New York 195: Adventure Mafia - Game over!

[EspeciallyTheLies]

ircher's newbietown AF imo.

[Egg]

I don't see why it wouldn't be allowed. Day 1 is about lynching the scummiest player regardless though. Can you tell me why Ircher is so obvtown?

[Egg]

I don't see why it wouldn't be allowed. Day 1 is about lynching the scummiest player regardless though. Can you tell me why Ircher is so obvtown?

[copper223]

@Egg
I sheep votes when you give me a case I like, how you express yourself is completely irrelevant so long as I can understand you and I'm not too prejudiced about what you are saying for whatever reason.

This might be cultural as well cause I've had the same sort of discussion with business friends in the US.

[Egg]

Meh. Can you at least see how confidence would look persuasive to most people though?

Example, which would get more votes:
"Guys, Egg is obvscum. Trust me. I'm very sure on this. I've played with him a ton and my reasons are as follows......"
Or
"I dunno. Egg looks kinda scummy I guess. He could still be town though. Meh, I guess the following are pretty decent points...."

I'm guessing the first.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

I don't see why it wouldn't be allowed. Day 1 is about lynching the scummiest player regardless though. Can you tell me why Ircher is so obvtown?

i didn't say he was obvtown. i said he looked super newbtown. and because that's how i feel about him, especially during those silly stats posts. he was trying. i think that section is probably a great place to look for opportunistic scum.

[drmyshottyizsik]

why don't you explain your motives here, shotty.

explain it to me.

Nah I think I'll be selfish and keep my reasons to myself.

ok so, i get the joke and all, but this should have been followed up with a real response, and i haven't gotten one, and it's an important question for me. what was the motive behind criticizing my scumhunting methods?

Fair enough. I feel, at least to a degree, I have explain myself. What in particular I'll be happy to expound.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

if you explained your motive for criticizing my methods, i missed it.

[drmyshottyizsik]

if you explained your motive for criticizing my methods, i missed it.

Well ultimately not to discredit what you've said, but rather present a possibly better approach. I am town reading you, I've reread your iso a couple time and I'm fair certain you are town. I just want us to be able to find scum more efficiently.

[Titus]

@Egg, Because I don't perceive ETL as doing that. ETL's laying out her evidence for why she reached her conclusions and seeing if other people reach the same place.

P.S. That "different" scumteam very rarely comes from anyone with a town PM. Just saying.

I agree that Shotty was taking a shot at ETL, trying to make her look bad. The two things are clearly different and he's trying to pain himself as equal to ETL without actually doing anything.

@Project, you like none of the wagons really?

@ETL, Your read on TBG?

[drmyshottyizsik]

also

[drmyshottyizsik]

ircher

[drmyshottyizsik]

is

[drmyshottyizsik]

dead

[Titus]

I don't see why it wouldn't be allowed. Day 1 is about lynching the scummiest player regardless though. Can you tell me why Ircher is so obvtown?

i didn't say he was obvtown. i said he looked super newbtown. and because that's how i feel about him, especially during those silly stats posts. he was trying. i think that section is probably a great place to look for opportunistic scum.

I agree with the facts here but I'd call Ircher obvtown that's really new here.

[drmyshottyizsik]

soon

[copper223]

@Egg
Saying you are 99.5% sure there is not showing confidence, it's either dumb overconfidence or scum theater, I see what you are getting at with Ircher possibly being scum pretending to do so because it looks good to be confident (this does not apply to how I read the game so my gut reaction was: this is likely dumb town talking out of their ass).

[Titus]

soon

I thought Ircher was already dead. Now he's dead sooon. Afraid you'll be turbo lynched?

[zakk]

holy thread explosion batman

[drmyshottyizsik]

soon

I thought Ircher was already dead. Now he's dead sooon. Afraid you'll be turbo lynched?

I said a while back it will take a few pages for him to bleed out.

[Titus]

soon

I thought Ircher was already dead. Now he's dead sooon. Afraid you'll be turbo lynched?

I said a while back it will take a few pages for him to bleed out.

Stop spamming. FFS. None of this bleed out shit. Ircher is town. Give some actual fucking reads, or has nothing happened in the past few pages given you a read at all?

[drmyshottyizsik]

soon

I thought Ircher was already dead. Now he's dead sooon. Afraid you'll be turbo lynched?

