Mini 1793: Freedom's Call (uPick Anything): Finale

[Antihero]

ev SHOULDN'T account for play

the extra day we had to earn by lynching scum. i think that's more than fair.

[RadiantCowbells]

I sincerely doubt that this game was townsided.

[RadiantCowbells]

Scum objectively fucked up big time.

I agree with Postie/Titus that scum should potentially have known that a governor existed.

[Party Boat]

Yeah Ircher I think you're underestimating how good it is to have one less townie to kill AND one more scum that town needs to kill (or at least needs to to have a bunch of their PRs work) than a normal setup would have.

I don't think it's fair to say that 'titus should have assumed a governor existed' but it is fair to say that titus should have played townier in general and not assumed that getting off one lynch would give scum a big advantage like it would normally, and scum got screwed in a REALLY bad way when our redirector/watcher was killed before it could do anything. If we had 3-4 scum alive day 3 I think this would have been an easy win for scum, but town chose 3 scum in the first 5 people that town could kill (postie, titus, UT, whitelight, & ircher) and there was no way scum could recover from that.

If I had to complain about something it'd be the 'confirmation' of Yume as town for a macho cop being in the setup and how little my strongman actually did to improve the scum's chances unless whoever I killed put a lot of effort into confirming that I really did have a quicktopic with them, but I don't think the game was townsided in general.

[Ranger]

If I had to complain about something it'd be the 'confirmation' of Yume as town for a macho cop being in the setup

Well, Demonic Angel's role also would not have protected me. It'd block me, but not protect me, so it didn't strictly speaking confirm Yume as town. I just thought it did because I didn't know about Demonic Angel. It did confirm at least one of {Yume, Demonic Angel} had to be telling the truth though.

Overall, I tend to agree this was town playing well, not really a town-sided game. It was still a very, very good game and I'll also be putting in some nominations for it tomorrow.

[Fate]

Next time on setup design:

Macho cop with no docs

huehuehuehuheue get fucked setup spec