Newbie 1687 (Game Over)

[notachipmunk]

I'm here too, gg you 2, hawkleader was right all along haha.

[Drixx]

The deciding factor was that your fake analysis didn't appear to at all consider the scenario where I was telling the truth, which made that big post of yours look like it was designed to get Reubus to vote me. If you had made that post look like you were open to all possibilities, I almost certainly would have voted Reubus, because I couldn't get him to engage and give me what I was looking for to read.

You nearly pulled it out. I sat here for awhile trying to decide which of you to vote.

[notachipmunk]

I would have done the same thing if I went along with you and said why Reubus is scum, would have left out the other scenario. I didn't really think that through I suppose. That's legit just how I saw what you were asking

[Drixx]

I am for real super embarrassed that I actually forgot I was the BP. What were you thinking when no BP claimed? You knew there was one right?

[notachipmunk]

yeah, once the mafia PT is released you'll see what I was thinking since I was talking to myself for like 3 pages lol. I thought Frog was the BP, I was very certain of it actually. You claiming that late messed my plan up a bit, I didn't mean to NK Frog - I thought it would result in a no kill.

[Zaicon]

Final Vote Count - Day 4

notachipmunk (2):

Reubus Swagrid, Drixx

No Vote (1):

notachipmunk

notachipmunk,

Mafia Roleblocker

, has been lynched!

Drixx,

Town 1-Shot Bulletproof

, wins the game!
Reubus Swagrid,

Vanilla Townie

, wins the game!
PantherPunt, PhantomCobalt, FrogSC2, kagesong, and Rufus Delorian also win the game.

Night 1 Actions

Rufus Delorian jails FrogSC2.
notachipmunk kills PantherPunt.
notachipmunk roleblocks Rufus Delorian.

Night 2 Actions

Rufus Delorian jails kagesong.
notachipmunk kills FrogSC2.
notachipmunk roleblocks Rufus Delorian.

Night 3 Actions

Rufus Delorian jails Drixx.
notachipmunk kills Rufus Delorian.

Mafia Thread
Dead Thread

[Reubus Swagrid]

YES

[Reubus Swagrid]

I am for real super embarrassed that I actually forgot I was the BP. What were you thinking when no BP claimed? You knew there was one right?

I'm sorry for my BM reaction to your forgetting of being the BP

[Reubus Swagrid]

Actually want to slit my writs, I've never played as scum before

[Reubus Swagrid]

REUBUS IS SCUM!!!!!!!!!!!! REMEMBER THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! REUBUS IS SCUM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Meme

[Reubus Swagrid]

I'm scum for hammering. Wait a moment...

That being said, the remaining town now needs to hammer me immediately with FOS on whoever does not vote on me and Drixx.

Trapped

Meme

[Reubus Swagrid]

Multiple people, especially newer players, attack and accuse me of scum convincingly now.

I'll give you a jump start:
I'm attacking Drixx, the leader of the Pam train. Use that and content as fuel for your arguments.
I've asked players questions, question my motives for those prods and reasonings for those questions.

I really thought I was the leader of the Pam train as per this post:

And also because it seems like everyone wants a Drixx lynch but everyone who hasn't voted is scared they'll look bad jumping on now.

VOTE: literallypam

This is RVS, nobody said they wanted a Drixx lynch. Also you're jumping on now? There is no case for Drixx being scum so jumping on this 'wagon' that has no substance would look bad, which is what you seem do be doing.

but whatever floats your boat

You sunk your battleship.

You want lock clear (pending scum flip) before going into the night that bad?

Meme

[Reubus Swagrid]

The deciding factor was that your fake analysis didn't appear to at all consider the scenario where I was telling the truth, which made that big post of yours look like it was designed to get Reubus to vote me. If you had made that post look like you were open to all possibilities, I almost certainly would have voted Reubus, because I couldn't get him to engage and give me what I was looking for to read.

You nearly pulled it out. I sat here for awhile trying to decide which of you to vote.

What could I have given you?

[Drixx]

A case against me and/or chipmunk. The point of my request was for me to be able to see the underlying thinking. Generally the hardest thing for town in the endgame is getting everyone to engage enough that the town players can evaluate people from scratch.

