Prozac's Basic Theme 4 - Murder in Marlowe - OVER!

[curiouskarmadog]

Anyway, focusing on the game again, Bins is still scum.

tell me why again...give me 3 points why Bins is scum.

what are your thoughts on KMD(slot)?

[notscience]

I'm curious about that too.

[Davsto]

Often pushing the counterwagons to scum, jumping on scum every now and again when it's convenient.
That whole "even if he's scum..." feels like scum getting ready to push people who pushed Espe but trying to act nonchalant and like "oh yeh even if he's scum which he isn't but just in case he is...".

That's two, can't think of a third.

I'll leave KMD until they've caught up. It's hard to get an idea on replacements when they've made very few posts and I don't remember having too strong of a read on CDB.

[Porochaz]

Caitlin started researching how to get started. She became obsessed about how to pull it off without getting caught. She didn't sleep, she didn't eat. She found a drug-dealer to help give her something to keep her awake, and that's where she found her opportunity to make her first kill. She pulled it off without a hitch, and stole a large quantity of Prozac to boot. Noone would expect renowned philanthropist Caitlin Hay of killing a drug dealer in his home.

Vote Count 3.02

xRECKONERx

(3): mykonian, pirate mollie, Spiffeh

Kmd4390

(2): notscience, curiouskarmadog

Bins

(2): Davsto, Flameaxe

Not Voting

(5): scotmany12, xRECKONERx, Kmd4390, Starbuck, Bins

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-11-22 21:00:00)

[Spiffeh]

Where does she push counterwagons to scum?

[Davsto]

Eventually all the neighbours were cleared of any wrong doing. However the scars of Dereks betrayal remained. The neighbours viewed each other with suspicion and stopped talking to one another. What were they up to behind their doors?

Votecount 1.10

-
Pirate Mollie -3 - CDB, Starbuck, Reck
Flameaxe - 3 - MattP, Bins, AJ the Epic
AJ - 3 - Spiffeh, Davsto, catboi
Davsto - 2 - Papa Zito, Scotmany
notscience - 1 - Nexus
MattP - 1 - Flameaxe

Not voting - 5 - mykonian, Marquis, Mollie, notscience, curiouskarmadog

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.

Deadline in (expired on 2015-10-23 14:00:00)

Nexus is v/la until Monday

Voting BBM, counterwagon to AJ.

Votecount 1.19

-
notscience - 5 - Nexus, Zito, Davsto, Flameaxe, scot
MattP - 5 - Marquis, catboi, notscience, spiffeh, Espy
Pirate Mollie - 3 - CDB, Starbuck, Reck,
Espy - 2 - MattP, Myko
mykonian - 2 - mollie, ckd
Davsto - 1 - Bins

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.

Deadline in (expired on 2015-10-24 14:00:00)

At this point, she is parked on me (who was once a counterwagon to MattP IIRC?), and then when suddenly MattP gains traction...

Votecount 1.20

-
MattP - 9 - Marquis, catboi, spiffeh, Bins, scotmany, notscience, ChannelDeliBird, Papa Zito, pirate mollie
mykonian - 3 - xRECKONERx, Espeonage, curiouskarmadog
notscience - 3 - Nexus, Davsto, Flameaxe
Pirate Mollie - 2 - Starbuck, mykonian
Espy - 1 - MattP,

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.

Deadline in (expired on 2015-10-24 14:00:00)

Bam, she's on him.

As Ethan lay down to sleep, he had seen the two feet sticking out behind the curtain, but seeing how everything had gone wrong, he decided it was probably for the best and fell asleep for the last time.

Votecount 2.06

Davsto

(5): Spiffeh, Flameaxe, Bins, scotmany, zito

Espeonage

(3): Starbuck, Davsto, pirate mollie

scotmany12

(1): ChannelDelibird

Starbuck

(1): Espeonage

ChannelDelibird

(1): notscience

Not Voting

(5): xRECKONERx, Nexus, curiouskarmadog, catboi, mykonian,

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

Pushing me counterwagon to Espe

Votecount 2.11

Davsto

(4): Bins, scotmany12, Papa Zito, xRECKONERx

Espeonage

(4): Starbuck, Davsto, catboi, pirate mollie

ChannelDelibird

(3): Nexus, Spiffeh, notscience

Bins

(2): Flameaxe, mykonian

scotmany12

(1): ChannelDelibird

Starbuck

(1): Espeonage

Not Voting

(1): curiouskarmadog

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

Deadline is (expired on 2015-11-08 19:00:00)

Ditto.

[pirate mollie]

I think Reck is being overly self-conscious and it seems like clearing his own name is more important to him than finding scum. Still not a fan of his or Bins' reaction to the Espy hammer because it looked like forced anger when they definitely couldn't have felt so certain about Espe so I wouldn't be surprised if at least one of them faked it.

Uhhh please tell me, oh arbiter of truthiness, how I

definitely

couldn't have felt so certain about Espe? Because I wouldn't have hammered that claim in a million fucking years. Let me play this game again, I'd do it the same.

Mollie, convince me on why reck is scum, plz.

he isn't this wrong in games.

like ever.

Are you high?

