You could be Anyone IV - GAME OVER

[Elyse]

Random's speculation is giving me doubt about Alchemist. It seems like he knows something didn't go right wrt the NKs and is trying to figure it out/get someone to say something. I'm racking my brain trying to figure out if there's some way SG didn't hide behind Alch. Due to flavor, grapes was most likely a vig kill and SG was the scum kill. This means that scum killed whoever she hid behind, but that person didn't die or she hid behind scum. Why would they kill Alchemist? It makes no sense. Even if they found the crumb, how did Alch not die? I guess we'll have to see his claim. So him being scum is definitely the most viable option.

Still, random's vote on PS is terribad and I don't understand how he could possibly think she is scum, from any PoV. If he is scum, maybe he knows that he targeted SG and she still died, hence the "maybe SG no-actioned?" Or maybe he's SK and shot Alchemist and doesn't know why he survived? Or he's scum and knows Alch isn't and is WKing him?

Idk I can't really think of a scenario where Alch

isn't

scum, but random is seriously breaking my scumdar and making me question it.

[PeregrineV]

My activity is my vote today.

Vote: Alchemist

[Errantparabola]

phoneposting. i'll come up with something coherent in a few hours

[jasonT1981]

Official Vote Count

Alchemist21

(8): T S O, Varsoon, Passionate Storm, Extrapolated Eagle, Elyse, Shiro, Garmr, PeregrineV

Passionate Storm

(1): randomidget

Not Voting

(8): I Am Innocent, inte, TheWayItEnds, Errantparabola, Alchemist21, Aneninen, Aunt Jemina, My Other Head Is Scum

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

Mod Note - Getting battered by Storm Frank, electric keeps going out. Will send a PM to my backup if it gets any worse.

[Varsoon]

Don't send a doctor my way either; such mundane tools can't heal the wounds a Sith may inflict upon me.

[T S O]

Dear idiots: look at the goddamn flavour for the nightkills. There are three (3) different kinds. Blood is obviously the SK, Mafia kill flavour is the same as it's ever been in YCBA games to date, so grapes was clearly a vig shot.

[My Other Head Is Scum]

Ugh, I need to be on my main. For this game.

Okay, what exactly am I missing so far.
Why Alchemist?

He is at L-1, and I dont' remember reasons why...

-Fire

[Elyse]

Read the game.

*war flashbacks to badass females micro*

But it seems like SG hid behind Alch and she was a hider and died last night.

[My Other Head Is Scum]

*war flashbacks to badass females micro*

I hate reading.

I did a bit of catchup, I am fine with this:

VOTE: Alchemist

Sorry Alch.

Cya all tomorrow, thats all folks, etc.

-Firebringer
The Scummiest Head in Existence.

[Elyse]

Waiting for a claim would have been nice

[My Other Head Is Scum]

Waiting for a claim would have been nice

You can yell at me tomorrow if he flips town.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Or anything. Waiting for anything would be nice.

At least until we got to talk to EP.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Yeah I'd like to do something and move somewhere for once before a quicklynch. Oh well. I guess everyone is pretty much done with this game.

[T S O]

I rather grudgingly accept Anen's response to my question.

I'm going to again advocate for an inte modkill - he is not playing whatsoever.

[T S O]

Well, another lurker, another hammer.

[Elyse]

Yeah I also would have liked to hear errant speak, though I don't understand eagle's attitude. We lynched scum day 1 and just lynched near confscum. We're in good shape. Well, town is at least.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Yeah I also would have liked to hear errant speak, though I don't understand eagle's attitude. We lynched scum day 1 and just lynched near confscum. We're in good shape. Well, town is at least.

I just hate feeling like I'm not doing anything.

And Titus I'm not mad at you for lynching town yesterday.

[Shiro]

Finally

[Alchemist21]

Hope this isn't locked before I respond.

I'm a VT. I think EE is on the Townier side of my spectrum again since Dapper was Town. Also looking at Shiro, AJ, TSO, PS, and Anen as the Towniest players that come to mind.

Not sure what to make of Varsoon's claim (I would have probably voted him today before hearing it). This is all off the top of my head before the thread gets locked.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

I guess I should just admit that I hate lynching people. No matter how sure I am someone is scum (and I would bet my mafia career on alchemist being scum) I always just think: maybe it's different. Maybe there's a bigger picture to see. I just want to see the whole picture. :/

Alch any scum reads?

[Alchemist21]

Quick review of some things in my notes - Garmr is also likely Town.

EP, Inte, and TWIE should probably get more attention tomorrow.

If this thread still isn't locked I'll try to figure out this hider mess.

[Alchemist21]

I guess I should just admit that I hate lynching people. No matter how sure I am someone is scum (and I would bet my mafia career on alchemist being scum) I always just think: maybe it's different. Maybe there's a bigger picture to see. I just want to see the whole picture. :/

Alch any scum reads?

No scum reads unfortunately, but many people were completely off my radar this whole time (see previous post), so there's probably a good number of scum in them.

[Alchemist21]

Only weak hiders die from targeting mafia according to the WIKI. Gwen't role was statwd to be regular hider. I'm still not sure why she would be dead and not me or whoever she targeted if it wasn't me.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Only weak hiders die from targeting mafia according to the WIKI. Gwen't role was statwd to be regular hider. I'm still not sure why she would be dead and not me or whoever she targeted if it wasn't me.

....

....

Wait a minute.

So then you were basically confirmed town?

[Alchemist21]

@Passionate Storm; How did you know of Gwen's hider innocent on you?

P-edit: I don't know if that confirms me or not, it just doesn't confirm me as scum.