[DeathRowKitty]

Drixx's bulletproof claim basically made him immune from lynch on the final day. If Drixx's claim was real, the jailkeeper became useless due to the existence of a scum roleblocker. That made Drixx the only plausible jailkeep target on the final night of the game. I was surprised to see chipmunk go after him on the final day, since I really think that Drixx bringing that up would have been checkmate if they'd wound up crossvoting.

Shhh, don't mind me, just an irrelevant spectator

[FrogSC2]

GG all,

@Reubus , I didn't want to give you lock clear because it would set you up as a prime night kill.

I just discovered dead chat... Panther was there for a long time.

"Frog- you can't post that much in games on this site. This is not MU." - Panther

^ Just wait until I break post count records for the 2+2 POG game.

The pace of this game is something I have to get used to.

Just for comparison, in the time I subbed in until now, I've completed 5 other non-turbo games:
1) Cheeeeese - 13 player standard with 1 cop - MU (Win) [Town]
2) Super Smash Bros Mash - 50er mishmash - MU (Win) [Scum]
3) Pirates of the Caribbean - 21er semi-open - MU (Win) [Town]
4) Shots Shots Shots - 9 players shots game - MU (

Loss to Panther you SOAB

) [Town]
5) Firebringers Improvised Game - 9 player upick closed setup - SC2 (Win) [Scum]

[Reubus Swagrid]

A case against me and/or chipmunk. The point of my request was for me to be able to see the underlying thinking. Generally the hardest thing for town in the endgame is getting everyone to engage enough that the town players can evaluate people from scratch.

I really didn't think I needed to justify myself and my actions would speak for themselves. I can see why you would ask for reads but really it was not much more difference than flipping a coin. Either trust your claim or don't. Chipmunk was a Null for me all game and I had a townish read on you

[Drixx]

@Frog - I came from a site that used 48 hour days with 24 hour nights, so the pace here was a huge adjustment for me as well. You want a laugh ... go find my earliest games and see the huge wall posts I used to make.

[kagesong]

I want to know............... What made me seem so scummy?

[notachipmunk]

I'm so happy Panther and kage said stuff in the dead thread. I figured it would be full on Frog or totally empty, and I like reading through the stuff on those so woot!
Although I definitely should not have NK'ed Panther, I mean it was a terrible move anyway but after reading that thread I see I really should have kept him =p
Also glad to see I'm not the only one talking to myself in an empty thread for weeks *cough* Panther *cough*

[Rufus Delorian]

Huzzah for town!

Good play chipmunk, I only thought you could be scum when you ended up with Drixx & Reubus since they were confirmed town for me

Kage, for me the main thing that made you seem scummy was the WIFOM stuff, it seemed like you were trying to confuse things or be deliberately contrary.

Not that my opinion should count for much, my game was entirely made up of dropping the ball, don't think I made a single good call, pretty fun though, reckon I'll get in on another newbie game in a month or so when I'm less busy.

Are there usually so many dropouts? That kinda confused things.

[PantherPunt]

wow I thought there was no way Drixx derped his role that hard and that it had to be a scum gambit

notachipmunk I thought you posted incredibly purely...great game to you.

Phantomcobalt's "lynch that other guy" was good comedy. not sure why he subs in games he doesn't actually play (this happened to me before where he subbed in as VT and became that day's lynch) - honorary 3rd scum!

gj Drixx and rubeus

[kagesong]

If I play scum, I want chipmunk as partner..............

[notachipmunk]

^This chipmunk is vicious and helps lynch her scumbuddy day 1, I wouldn't wanna be my own partner lol

FROGGG!!! what did you mean by this post if you happen to remember? As in, what did you want me to figure out, something about a BP claim thingy?(post 551 for reference)

"I'll ask that after you walk through everything completely, do not post it yet.
You are not a prime night kill target in the event that the game continues.
Keep your findings ready for copy paste if necessary tomorrow.
Please understand why I'm asking you to keep this to yourself instead of posting it."

[notachipmunk]

Actually I just reread it, did you mean that a goon would claim BP, whereas a roleblocker wouldn't because they know someone could counterclaim? Idk why that little paragraph had me so confused, I think it's bc I thought you were BP Frog