Newbie 1714 (Game Over)

[Raskolnikov]

VOTE: Ranger

[Raskolnikov]

Liking zyf here. Beeboys response reads fairly relaxed though I don't know how good as scum he is.

{beeboy}
{dvds}
{Zyf, sad}

How is zyf at the bottom here?

[Raskolnikov]

{zyf}
{beeboy, dvds}
{ranger, sad}

[Zaicon]

Vote Count 1.1

Ranger (2):

beeboy, Raskolnikov

Sickofit1138 (1):

sad1492

Raskolnikov (1):

Zyf

No Vote (5):

AYaLE_, dvds12, F-oh-ex, Ranger, Sickofit1138

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!

Deadline is Wednesday, June 15, at 4:00 PM CST, which is in (expired on 2016-06-15 16:00:00).

[Zyf]

Liking zyf here. Beeboys response reads fairly relaxed though I don't know how good as scum he is.

{beeboy}
{dvds}
{Zyf, sad}

How is zyf at the bottom here?

Yay a friend
I think ranger just does it the other way 'round.
Explanation for your vote on ranger would be nice.
UNVOTE: raskolnikov VOTE: f-oh-ex
Because activity is always helpful
Also is there any "nickname" of sorts I can use for your name?

[Raskolnikov]

You can call me rask
Ranger always does it from town to scum, though it's a bit annoying because you don't know how strong the extremes of the list are at any given point.
Not particularly scumreading anyone atm but poking her is necessary.

[Zyf]

You can call me rask
Ranger always does it from town to scum, though it's a bit annoying because you don't know how strong the extremes of the list are at any given point.
Not particularly scumreading anyone atm but poking her is necessary.

Ok.
Well yeah, it is odd that she scumreads 2 and townreads 1.
Ugh, just lost a (relatively insubstantial) post. Thanks touchscreens.
Anyway, does the attitude of wanting to "coast" work as a VT? I wouldn't think so on my own since townie's goal is to find mafia, which requires discussion, right?

What about you? Experience level in mafia? Have you played pre-forum signup?

[Sickofit1138]

Boo!
VOTE: Sad

[Raskolnikov]

Wait, did you unvote me because I townread you?

[Zyf]

Boo!
VOTE: Sad

...no explanation?
Particularly interested in your reads on beeboy and ranger, in that order.

[Zyf]

Wait, did you unvote me because I townread you?

No, I unvoted you because the purpose of he vote was to get you to talk.
In case you haven't noticed yet, I'm just voting people who haven't posted.
I chose you first since as an SE you'd have more experience, and then Fox becuase sick had already been voted.

Stupid touchscreen typos

[Sickofit1138]

OMGUS.

I hAve null on both, I need to get some more info before I'm ready to make a solid read.

[Zyf]

OMGUS.

I hAve null on both, I need to get some more info before I'm ready to make a solid read.

Def agree we need some more talking.
What do you think of rask's alignment?
I'm slightly leaning town.

[Zyf]

Noticing that ranger's active in a different thread right now but ignoring this one.
So while I don't think that's enough evidence to bring someone to L-2, I would like some explanation, as an inactive IC is not exactly helping out.

[Raskolnikov]

Anyway, does the attitude of wanting to "coast" work as a VT? I wouldn't think so on my own since townie's goal is to find mafia, which requires discussion, right?

What about you? Experience level in mafia? Have you played pre-forum signup?

Don't entirely understand what you're asking with this question. VTs straight up shouldn't coast, though some people are like that stylistically. PRs can have motivation to but that's a discussion to avoid right now.

Started in starcraft 2 arcade mafia which had 0 scumhunting tbh. Played a fair amount here, mostly newbies. I like to think I've gotten decent now but then again I vaguely remember thinking that before

[beeboy]

VOTE: Raskolnikov

[Raskolnikov]

Noticing that ranger's active in a different thread right now but ignoring this one.
So while I don't think that's enough evidence to bring someone to L-2, I would like some explanation, as an inactive IC is not exactly helping out.

I think you're being oversensitive with this judgement, though.

[Raskolnikov]

VOTE: Raskolnikov

?

[Sickofit1138]

I do like what be seen some rask.

I definitely would like some more conversation to hop onto.

So 2 questions:
1. Why did you choose your username?
2. How long have you had a general experience in mafia? (Not necessarily just this site)

[Raskolnikov]

Have you not been reading the game?

[Zyf]

VOTE: Raskolnikov

?

Double ?
Also because I'm too lazy to go back and quote rask's response to my question...
UNVOTE: f-oh-ex VOTE: beeboy
Firstly because I now have more support for my reasoning against the inactive coasty townie, and becuase beeboy is voting someone I'm reading as town without giving me info to hink otherwise

Anyway, to sick:
See first page
And username because...idek imo it sounds cool
Honestly I'm reading sick as nullscum due to a path towards less helpful/relevant discussion and because there appears to be a lack of reading the thread.
Then again it could be newbness on one (or both) of our parts.
Note: did read rask's post before posting, so I agree with 'em

[Zyf]

VOTE: Raskolnikov

My biggest question is if it's a sort of omgus why them instead of me?

[beeboy]

1. It isn't an omgus because rask wasn't voting me.
2. I don't like how Rask made his vote lose any form of pressure by saying it was a poke rather then a real read. Not only is that playing it way too safe for me to think it is town it also fails to actually apply any pressure with your vote.

[Ranger]

How is zyf at the bottom here?

Zyf's not at the bottom anymore, but was at the time.

And I told you not to tell the newbies the answer. >:I

Noticing that ranger's active in a different thread right now but ignoring this one.
So while I don't think that's enough evidence to bring someone to L-2, I would like some explanation, as an inactive IC is not exactly helping out.

Do as I say, not as I do: I'm in a

lot

of games. More than you can handle. I guarantee you, no matter how much you think you can handle this many games, you can't. The point is, I average about ten at once. This means that it takes me a while to get around to one game in particular. I actually came into this game

first

. After I was caught up here, I moved on to others, and after finishing all of them, now I'm back. You can expect that of me often: I'll be online, and get to a game as soon as I can. Depending on how long the other games take, this could be mere minutes or a couple of hours.

{beeboy}
{dvds, Zyf, Raskolnikov, Sickofit}
{sad}

That these are reads was spoiled for ya, but I'm still not sharing what strength they are right now.

[Zyf]

Anyway, I've gtg now. G'night.
Oh goddangit beeboy posted
1) right but at first i thought it was because you didn't like their response to the coasting thing or something
2) your meaning rask's right? If so, I think that's fair logic but it's not like rask just said "ranger pls post;" at least they voted, which I certainly have been a little less comfortable with. It's just not a strong enough reaction for me, but I'll keep that in mind.
Ok for real now, gnight
Fhwicjwj Ranger y

Hey, I'm sorry, wasn't aware you were that bustling. Good to know.
A couple of questions:
1) What is the benefit for town if you deliberately withhold the strength of your reads? It just makes it harder for us.
2) Why was beeboy in townie for you before they even really made a meaningful analytical post? (This is at the beginning of the game?)

Ok. Like actually tho. I'm going.