A Musical Mafia! (Game over)

[Dwlee99]

oh

[Mirhawk]

I just realized pretty much everyone who wasn't scumreading me is dead. This sucks.

That's a dumb reason Nugs. If we were talking about another player I don't think you would be able to convince me that it was more likely that I made a PT mistake over me just not remembering exactly what Piper said fifty pages ago.

Also Dwlee stop ignoring me, do you have any useful results or not?

I also want an update on Piper's supposedly devious plan to break the game open if they got some breathing room.

[Mirhawk]

well except Dwlee and Dramonic. Piper doesn't count, they're probably scum.

[Dwlee99]

Yo, can someone run by me why Dwlee deathtunneled TPP for what he saw a slight inconsistency about roles but he isn't with flubber even though its a kind of CC?

It wasn't a real CC.

@Mirhawk

[Dwlee99]

mirhawk are you on the tpp wagon?

[Mirhawk]

Man, now I have to change my spreadsheet.

No, but I can get on.

Vote: Piper

[Dwlee99]

Vote: Piper

[Flubbernugget]

For those following at home I still think Mirhawk slipped role hunting he was doing in a scum pt. This actually works perfectly if dwlee is a scum tracker too.

....

Why have you previously expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with my slot and/or the Mirhawk push if you feel that way?

Because those happened before what I'm seeing now

[Cerberus v666]

For those following at home I still think Mirhawk slipped role hunting he was doing in a scum pt. This actually works perfectly if dwlee is a scum tracker too.

....

Why have you previously expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with my slot and/or the Mirhawk push if you feel that way?

Because those happened before what I'm seeing now

<3 good answer.

[drmyshottyizsik]

For those following at home I still think Mirhawk slipped role hunting he was doing in a scum pt. This actually works perfectly if dwlee is a scum tracker too.

....

Why have you previously expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with my slot and/or the Mirhawk push if you feel that way?

Because those happened before what I'm seeing now

<3 good answer.

this is scummy

[Cerberus v666]

For those following at home I still think Mirhawk slipped role hunting he was doing in a scum pt. This actually works perfectly if dwlee is a scum tracker too.

....

Why have you previously expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with my slot and/or the Mirhawk push if you feel that way?

Because those happened before what I'm seeing now

<3 good answer.

this is scummy

Not really. I asked him why he did/didn't do something, and his explanation makes sense. I already knew the answer, but was checking to see if he was going to try to create a reason when the chronology of events is pretty clearly laid out.

[itlepip]

For those following at home I still think Mirhawk slipped role hunting he was doing in a scum pt. This actually works perfectly if dwlee is a scum tracker too.

....

Why have you previously expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with my slot and/or the Mirhawk push if you feel that way?

Because those happened before what I'm seeing now

<3 good answer.

Pip rating scale.

This post is hereby declared NAI

[Flubbernugget]

I genuinely thought Mirhawk was at L1 with my vote but I seem to have brought a stream of intentional reaction tests to the game with it and they're all fucking shit.

[Rob14]

Vote Count #4.4:

Mirhawk:

pistachi0n, podoboq, itlepip, Flubbernugget, SirCakez (5)

The Pied Piper:

Dwlee99, dramonic, Mirhawk (3)

Flubbernugget:

drmyshottyizsik (1)

Not Voting:

The Pied Piper, Marquis, Malakittens, Cerberus v666

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

V/LA:

None.

Deadline:

(expired on 2016-05-29 21:40:00)

[Mirhawk]

@flubber

That's a dumb reason Nugs. If we were talking about another player I don't think you would be able to convince me that it was more likely that I made a PT mistake over me just not remembering exactly what Piper said fifty pages ago.

I'd also like to hear from more people as to why the case I laid out on Piper yesterday is less than compelling. Assume I'm not scum for a moment, why don't you agree with it?

[drmyshottyizsik]

For those following at home I still think Mirhawk slipped role hunting he was doing in a scum pt. This actually works perfectly if dwlee is a scum tracker too.

....

Why have you previously expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with my slot and/or the Mirhawk push if you feel that way?

Because those happened before what I'm seeing now

<3 good answer.

this is scummy

Not really. I asked him why he did/didn't do something, and his explanation makes sense. I already knew the answer, but was checking to see if he was going to try to create a reason when the chronology of events is pretty clearly laid out.

In law I think this is called leading, also confirmation bias? I'm going to meta you now

[Cerberus v666]

For those following at home I still think Mirhawk slipped role hunting he was doing in a scum pt. This actually works perfectly if dwlee is a scum tracker too.

....

Why have you previously expressed a degree of dissatisfaction with my slot and/or the Mirhawk push if you feel that way?

Because those happened before what I'm seeing now

<3 good answer.

this is scummy

Not really. I asked him why he did/didn't do something, and his explanation makes sense. I already knew the answer, but was checking to see if he was going to try to create a reason when the chronology of events is pretty clearly laid out.

In law I think this is called leading, also confirmation bias? I'm going to meta you now

Confirmation bias is the interpretation of events based on a pre-existing conclusion regarding said events - that is, seeking to (consciously or not) find evidence to support a position, rather than looking at the evidence objectively and seeing what conclusion it leads you to. Asking a question with knowledge of what the simplest answer is is a very different thing; it's nothing more than giving him enough rope to hang himself with, which he didn't do.

It is, however, leading, yes. I did ask him a question which was deliberately phrased in a way that could give him cause to think there should be some other reason.

[Flubbernugget]

@flubber

That's a dumb reason Nugs. If we were talking about another player I don't think you would be able to convince me that it was more likely that I made a PT mistake over me just not remembering exactly what Piper said fifty pages ago.

I'd also like to hear from more people as to why the case I laid out on Piper yesterday is less than compelling. Assume I'm not scum for a moment, why don't you agree with it?

I would expect you to look into it

[Mirhawk]

Look into what? There's only two possible scenarios, either I'm scum and I made a PT slip or I didn't remember exactly what piper said two weeks ago.

My point is that I don't think you would be able to convince me that the former is more likely than the latter. So what makes you do sure this is the case?

[Mirhawk]

*so sure

[Mirhawk]

@cerb
You realize pretty much everything pipes said to me is heavily skewed by confirmation bias right?

[Mirhawk]

Aggh, pip. I meant pip.

I hate autocorrect sometimes.

[itlepip]

Well me having confbias doesn't make the evidence go away.

[Mirhawk]

Depends on how you look at it really.

It doesn't call the really call the argument into question so much as it makes your reason for finding scummy questionable.

[SirCakez]

>checks in
>sees lack of Pied Piper posts
>is further suspicious of said Piper
>checks out