A Musical Mafia! (Game over)

[Dwlee99]

LET HIM ANSWER FOR HIMSELF CERB

[Dwlee99]

And Joat with tracker AND tracker AND watcher doesnt make much sense

[Cerberus v666]

LET HIM ANSWER FOR HIMSELF CERB

NO because what you're talking about doesn't make any fucking sense.

And Joat with tracker AND tracker AND watcher doesnt make much sense

...

That's not true. There's nothing nonsensical about it. It's a little redundant, but considering we have a claimed cop, if a mod wanted to give a JOAT a useful investigative ability, without actually giving town an outright cop, while having a ninja+tracker+watcher group, what exactly is he supposed to give the JOAT?

[Marquis]

That's why I'm not super Pissed at you. I still wish you had waited until marquis had time to say something, she's our cop.

Someone tell me how in the world they find this to sound genuine.

I don't believe Mirhawk seriously thought he was hammered. shotty's fakehammer post didn't even make any sense with where his reads were at just a second ago.

[Dwlee99]

holy fuck cerb shhhh

[podoboq]

also I'm pretty sure I didn't hammer

I know. There's only 5 votes on him total. Shoulda kept up the act longer though shotty.

Nah I got what I want. I had reason to believe he was telling the truth, but that seemed like a good opportunity to test the waters.
VOTE: flubber feels like a good vote after the fake l-1

I have no idea why you're scumreading flubber for doing what you were doing....before you were doing it.....

[drmyshottyizsik]

also I'm pretty sure I didn't hammer

I know. There's only 5 votes on him total. Shoulda kept up the act longer though shotty.

Nah I got what I want. I had reason to believe he was telling the truth, but that seemed like a good opportunity to test the waters.
VOTE: flubber feels like a good vote after the fake l-1

I have no idea why you're scumreading flubber for doing what you were doing....before you were doing it.....

never said I scum read him. That is the point of putting pressure on them.

[podoboq]

if it is sincere it's not a reaction test or a gambit

OK, so let's assume that it wasn't a gambit or a reaction test. Flubber legit thought Mirhawk was at L-1. Why is that scummy?

[podoboq]

if it is sincere it's not a reaction test or a gambit

OK, so let's assume that it wasn't a gambit or a reaction test. Flubber legit thought Mirhawk was at L-1. Why is that scummy?

[podoboq]

also I'm pretty sure I didn't hammer

I know. There's only 5 votes on him total. Shoulda kept up the act longer though shotty.

Nah I got what I want. I had reason to believe he was telling the truth, but that seemed like a good opportunity to test the waters.
VOTE: flubber feels like a good vote after the fake l-1

I have no idea why you're scumreading flubber for doing what you were doing....before you were doing it.....

never said I scum read him. That is the point of putting pressure on them.

So you're not voting for Flubber because you think he's scum? You're voting him for some ephemeral garbage about wanting pressure on him? Why would you want to put pressure on a slot you don't think is scum? We're not in the RVS phase anymore, man.

[drmyshottyizsik]

also I'm pretty sure I didn't hammer

I know. There's only 5 votes on him total. Shoulda kept up the act longer though shotty.

Nah I got what I want. I had reason to believe he was telling the truth, but that seemed like a good opportunity to test the waters.
VOTE: flubber feels like a good vote after the fake l-1

I have no idea why you're scumreading flubber for doing what you were doing....before you were doing it.....

never said I scum read him. That is the point of putting pressure on them.

So you're not voting for Flubber because you think he's scum? You're voting him for some ephemeral garbage about wanting pressure on him? Why would you want to put pressure on a slot you don't think is scum? We're not in the RVS phase anymore, man.

the only pressure people you think are scum argument is a bad one. By that logic no one would ever do anything

[Marquis]

I mean there's a good chance shotty/True Ogre's slot could have actually been scum based on how he's playing around the Mirhawk mess but that's for later.

[Cerberus v666]

I mean there's a good chance shotty/True Ogre's slot could have actually been scum based on how he's playing around the Mirhawk mess but that's for later.

If TO/talah had been even a tiny bit less town, I would be extremely suspicious of shotty.

[SirCakez]

Actually I guess I blame several people, pup just annoys me the most.

Anyways, good luck guys. Try not to lose.

This reaction actually reads a lot like Skybird's post-hammer to me. Same "good luck guys" that's very ambiguous.

[SirCakez]

Wait shotty replaced talah.
Who'd you check?

[pistachi0n]

*sigh* Now I have to decide if Mirhawk's reaction was legitimate or not, and whether or not it overrides my concerns about his slot.

Boo.

Who doesn't pay attention to how many votes are on them? I don't buy it that Mirhawk thought he was getting lynched.

[Rob14]

Vote Count #4.3:

Mirhawk:

pistachi0n, podoboq, itlepip, Flubbernugget (4)

The Pied Piper:

Dwlee99, dramonic (2)

Dwlee99:

SirCakez (1)

Flubbernugget:

drmyshottyizsik (1)

Not Voting:

Mirhawk, The Pied Piper, Marquis, Malakittens, Cerberus v666

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

V/LA:

None.

Deadline:

(expired on 2016-05-25 21:40:00)

[Rob14]

Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS is a nonprofit organization that supports those with HIV/AIDS, leads various women's health initiatives, and provides grants to organizations benefiting those with critical illnesses. They're a great cause.

Many of the fundraising shows they do each year involve giving the audience a peak at what musicals would look like if done a bit differently. In the video below, 13-year-old Joshua Colley, who played Gavroche when the current revival of Les Miserables opened on Broadway, gets his shot as the youngest Jean Valjean in a professional production. He knocks it out of the park.

[Mirhawk]

Sigh, not dead. That's embarrassing.

[Rob14]

Malakittens was prodded.

[Mirhawk]

It was Ogre. There's a little "Search this topic" thingy up top, below where it says "A Musical Mafia! (Day 4)", to the right of the "Reply" button.

Cool thanks, I didn't know that.

This doesn't look very important, though I note Axel was perhaps poking a little at Ogre in that exchange.

[Mirhawk]

You know what? I was 100% sure you were going to dodge this question but you did by pushing the same way two other people did so you're probably going to get away with it

I haven't used my tracker yet

Any now you're confirming everything just because?

You're obviously being cagey about your role, why would it be suspicious for anyone to point that out? The fact that three people have pointed it out is a pretty clear indication that it's pretty obvious what you're doing.

[Mirhawk]

Pip do you actually want some kind of response to 5398?

It's mostly a big steaming pile of confirmation bias and you still not knowing why I was voting Skybird.

I found Axel vaguely townish all game, why would I have gone out of my way to further sort him when there were loads of other players who I was more interested in?

There's a couple questions in there, but I'm pretty certain you don't actually give a shit what my response to them would be so whatever.

[Mirhawk]

Oh ok well I am counterclaiming flubber's tracker. I await your response flubber :^)

Do you have any results from the first three nights?

[Mirhawk]

if it is sincere it's not a reaction test or a gambit

I should have stated that differently. What does the APPARENT sincerity of the L-1 have to do with his alignment? If it appears sincere, it was supposed to be. You don't know of that's because it WA a reaction test and he wanted people to believe him, or if it's because he sincerely believed it was L-1 (which I find improbable, given that there was a VC not very far back, with no votes since.)

If it WAS sincere because he somehow didn't know that, do you have any idea why scum would mame that post without knowing it was true?

Pedit: Flubber is a joat, so the assumption would be a 1 shot tracker and other abilities, versus your infinite tracking I assume, also wtf would you claim that right now when the ninja JUST died and thus your ability became especially useful?

I agree with everything in this post.