You could be Anyone IV - GAME OVER

[Elyse]

TSO's 3148 is pretty damning, IMO.

Can people explain townreads on Eagle? I've been going back and forth with him.

At this point, I've put PS, TSO, Aneninen, Garmr, Varsoon, and TWIE in my townpile.

[Randomnamechange]

TSO's 3148 is pretty damning, IMO.

Can people explain townreads on Eagle? I've been going back and forth with him.

At this point, I've put PS, TSO, Aneninen, Garmr, Varsoon, and TWIE in my townpile.

I cant really to be honest. He just seemss genuine.

[jasonT1981]

Official Vote Count

Extrapolated Eagle

(4): Garmr, Shiro, T S O, Passionate Storm

Errantparabola

(2): Extrapolated Eagle, randomidget

randomidget

(2): Varsoon, Aneninen

I Am Innocent

(1): Elyse

My Other Head Is Scum

(1): Errantparabola

Not Voting

(5): I Am Innocent, TheWayItEnds, ZZZX, My Other Head Is Scum,PeregrineV

Day 4 Deadline

(expired on 2016-01-19 14:09:44)

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

Jason - hypothetically, if a Strongman targets a Hider who is hiding behind someone else, what would be the result?

Apologies, I missed this first time reading. If a strongman targets the hider, and the hider hides, the hider is hidden and therefore would not die. The only way a hider can die, is if they hide behind scum nullifying their hiding ability leaving them open to night actions (and in the process dying even if not targeted) or hiding behind someone, who is themselves targeted for the kill.

[Passionate Storm]

TSO's 3148 is pretty damning, IMO.

Can people explain townreads on Eagle? I've been going back and forth with him.

At this point, I've put PS, TSO, Aneninen, Garmr, Varsoon, and TWIE in my townpile.

Well, we both agree Aneninen is scum. Why do you think he's town?

[Elyse]

For me it goes back to his Clotilde gambit. It seems like something he wouldn't do as scum and it looked like an attempt to solve the game. Since then his posts haven't really wowed me but they aren't scummy either.

[TheWayItEnds]

i dont understand how people are town reading varsoon still.

[Randomnamechange]

Yeah, Varsoon should be at best null.

[T S O]

Let's just say it - he seems like the vig. That's it. There's no point hiding it because literally -everyone- is thinking the same.

[T S O]

TSO's 3148 is pretty damning, IMO.

Can people explain townreads on Eagle? I've been going back and forth with him.

At this point, I've put PS, TSO, Aneninen, Garmr, Varsoon, and TWIE in my townpile.

Yes, yes, quite likely, also fairly likely, I guess and yeah.

[T S O]

I mean - Varsoon has somehow survived to d4 despite being the most obvious vig there is, which is sorta admirable in its own right.

[T S O]

I'm not trying to direct vig shots because I'd bet scum have some way of nullifying it.

[T S O]

Though, aside from a Doctor, I guess it's all irrelevant, since they'll just target Varsoon. Hmm.

[TheWayItEnds]

Is that what we're thinking?

Oh.

[Passionate Storm]

For me it goes back to his Clotilde gambit. It seems like something he wouldn't do as scum and it looked like an attempt to solve the game. Since then his posts haven't really wowed me but they aren't scummy either.

When's the last gamesolvey post they had?

I am quite alarmed at our level of agreement....

[Elyse]

I was talking about the Clotilde thing.

[PeregrineV]

Mmm. Look at his interest in the Elyse wagon when Klingon becomes viable lynch. And then his sudden forgetting of the topic. Also watch how is reads on people flip back and forth literally from post to post.

He seems to mostly have a townread on Elyse that matches yours. Other than a post or to, it doesn't seem like much disagreement between you two.

And flipflopping on people is, recently and unfortunately, pretty often town behavior.

Unless you got specifics, still not my first choice for lynch today.

(Who is, you ask, if you haven't yet?)

Not sure. Want to actually ISO Kling for leads, but need to finish this close week.

[PeregrineV]

Invalidate my premises, and my confidence wanes.

Yup. I still think scum piled on Spifflop and itlepipitlepip and alchemist. EE fits that bill.

PV also fits due to vote pattern.

Is this like the third random jab for the third random reason?

@Jason, If a Hider hides behind a Mafia Godfather, and assuming no other action on the Hider or GF, will the Hider die?

[PeregrineV]

@TSO

- Currently thinking that Eagle doesn't seem like scum. I saw your giant post on it, and will have to go back and analyze and argue before I vote for him.

[jasonT1981]

Invalidate my premises, and my confidence wanes.

Yup. I still think scum piled on Spifflop and itlepipitlepip and alchemist. EE fits that bill.

PV also fits due to vote pattern.

Is this like the third random jab for the third random reason?

@Jason, If a Hider hides behind a Mafia Godfather, and assuming no other action on the Hider or GF, will the Hider die?

Hiding behind any mafia, regardless of their role will result in death, as well as leave the hider open to night actions.

[Elyse]

Shiro's absence is making me question him as well

[PeregrineV]

Invalidate my premises, and my confidence wanes.

Yup. I still think scum piled on Spifflop and itlepipitlepip and alchemist. EE fits that bill.

PV also fits due to vote pattern.

Is this like the third random jab for the third random reason?

@Jason, If a Hider hides behind a Mafia Godfather, and assuming no other action on the Hider or GF, will the Hider die?

Hiding behind any mafia, regardless of their role will result in death, as well as leave the hider open to night actions.

@Jason- thx!

@PS- Talk to me if you want a response. Or not.

[T S O]

Wait, so:

If a Hider hides behind a Mafia, and the Mafia shoots the Hider, the Hider dies by Mafia kill?

[T S O]

I think this may be the correct scenario, at last.

[Shiro]

Shiro's absence is making me question him as well

Excuse me absence ? I didn't post for one page and you call that absence ? Seesh

[Shiro]

Like not posting doesn't mean I am not here reading