Mini 1735 - Mana Khemia: Mafia in Al-Revis [End]

[Flay Gunnar]

votecount 1.27

itlepip (4) - Spiffeh, 3dicerolling, Cold Pizza, Maxous
Spiffeh (2) - Suzune, CharlotteBebe
Maxous (2) - Antihero, Vayne Aurelius
Saki (2) - Gilgamesh King Of Heroes, Rogue
CharlotteBebe (1) - Saki
MarioManiac4 (2) - Titus, itlepip
Suzune (1) - MarioManiac4

Not Voting (0) -

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline is November 12, 12:30 GMT-7 or in (expired on 2015-11-12 12:30:00).

Please let me know if you see any mistakes

Mod Notes:

Cold Pizza and Gilgamesh King Of Heroes have 1 hour and 20 minutes to post or will be prodded

[Suzune]

I apologise but I do not get it is kind of vague. What is there to not get about it. Looks pretty simple to me. Itlepip commented silly when he should have commented on the events. This in turn bothered spif. So spif voted on him and got a mini wagon started for no reason. Itlepip attempted to confront him about the reason for the train and spif said basically that his reaction was enough to justify the train.

It looks to me like a lucky mistake. I know how frustrating it is to be in that position itlepip was in and with no real case sitting on him the train does not make sense to me. There is the case in a nutshell.

Although to be fair to you Mario. You joined that train for a while for no real reason.

There is definitely reasoning behind the wagon. The way you are talking is as if you are only reading through a certain page. Lucky mistake literally makes no sense whatsoever. You need to elaborate more.

@Itlepip - I'm going to respond to you later when I can get on a computer, where I can quote better and look at the thread easier.

I'm also not a fan of the MM4 wagon, but I do think Titus is town. Still scumreading Rogue slot.

i apologize but I get a bad feeling from this lynch. I feel pretty sure it is going to come up townie. Since you clearly are well clued in on the reasons perhaps you can explain it for me because I do not see anyone joining the train for really well thought out reasons.

[Rogue]

K, Saki / Suzune / ??? {itle/Mm4}

[Spiffeh]

I actually like that list a lot.

Glad we're neighbors

[Spiffeh]

Except Mario is town and itle should be your #1 choice.

A Saki lynch wouldn't be the worst thing in the world though.

[Rogue]

I mean if I have to I'll comprise on Itle, but rather have Saki first if I can. The fact i can't even get the wagon going speaks wonders.

- R

[Rogue]

TITUS
ANTI

ASSEMBLE.

[Titus]

VOTE: Saki

Prefer Saki to pip.

Strongly prefer Mario but I don't see the point in pip, Conftown on it not withstanding.

[Flay Gunnar]

Cold Pizza and Gilgamesh King Of Heroes have been prodded!

[CharlotteBebe]

You can stop being smug. It actually doesn't look good on you.

Just saying, but if we lynch Saki. I will promise fresh cookies (of your choice) to everyone on the wagon.

~R

im not being smug.
im just being amused.

can you articulate your saki read more clearly?
why exactly is he scum?

[3dicerolling]

^this please. I'd like to hear more of your reasoning before I (CHOO CHOO) vote saki.

[Saki]

pdodge

[Saki]

oh and a quick reply (phoneposting, soz) to mara

ftr, effortsaki was never alignment indicative
i was never consistent enough a player to be meta'd
and this is my first game of mafia since i was banned for fire emblem back in 2013
so two years have gone by since ive last played

please tell me you have something other than meta to lynch me for

[3dicerolling]

I apologise but I do not get it is kind of vague. What is there to not get about it. Looks pretty simple to me. Itlepip commented silly when he should have commented on the events. This in turn bothered spif. So spif voted on him and got a mini wagon started for no reason. Itlepip attempted to confront him about the reason for the train and spif said basically that his reaction was enough to justify the train.

It looks to me like a lucky mistake. I know how frustrating it is to be in that position itlepip was in and with no real case sitting on him the train does not make sense to me. There is the case in a nutshell.

Although to be fair to you Mario. You joined that train for a while for no real reason.

There is definitely reasoning behind the wagon. The way you are talking is as if you are only reading through a certain page. Lucky mistake literally makes no sense whatsoever. You need to elaborate more.

@Itlepip - I'm going to respond to you later when I can get on a computer, where I can quote better and look at the thread easier.

