Prozac's Basic Theme 4 - Murder in Marlowe - OVER!

[Spiffeh]

Then just say it now so you can say "I told you so".

Win-win

[Davsto]

Well I told you so it was Espe.

I also informed you thusly that at least one other is in Zito/myko/notsci

[Papa Zito]

Part of the point of this exercise Davsto is we're attempting to figure out if you even HAVE reasons for the people you've deemed scum. If you have any you have to tell us or we're forced to conclude that you don't. Once reasoning is provided we can all take a gander and decide if your thought process comes more from scum than town, but if you can't even provide the reasoning to begin with, well.

[Spiffeh]

And it would be a lot easier to follow through on those if you explain why.

[Davsto]

But I've proved I have reasons by making a fucking giant fucking post about espe

jesus wept

[Davsto]

I've already provided the reason I'm not so hot on you, and my notscience one is still there.

myko is gut

you're welcome

[scotmany12]

> refusing to elaborate on your scum reads
> massive fucking post literally 30 minutes ago.


Like, that shit takes effort. I see no productivity in doing it for more than one player.

See. Here's my problem. You know people want to see stuff from you, and in doing so it could save your own skin. How is that not productive? You've been skating by for quite sometime, if you really were town, wouldn't you be doing all you could to try to convince people that so to avoid a mislynch?

[Flameaxe]

I'm not entirely sure where any of this is getting us though

[Davsto]

I'm not so naive to think that you all will actually suddenly decide to let me off. If I provided that nice Epse wall and everyone's still scumreading me for it, three other, less substantial ones aren't going to change jack.

PEdit you don't say

[Spiffeh]

Flame it's getting us a Davsto lynch and one more dead scum!

scot just vote Dav already we know where this is going

[Flameaxe]

Is it though?

Is it?

[mykonian]

might work, at least it's not a bad lynch.

[scotmany12]

VOTE: Davstro

[Papa Zito]

hurray

VOTE: Davsto

[Davsto]

[Flameaxe]

You're hard to love but you're even harder to hate dav

[Davsto]

I will take that as a compliment.

[Flameaxe]

It was meant as one

[pirate mollie]

@Mollie: You know zito far more when it comes to mafia. I just don't think he has been scummy at all. His vote on MattP was understandable for me, and I didn't see any of the kicking and screaming.

what makes you think this, scotty?

[pirate mollie]

also I absolutely HATE this lynch on dave

[Bins]

uh why

[Porochaz]

Unfortunately from the word go, the holiday had not gone to plan, everything that could go wrong had done and that's how he found himself in his hotel room alone that night.

Votecount 2.05

Davsto

(5): Spiffeh, Flameaxe, Bins, scotmany, zito

Espeonage

(3): Starbuck, Davsto, pirate mollie

scotmany12

(1): ChannelDelibird

Starbuck

(1): Espeonage

ChannelDelibird

(1): notscience

Not Voting

(5): xRECKONERx, Nexus, curiouskarmadog, catboi, mykonian,
With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

[catboi]

Davsto's posting on the last page looks town and I no longer have interest in lynching him. Votes from scot and Zito look not great.

It's not a good lynch because now we know matt is scum, at first I wouldn't even expect him day 1 to pick a scum and a town as a limited choice for his lynch, and on top of that, he surely would not pick his scumbuddy as a preference. The situation wasn't close to as clear that scum was forced to make a choice like that. Matt had options, he chose to go with a limited choice between AJ (espe) and davsto. I'd say AJ is very town coming from that despite his own play, davsto is likely town.

While I think this sort of reasoning is maybe a bit naive, do agree that I'm a little wary of voting espeonage today.

also now that it ended I can say I think CDB doesn't seem as fake to me here as in mini 1716 where his reads were sort of full of crap and based around nitpicky tone things (realize it's a vastly different environment, but still). Don't think the inactivity is alignment indicative but I also think he was favoring this game over that one but that's just from memory

I am pretty sure his read on me on d1 was nitpicky for something that he knows wldn't be scummy from me and his read on scotty isn't any better.

voteparking absolutely is scummy combined with lurking. its a lone vote that you never REALLY have to be accountable for since it usually doesn't wind up in a lynch and most of the time pple read the lynch wagon and somehow manage to miss OH HAI WHAT ARE OTHER PLAYERS DOING.

I don't think his read seems that bad but I still want to investigate myself before I really go into it. I think what he's saying there is understandable and I feel like I'm repeating myself on this, could maybe go over the points in detail later. Do agree that the way he read you early day 1 as a whole didn't make a ton of sense, but also it was early and I like the way his thoughts have progressed since then? This is all sort of from memory so I'm somewhat talking out of my butt here but it's late so I don't want to explain too much.

[catboi]

I didn't like his readslist, there were a lot of really weird issues with it.

Generally like notscience's readslist (in terms of process), would like him to go into more detail on this as to what he found weird about it - I know he says more in the post I quoted but I want to hear specifics. Not sure I see this read.

[Spiffeh]

Tell me how Davsto's posts look town.