I also selfishly kinda want to lynch ranger to sort out my sir cakes read because her sticking him in the top tier feels like what she did with bbmolla and lld, but some other posting feels townish and I was hoping nacho would pop back up and talk about ranger
So, the thing that bothers me about the refusal to claim is that town does it too, but if ranger were town with a claim that would lose its usefulness then I would expect something to that effect. Like, if I claim then, blah blah blah, but it was just I won't claim no matter what.
I still like all the town reads I mentioned earlier. My blip about true ogre was a bit eased by his "my personal hell" comments but I stand by the complaints about a no lynch. It was never going to happen.
Pistachios needs to claim his flavor for being a miller and it bugs me that he was like I've never seen a miller claim flavor before so he wasn't. I don't remember seeing any posts that I thought were super likely town from him, but don't really remember posts anyway. Regardless, don't write someone off as town simply because they claim miller.
I still like my sir cakes scum read, and will especially so if ranger flips scum, but this is a read I don't hold toooo much stock in because I'm not completely caught up so I don't know if he did something townie and day one is not my strongest day at all. Also if Ranger is scum then my gut scum read on her predecessor is about all I expect to get right on day one, so there is that.
Oh I liked Axel's post about being able to suss out bogus claims. Not really alignment indicative but I liked it.
Not a big fan of tic tac.
Don't like mala's recent push on mirhawk about him not pushing her or only pushing when it's convenient and that it's somehow scummy for him to be pushing a different scum read because it's viable. Mala has been playing this game long enough to know that this is exactly how the game is played. You can't always get your top scum lynch, and when it's not viable at all you have to be pragmatic and do what can actually be done in the game. She knows that, so it is complete bullshit.
↑Spiffeh wrote:Cakez do you think someone's lying about it or something?
Davsto was a fruit vendor and he was scum
No I'm saying all these people are like "hurr durr scum would claim Fruit Vendor" and scum wouldn't claim that obviously since it's confirmable unless they actually were one, so I'm asking where anyone has seen a scum FV other then Dav in Paint Mafia.
Lynching Ranger will basically explode open this game in terms of reads so even though I have this sick feeling she's going to flip town lynching her is the right play here.
I demand we open with a tictac wagon tomorrow though.
I'm a big ol jerk and I have not read Pied Piper's posts with any sense of depth. (I'm really really sorry guys. I literally joined this game specifically to play with you and then I skim your posts ) What I have skimmed I've liked, but I don't have a read here that I can bank on.
↑Cerberus v666 wrote:I think people have been casing you for like 6 days, i just haven't been paying enough attention to the cases to absorb the details and reiterate them for you.
Fruit vendor.
*sigh*
Testable claim. ;-/
NAI claim? Scum fruit vendor+ other stuff? Functionally a goon, but with neutral utility that might make town think he's scum?
@Rob13: In your games, can the member of the scum team who sends in a kill ALSO use another power they have, or is the kill the only action they may take?
That information would be available to the mafia team. It is not public knowledge and varies by game.