I'm also not a fan of the MM4 wagon, but I do think Titus is town. Still scumreading Rogue slot.

i apologize but I get a bad feeling from this lynch. I feel pretty sure it is going to come up townie. Since you clearly are well clued in on the reasons perhaps you can explain it for me because I do not see anyone joining the train for really well thought out reasons.

Not sure why you are apologizing. I'm also not sure why you are asking me to answer a question I just asked you?

[3dicerolling]

That innocent child is cold pizza

Who hasn't posted in ages and isn't in any way leading town to victory.

I must agree they are quite quiet.

heh 'quite quiet'


in before spiffeh or 3die yell at me for making a joke post, 3die, you haven't developed any more reads than I have, and I have explained most of mine.

I didn't even vote you for the joke post. You are acting like spiffeh and I have a war against jokes. I voted you for the reaction to your own wagon. I was also intrigued to see how more pressure would affect you, and you got really quiet during that period of time. That is why my vote is on you. I also have not liked where your votes have landed this game.

[Cold Pizza]

Dodge for a day.

Also whoever said effort saki is scum.

We're talking about someone who haven't played in a good while. I mean, a good while.
So applying old as h meta is uh

[Maxous]

OK.
I swear I'm going to reread the thread and I'm going to force myself to get reads.

So this is the best I can get, mostly from gut;

MarioManiac4
Cold Pizza
Spiffeh
Maxous
CharlotteBebe
notscience
Saki
3dicerolling
Titus
Antihero
Gilgamesh King of Heroes
itlepip
Suzune

So;
VOTE: Suzune

Is that all you got Mario?

unfortunately.

Wait who is this gilgamesh guy and why does nobody seem to talk about him?

Also, on the scuminess of miller claims; I see them as almost exclusively town. I know some scum go ahead and do it anyway, but not so many.
The quality of scum seems to be fairly high in the game, from my lack of finding scumreads. I don't think they'd claim a role that would almost certainly end up getting them lynched anyway. The way Maxous did it, just saying "I'm miller" and not milking the towncred dry, is far more likely to come from town, IMO.
In fact you can put Maxous above Spiffeh in the list.

Pedit: Mostly just awkwardness.
I'd like a response on why so I can delve into that. Sometimes one hole in the scum-ship can end up propping others and sinking it.

these posts look pretty town

[Maxous]

CB is probably town too but I would be a bit more cautious about that read.

While I'm at it, ill say that NS and 3DR round up the rest of my town-reads currently.

Saki seems very town to me.

/opinion

uhh let's see here is where I was at last

[Maxous]

yeah ok,

Suzune, itlepip or Antihero

that's my lynchlist

[Maxous]

above is basically the 3 "least town" of the game

[itlepip]

Holy shit Maxous you got pocketed there. In your 'why mario is town' all he did is post an ordering of names with no reasoning and then said that you are town and that is all you need to shout "MARIO IS CONF TOWN GUYZ"

[Cold Pizza]

People should really get in this game and post their aversion to the ittlepip wagon.

Things have been grinding along real slow-like for a Day 1.
This feels like a scum-wagon feels, where it takes that extra 'oomph' of a push to knock it over the ledge.

@Itle: Pretty sure Maxous covered more than just the reads list there. If he's getting buddied, it's probably also due to how Mario handled the Miller claim.

[itlepip]

People should really get in this game and post their aversion to the ittlepip wagon.

Things have been grinding along real slow-like for a Day 1.
This feels like a scum-wagon feels, where it takes that extra 'oomph' of a push to knock it over the ledge.

@Itle: Pretty sure Maxous covered more than just the reads list there. If he's getting buddied, it's probably also due to how Mario handled the Miller claim.

The posts he quoted in 766 were "I dunno what the game is" the list of people with no evidence or explanation and then "hey I think maxous's miller claim is super towny". Saying that that any of those posts is towny is baffling to me, and the only one that had anything that could be read was the Maxous buddying, which it looks like MM4 completely bought.

[Maxous]

The posts read as genuine overwhelmed town.
I don't think he's scum-faking it.

[itlepip]

The posts read as genuine overwhelmed town.
I don't think he's scum-faking it.

Like, I think you are town here since I don't think that scum would throw out that MM read, but I don't see how any of his three posts are towny at all.