THIS

is your grand push against me? Uh, I could go through here and link all the games where I'm wrong and how me saying "I think XXX is town therefore they are probably scum" has become a self-fulfilling meme at this point. Are you conflating F2F mafia and forum mafia again? Oh dear.

plz link all the games that you were wrong in.

consider it a fun exercise.

[Flameaxe]

I especially like the part where this logic is still awful regardless

[pirate mollie]

I really don't see how my play was "bad" yesterday, yes it was a bit wobbly at times but in the end I helped lynch scum and honestly the end results are super duper more important than how we reached them.

I agree with you that this back and forth is not helping. lets talk about end game.

[Flameaxe]

That quote basically sums up all 120 pages here

[Nexus]

stop being knobs ffs

[xRECKONERx]

I think Reck is being overly self-conscious and it seems like clearing his own name is more important to him than finding scum. Still not a fan of his or Bins' reaction to the Espy hammer because it looked like forced anger when they definitely couldn't have felt so certain about Espe so I wouldn't be surprised if at least one of them faked it.

Uhhh please tell me, oh arbiter of truthiness, how I

definitely

couldn't have felt so certain about Espe? Because I wouldn't have hammered that claim in a million fucking years. Let me play this game again, I'd do it the same.

Mollie, convince me on why reck is scum, plz.

he isn't this wrong in games.

like ever.

Are you high?

THIS

is your grand push against me? Uh, I could go through here and link all the games where I'm wrong and how me saying "I think XXX is town therefore they are probably scum" has become a self-fulfilling meme at this point. Are you conflating F2F mafia and forum mafia again? Oh dear.

plz link all the games that you were wrong in.

consider it a fun exercise.

Uh, no -- I have better things to do with my time, and it's evident enough if you look at basically any game in the past...two years. I thought I was past the days of people trying to lynch me because "Reck is better than this! He's rarely wrong! He always catches scum!" but apparently not.

[Starbuck]

To address Davsto's #2952, I wasn't saying you were bad at the game and my post that you quoted says is exactly what I meant. I wanted you to replace out for someone who would actually contribute. Your contribution was the problem, not your play. You were making every excuse in the book to not contribute and thus, becoming a distraction.

There's a difference with being frustrated about your lack of contribution and saying that you are bad at the game. I'm not sure how that message got construed from "Starbuck dislikes Davsto's lack of contribution" to "Starbuck thinks Davsto is bad at the game" because that's not what I think at all.

[Starbuck]

I think Reck is being overly self-conscious and it seems like clearing his own name is more important to him than finding scum. Still not a fan of his or Bins' reaction to the Espy hammer because it looked like forced anger when they definitely couldn't have felt so certain about Espe so I wouldn't be surprised if at least one of them faked it.

I agree with this wholeheartedly. As much as I love Reck, I haven't really been all that impressed with him. I need to do a full ISO of him today to give you guys some more detail on that.



Davsto, if you could really just drop the AtE and woe is me, things would be so much better. Like the points you brought up yesterday on Espy were spot on. The points you are bringing up on Bins, currently, are spot on. More of that and less of the other distracting B.S. When you contribute, you contribute good stuff, so stay on that track. Please?

[xRECKONERx]

Uhhh please tell me, oh arbiter of truthiness, how I definitely couldn't have felt so certain about Espe? Because I wouldn't have hammered that claim in a million fucking years. Let me play this game again, I'd do it the same.

[xRECKONERx]

everyone pretending the espe claim was OMG SUPER SCUM needs a fucking reality check. it looked legit, his claim made sense in progression with how he went from targeting me to saying he's a hider, and anyone pretending otherwise to try and cast shade elsewhere needs rope

[Spiffeh]

I don't think your reaction made sense for someone who was going back and forth on Espy all day.

[Spiffeh]

That's not my only reason for scum reading you either.

[pirate mollie]

everyone pretending the espe claim was OMG SUPER SCUM needs a fucking reality check. it looked legit, his claim made sense in progression with how he went from targeting me to saying he's a hider, and anyone pretending otherwise to try and cast shade elsewhere needs rope

I haven't seen a scummier claim like that since serene in graveyard shift.

and while you might THINK it might make you look town I think the opposite.

[Bins]

Man, I forgot about SK being really likely.

This changes a lot. Doh.

[Bins]

Uhhh please tell me, oh arbiter of truthiness, how I definitely couldn't have felt so certain about Espe? Because I wouldn't have hammered that claim in a million fucking years. Let me play this game again, I'd do it the same.

^^^^^
^
^^
^
^
^
^
^^

[Spiffeh]

Bins I just explained that (for Reck's case anyway)

Idk how you felt about Espy the whole day.

The reaction is still unnatural either way imo

[Bins]

I don't think your reaction made sense for someone who was going back and forth on Espy all day.

It really does. I could be scum reading someone really hard and if they claim hider and have it that built up I would let them live another day.

And you're willing to believe that Espe had a SETUP (man, I would believe it if it was pulled out of his ass as a gambit) "investigative innocent" on his buddy? I guess I could see it. But ughgh... what if we had believed his claim and Reck wasn't NK'd and then we lynched one of them and they flipped scum? That would be horrendous for them.

[Bins]

SK being likely means I shouldn't be giving townreads to the people who were super "not-Espe" buddies. This... is a big list of people. Dammit.

[Spiffeh]

True I did forget about his innocent claim on Reck.

Idk that does make me question it more