If they're being defended from something, they're under pressure, even if that pressure is miniscule.In post 148, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:He's not even under any real pressure. How can you whiteknight someone who's not under pressure?
Because I don't think WhiteLight would defend a partner this obviously.In post 148, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:Also why are you assuming the person you're attacking is town for the purposes of attacking someone else?
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
at this point, i'm pretty certain it's a breakdown in communication and the "too sexual" thing is the flavor rc gave to accompany the self-janitor thing shotty is claiming.In post 142, Postie wrote:Lynch all liars with no town motivation to lie and potential scum motivation, yes.In post 140, WhiteLight wrote:Lynch all liars?In post 139, Postie wrote:Yes. There's no reason for him to lie about it as town.
~Suz
Can you think one is scum and one isn't?In post 154, Antihero wrote:also, i'm now scumreading both heads of whitelight
I acceptIn post 149, Gammagooey wrote:let's do it but i have a requirementIn post 126, Untrod Tripod wrote: also I'm done reading what has happened so far and my god this game is a trainwreck
Gamma, wanna posse up?
only sane people in the posse regardless of how town they are
y/n?
Personally, I am just confused. I did not defend anyone. Instead I asked you about your stance.In post 150, Postie wrote:Because I don't think WhiteLight would defend a partner this obviously.
On reread, moving Gamma into the same tier as shotty.In post 162, Postie wrote:[snip]
Yet despite this comment. We are still worth of your vote. Quick turn around on this lynch train...In post 163, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:Still have my eye on Postie. I don't agree that WhiteLight's defending of shotty is scummy, and 150 trades the assumption that shotty is town for an equally bad one that WhiteLight is scum.
And yet... that's not what I was saying. I'm trying to sort you and right now I think you are scum. (That last comment didn't help.) Postie's argument is literally "WhiteLight is scum because they are whiteknighting shotty. I know shotty is town because WhiteLight wouldn't defend their partner like that." which is like, logical fallacies out the wazoo. Doesn't mean I don't think you're scum.WhiteLight wrote:Yet despite this comment. We are still worth of your vote. Quick turn around on this lynch train...In post 163, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:Still have my eye on Postie. I don't agree that WhiteLight's defending of shotty is scummy, and 150 trades the assumption that shotty is town for an equally bad one that WhiteLight is scum.
~Suz
And Anti isn't?In post 170, Postie wrote:My role PM says I get three warnings and, while I've messed up three times now, I haven't gotten any warnings so hopefully I'm still good.
And sorry, Anti. I've never seen scum!you so I don't really know how to sort you. I mean I know I don't know the scum meta of most of the people I'm townreading, but they're, like, towny in a way I think would be difficult to fake.
Not really. My argument is that the way they're defending shotty feels unnatural, but too obvious to be scum defending scum, and therefore it feels like whiteknighting.In post 169, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:Postie's argument is literally "WhiteLight is scum because they are whiteknighting shotty. I know shotty is town because WhiteLight wouldn't defend their partner like that." which is like, logical fallacies out the wazoo.
