mafia.

This is why I'm suspicious of Nosferatu.
What else does he claim if he thinks the town is serious about mass claiming at that point?

[Knuckles]

did your grapes read shift or is it just because it's in town(?) category?

town? category.

[Knuckles]

Give them a flavour claim.
Leave the role behind it to the player.
As claiming is a pretty big part of mafia.

This is why I'm suspicious of Nosferatu.
What else does he claim if he thinks the town is serious about mass claiming at that point?

Like I guess maybe he only claims Vanillaizer part of his role, but what if someone uses an ability on him and it fails? He practically has to claim Vanillaizer because it's public.

[Xtoxm]

The assumption i'm working from is that we each have 1 of the 13 listed games, and scum are intended to fakeclaim as anyone from their game (or not, we don't know yet if scum have actual antagonist flavours).