I said a while back it will take a few pages for him to bleed out.

Stop spamming. FFS. None of this bleed out shit. Ircher is town. Give some actual fucking reads, or has nothing happened in the past few pages given you a read at all?

You were two busy saying I think ETL is scum to see my post right before where I called him a town read?

[zakk]

not buying titus' copper stuff btw

but I do
VOTE: Copper

eh

Sup.

Titus and Icher are town.

I'm going to ignore the arguments that have already taken place and vote for the actual mafia.

Vote: TehBrawlGuy

The whole statistics discussion is stupid and doesn't read natural. Feels like a poor attempt at distancing to me, as does Ircher's "go vote shotty". VOTE: Ircher

Copper case has no real merit imo. Copper had no reason to unvote/vote anyone else, but also no reason to actually believe Ircher was more likely to be scum than anyone else at the time.

Primarily because in this post, he is setting himself up to vote for both Shotty/Ircher as opposed to taking one side. It looks like he's trying really hard to agree with both players at the same time.

Also, I want to see him under pressure.

I like your style. I think you're town.

[Egg]

ETL, meh, same thing in my opinion. town as fuck (guessing that's what af means) and obvtown both express a strong read. But anyway, you say he was "trying". Trying to do what? What about his effort reads as town and not scum?

Titus, I disagree with the idea that only scum have "different" scum team ideas. Do I really have to bring up Inuyasha mafia where you were the only one interested in lynching the claimed friendly neighbor Y+B and the person claiming to get their confirmation BBMolla? Not only were you town, but you were right which amazes me to this day. I also don't think drmy's joke was some plan with an ulterior motive to make ETL look bad. I think he was just poking fun at her.

Copper, this is weird but I think we are on the same page and really far off at the same time. But as long as we understand what the other is saying, I think we'regood because otherwise it turns into an obnoxious semantics battle that goes in circles.

[zakk]

lol whoa i just realized there were people in the OP and that isnt just an abstract picture. lol

ok cool shit. heres my reads as they are

Persivul

- seems very town. like the magna push. (this is why i should have lynched you in evo, you weren't super obvtown there, and you seem to be here.)

Ircher

- seems very town (newbtown that's looking for ways to prove his worth, and not (newb)scum looking for ways to look town). post 25 doesn't come from newbscum. post 40 doesn't come from newbscum.

Egg

- seems pretty town (and very similar to a game i just finished with him where he was town)

projectmatt

- seems town. i like how he posts and what he posts about.

TehBrawlGuy

- seems town. i like that he likes my posts. don't see what other people call him scummy for.

drmyshottyizsik

- seems annoying and narcissistic mostly. doesn't seem particularly town or scum. would lynch, regardless. i keep seeing DGB, zito, and reck, with every post he makes. #51 is an odd post to make as scum (from 2010) though.

MagnaofIllusion

- doesn't seem particularly town or scum. seems like an old fogey like jazzmyn. (and lol. chill. no i haven't played with shitty that i can recall. and i think i'd recall.) i don't really see scum making a post like 50.

Titus

- doesn't seem particularly town or scum. seems too indignant about copper-scum. idk what i have to do with that argument though i saw my name dropped about 20 times with regards to copper. titus do you usually tunnel?

heuristically_alone

- can never really accurately read this guy due to posting style. have played with him as both alignments that i can recall, can't really (be assed to try to) tell a difference in posting.

Nosferatu

-

alban

-

I Am Innocent

-

copper223

- titus brought up stuff. i went back and looked. i can kinda see it. looks like confbias though, and i'm not really into the copper wagon it looks forced. i have no real opinion on the slot

SethYazura

-

Killthestory

- funny, but annoying. no idea on alignment. wouldn't mind lynching in the first 2-3 days or so if he keeps being like he's being.

cytheflyguy

-

Aneninen

-

Desmond_13

-

Lowell

-

EspeciallyTheLies

- saw the posts. liked the posts. don't remember much about the posts. feels pretty townie

haven't caught up fully. skimmed most of the thread after p6. some things stuck out and are added in above. some things didn't. if anyone's blank that means i have like 0 read on them yet. ask me questions if you have questions. if i have an answer i'll post it if i can but i might not have much time over the next few days due to RL stuff

@mod/peeps: i'm gonna be gone most of this weekend

try not to make the thread 50 pages before sunday evening lol