Open 635 - JK9++ (Game Over)

[Frozen Angel]

FA pls

Honestly, I'm having a crisis of confidence and am worried she may be scum with SC.

what about recent events made you doubt that?

[Ranger]

this is like a semi slip
Thor is not online. how you scratched him ?

It's not a slip.

In that scumteam scenario, three town are voting for SC, and therefore it takes only two scum being online to hammer.

[mhsmith0]

PS FA and I are both on, it is now impossible for there to be an FA/MHS/Thor team (since we'd quick hammer SC). More progress of sorts.

this is like a semi slip

Thor is not online. how you scratched him ?

There are three votes on SC. You and I would quick hammer SC if Thor was our teammate. Well, I guess it'd be risky with RC and Ranger hanging around, so not a total disqualifier, but IMO it's fairly disqualifying. Not a slip, sorry.

ninja'd: yep

[Ranger]

what about recent events made you doubt that?

Well, mhsmith's caution seems reasonable, but yours just seems uncharacteristic. Frankly, if you were town, I'd expect you to have voted by now.

[Frozen Angel]

oh huh

[RadiantCowbells]

FA what if Postie came on. pls just vote.

[Ranger]

I'm going to make this easy on you, FA.

We win now if you vote, guaranteed.

[Frozen Angel]

I feel uncomfortable with these sudden voting requests

what is going on here

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: SirCakez

[RadiantCowbells]

ffs FA.

[Frozen Angel]

VOTE: Sircakez

[RadiantCowbells]

That didn't need to take 17 minutes >.>

[Frozen Angel]

This was just weird

I feel RC - Ranger is not possible or a lynch on SC was happening so earlier so you two pushing this so hard was weird

[Ranger]

Glad it's over, though. <3

[mhsmith0]

Some SC highlights (I'd had some other notes, but they're less ASAP right now):

1888SC makes ridiculous theory about Titus strongarming a no kill. Back and forth with Titus ensues. I'll +1 on the plausibility of Titus's 1893, but if that's true, mafia was a day late and a dollar short. Shooting outside Titus-Ranger on N1 was extremely sub-optimal unless Titus or Ranger was mafia. I don't care how awesome Heartless is, when you're mafia you PR hunt with your kills until there are no more PR's. I suppose given that no one seemed to think Ranger was obv!doc until D2 (despite what read to me as a clear CC on D1), I may be over-thinking this. I guess it's a point against my "a 3 VT team is silly given the game state" and "why in the world would a mafia team not including Titus or Ranger shoot outside that duo on N1" take.

1902SC doubles down on this theory. No-killing for a theoretical boost to town cred for one member is a HORRIBLE idea as mafia, becuase all it takes is one doc/JK/hider save going forward, and suddenly town gets an extra lynch (also notable: in this setup as mafia you have an outside chance of double killing given a hider slot, and suddenly town LOSES a lynch).

1904AS votes SC. Makes sense.

19063dr insults SC. Makes sense.

1922Exp doubtcasts SC. Nods. It's actually pretty funny that SC wasn't lynched D3.

1932Thor defends SC, discrediting Titus on Thor and SC. Back and forth ensues. Titus looks beter than Thor/SC here.

1973Ranger calls SC obv!town. I'm not really seeing it. This may have been influenced by Ranger's read of Titus at the time though.

2003SC breaks out the chainsaw for Thor on Postie

2025Agree with Ranger about mass claim being dumb, disagree about it pointing particularly to Titus-Postie.

2177And that's why you don't say your results right away. "I claim tracker. Results to come later". That works much better. Dipoles are a good thing.

2196dead town read: SC as mafia, Titus as (null-mafia?), Ranger, RC, postie town. FA null, Thor null-town, MHS null-mafia.

2202Thor seems to prefer SC lynch to FA, calls RC, Ranger town.

2212I'm with AS rather than SC here.

2222RC really doesn't want to lynch SC.

2234I'm not sure why ANY of the VT claims on N1 would have been unlikely "to go along with the derp idea of not killing a town Titus". After SC's "I bet mafia no-killed intentionally" theory, he doesn't get to hop out of that grouping. Like, not at all.

2249Will +1 on the bizarre lack of interest in lynching SC if he was town. Just never quite gets the requisite momentum.

2268The almost immediate "let's pile on Titus" by SC start of D3 does seem pre-meditated. OTOH, it could be town too lazy to check the night actions as much as it could be wolf. Null IMO.

2435AS's lynch list: SC, FA, Thor, Postie

2522AS last will reads, wolf reads on SC/FA, nullscum on Thor

That's my day 3 notes that are SC related. Hadn't gone through D4 yet.

PS Presuming SC wagon goes through, SC flipping bus driver would mechanically clear the four PR's, SC flipping goon would mechanically mean that either it's a SC/MHS/FA team (with Thor as actual VT) or RC is a liar (or maybe that bus driver result mentioned earlier?), and SC flipping JOAT would mean that we'll likely get an extra lynch to afford anyway.

ninja'd: well I guess that doesn't matter anymore then *shrugs*

[mhsmith0]

So was it FA/RC/Ranger after all?

[Ranger]

So was it FA/RC/Ranger after all?

Well, we'll have to wait for the mod to see on that!

[Frozen Angel]

I feel terrible , baah

[Frozen Angel]

I have nothing to say.

[mhsmith0]

So was it FA/RC/Ranger after all?

Well, we'll have to wait for the mod to see on that!

i.e. "yes". Oh well. Guess RC got a really nice birthday present after all. Well, I guess you could be just trolling me.

[Ranger]

Well, I guess you could be just trolling me.

:]

[Frozen Angel]

This hammer was like the stupidest thing I ever done in all my mafia games after that cop claim in jake game...

omfg I deserve to loose

[mhsmith0]

This hammer was like the stupidest thing I ever done in all my mafia games after that cop claim in jake game...

omfg I deserve to loose

*shrugs* well, it's not a RC/Ranger/MHS team. Beyond that damned if I know. But it feels like RC/Ranger just won. So.. *shrugs*

[Frozen Angel]

They were like screaming just end the game for us

and I gave it to them! ..........................

[Frozen Angel]

although It was extremely unlikely for me to vote Ranger ever. she was like obvtown to me.

gg