A Musical Mafia! (Game over)

[Dwlee99]

I guess me saying I forget stuff is just gonna be met with responses of "well you're a bad player, dwlee" lmao

[Cerberus v666]

I guess me saying I forget stuff is just gonna be met with responses of "well you're a bad player, dwlee" lmao

Forgetting stuff like people you scum read and completely ignoring them in the future? Yeah. I will call you a bad player for that.

Don't worry though, I'm generally very good at retaining information about the game, assuming I read it properly the first time, so I have unrealistic expectations.

You didn't address the tail end of my post. Are those behaviors by Mirhawk, which you said you don't remember (which is weird, because it happened before you replaced in, and I was under the impression that you didn't want to read the game, so I'm a bit confused about how you could possibly hope to recall something you may have never read), town? Are they scummy? If they're town/not scummy, what has been done in this game as far as you've seen, which is scummy? I'm trying to establish a baseline here, because I've never played with you and you just made an excuse for something which I view as undoubtedly scummy, leading me to suspect that we have very different views on what is/isn't acceptable behavior from a town slot.

[Dwlee99]

I guess me saying I forget stuff is just gonna be met with responses of "well you're a bad player, dwlee" lmao

Forgetting stuff like people you scum read and completely ignoring them in the future? Yeah. I will call you a bad player for that.

Don't worry though, I'm generally very good at retaining information about the game, assuming I read it properly the first time, so I have unrealistic expectations.

You didn't address the tail end of my post. Are those behaviors by Mirhawk, which you said you don't remember (which is weird, because it happened before you replaced in, and I was under the impression that you didn't want to read the game, so I'm a bit confused about how you could possibly hope to recall something you may have never read), town? Are they scummy? If they're town/not scummy, what has been done in this game as far as you've seen, which is scummy? I'm trying to establish a baseline here, because I've never played with you and you just made an excuse for something which I view as undoubtedly scummy, leading me to suspect that we have very different views on what is/isn't acceptable behavior from a town slot.

I don't remember those points being brought up is what I meant. And I answered that I wasn't sure what I saw so far that has been scummy except that plot gave me bad vibes when I replaced in and hiplop agrees so that's p hype.

[itlepip]

Just take my word for it dude.

[Dwlee99]

guhureihguwehiugh
i dont trust you
your avatar is a little tiny man who is going to do something weird to cause pain to my big toe.

[Cerberus v666]

Dwlee: you're saying you missed the post by itlepip at the top of the last page, where we had our discussion ? That's the post outlining the suspect behaviors by Mirhawk. How did you miss that? It was there every time you entered the thread to respond to me...

[Dwlee99]

i think i must have missed something in that post? All I recall was the stuff about the mirhawk forgetting his read.

[Dwlee99]

yea that post is all about him forgetting his dav read.

[Cerberus v666]

And pushing, in turn, seemingly indiscriminately, every single person who looked even slightly viable as a lynch.

And please stop reducing it to "forgetting his read". Let him answer for himself. You don't know if that's what happened. You're making a silly assumption which you have no reason to make, when he can come and tell us himself.

[Cerberus v666]

I mean, he does seem to have very good recall about all the events of this game. Why would he forget his Dave read, when he remembers everything else?

[Dwlee99]

And pushing, in turn, seemingly indiscriminately, every single person who looked even slightly viable as a lynch.

And please stop reducing it to "forgetting his read". Let him answer for himself. You don't know if that's what happened. You're making a silly assumption which you have no reason to make, when he can come and tell us himself.

oh gotcha

I mean, he does seem to have very good recall about all the events of this game. Why would he forget his Dave read, when he remembers everything else?

I dontttttttttttttttt knowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

[itlepip]

Why are you presuming that Mir is town here?

[Friendless Seniors]

Dwlee slot = town

Cerb slot moves down. He seems to be hella trying to take advantage of Dwlee here. I'm sorry. Fucking cerbs case is "ranger thought it"? Bullshit. This isn't town cerb.

Let's Lynch Piper.

Pip, axel etc, the important thing here is that your case seems to be based on skubird not playing well. Honestly, your points are irrelevant to alignment. Town fucks up too.

Vote actual scummy person Piper, please? Not just mislynch bait.

[Dwlee99]

Why are you presuming that Mir is town here?

I'm trying to take an objective stance on mirhawk and think everything through, you guys are the ones presuming he is scum (aka confirmation bias)

Vote actual scummy person Piper, please?

^ this

[Friendless Seniors]

Dwlee is 100% right. People forget scumreada all the time. Shit happens. Cerb knows that, and him pushing this angle is ridiculous. Same with Nacho (IMO top 10 scumhujters on site), Plotinus (spectacular)

These people pushing a case this bad is just plain scummy.

[The Pied Piper]

Who am I pushing for forgetting something?

[Dwlee99]

hiplop are you buddying me

[Friendless Seniors]

Idgaf about you

[Friendless Seniors]

Skybird.

[Friendless Seniors]

Dwlee, if anything I'm buddying skybird. You happen to be on the right track

Also something something beetlejuice re:pipers

[Dwlee99]

i didnt understand those first two posts but the third one made sense!
also true about the beetlejuice thing.

[Cerberus v666]

..naw man. This is EXACTLY the sort of shit I push people on. I don't understand why both of you, now, are insistent that forgetting about his scumread on Dave is what happened here. Let Mirhawk tell us himself. I also find it highly unlikely that you can tell me that you sincerely believe that completely dropping your top scum read for absolutely no reason is COMPLETELY NAI.

Anyways, the rest of this game though, yeah, totally not my normal town me. Sorry. Not giving it my all, so you get half-assed Cerb. My case isn't "Ranger thought it." It's, I find these points to be scummy and inconsistent for these reasons, which have been previously covered by myself and others. In addition, Ranger thought it was scum.

Dwlee: Naw, I just believe those things done by Mirhawk were acummy. I can absolutely see where they may have been done by town, but I believe it's significantly more likely to have been done by scum.

Also, FS, how am I taking advantage or dwlee? I'm mocking him at most. I dislike people who come into a game and don't want to actually catch up and know what's going on, and then have the audacity to demand more from someone else, when they can't even be bothered to know what's going on themselves.

[Dwlee99]

maybe not completely but it is null enough. I guess we'll see what mirhawk says though. I still dont really see your point with the oppurtunism because itl listed like 3 people he pushed. Doesn't seem oppurtunistic to me. And I can figure out the game through interactions with people. reading 100 some pages isnt going to do anything for me. And me asking about your scum read on mirhawk isnt very demanding?

[Friendless Seniors]

Not suspect in this context. It's bad, not suspicious? It didn't appear to be for any real gain. Just a random swap. I think that's more likely to come from town, honestly.

Okay. Glad you see it. Understand why I sucmread you...sorta? Also misinterpreted your nocking as trying to bully into getting on your side. I getchya now.

I want a big long cerbpost on your thoughts on pied Piper. Not allowing you to sit on the sidelines like this, cerb.

[Friendless Seniors]

Why are you presuming that Mir is town here?

Thoughts on Piper now.