↑ pieguyn wrote:yes - what you're doing here looks similar to the kind of thing I'd do if I saw someone getting cleared/widely town read and wanted to stop it. specifically I take issue with you claiming things like, "if he's scum he's lying about some aspect of his role" and "we haven't seen the gladiator in action" when in reality this is unreasonable. it makes no sense for someone to make up something like that most of the time, and even if they are there isn't a point in discussing it until it actually comes up.
Ok:
1) Who, besides Sakura, had asserted that the role most likely was town at the point where I disagreed?
2) Why is muffin not being entirely truthful unreasonable (from either alignment)?
3) Is what you really mean is "there's no point in scrutinizing the person fakeclaiming until it is demonstrably proven that they are" or "there's no point in not taking the claim at face value until proven otherwise"
Because I agree with the first statement, disagree with the second, and even if I agreed with the second AND muffin is exactly what he says he is there's
no fucking way for me to discern alignment from that with any degree of accuracy and that's all I've fucking been saying the entire fucking game
I'm just really fucking sick of this conversation
