Dunnstral wrote:So you're arguing that kuroi is town because Panther and I were pushing him?
Yes. BECAUSE,
There's only 3 scum in the game.
Of ^this. There's only three. I have a very, very,
very
strong {ploben, Dunnstral, PantherPunt} scumteam. It's not just individual posts, either, it's also your buddy-buddy reactions and trivial questions to each other that you never bother to follow through on. Given that, and your push on Kuroi, it's basically impossible for him to be scum, even though his posting contains basically nothing town.
I'll be honest - I'm a bit uncomfortable knowing that you're so confident that I'm scum. Again, when I go through the ISO.
lolwut
she is calling you town by process of elimination because she nailed the whole scumteam.
this is a super weird combination of Ranger defending kuroi by way of scumreading others "very, very,
very
strongly" and Kuroi turning around and distancing from Ranger
glad you quoted this post and said 'kay instead of responding to the post dedicated to you that immediately follows it in 687. hope to see that response.
I guess I didn't see that post, but I didn't list my reasons for wanting for lynch him. Are you saying that because I list my reasons, I didn't have a reason?
Also, I stand by with what I said about Ranger. I find it strange that someone is so certain fo who scum are early on in this game. If she nailed all scum, then everyone else is scum by elimination, and she only mentioned me.
What? Ranger was calling you town. What does "If she nailed all scum, then everyone else is scum by elimination, and she only mentioned me." mean?
I'm sorry, but are we speaking the same language? This is English, right? I shouldn't have to ask this, but no one is understanding my clear message.
I understand that Ranger is calling me town.
I said that I was uncomfortable. I'm uncomfortable because she was confident in this.
Now if she nailed all scum, that would mean that she got a hold of every other person not scum and called them town.
In post 666, Chip Butty wrote:
Oh, no, guys! Now that the theory in its original form has been shot down, this eagerness to advance it without due scrutiny doesn't look so Towny anymore. In fact, scum would be delighted to back a scheme that painted Town.Ranger as scum, right? I'm going to need those cookies back. I'll return them to you if Ranger flips Traitor.
FYI, I literally shot down your theory and amended it for you so that it made any semblance of sense. Then I proceeded to say we should drop it and I've only pushed Ranger for things that have nothing to do with that at all.
Glad to get suspicion of over-eagerness from you for correcting your over-eagerness...
In post 666, Chip Butty wrote:
Oh, no, guys! Now that the theory in its original form has been shot down, this eagerness to advance it without due scrutiny doesn't look so Towny anymore. In fact, scum would be delighted to back a scheme that painted Town.Ranger as scum, right? I'm going to need those cookies back. I'll return them to you if Ranger flips Traitor.
FYI, I literally shot down your theory and amended it for you so that it made any semblance of sense. Then I proceeded to say we should drop it and I've only pushed Ranger for things that have nothing to do with that at all.
Glad to get suspicion of over-eagerness from you for correcting your over-eagerness...
Dunnstral wrote:So you're arguing that kuroi is town because Panther and I were pushing him?
Yes. BECAUSE,
There's only 3 scum in the game.
Of ^this. There's only three. I have a very, very,
very
strong {ploben, Dunnstral, PantherPunt} scumteam. It's not just individual posts, either, it's also your buddy-buddy reactions and trivial questions to each other that you never bother to follow through on. Given that, and your push on Kuroi, it's basically impossible for him to be scum, even though his posting contains basically nothing town.
I'll be honest - I'm a bit uncomfortable knowing that you're so confident that I'm scum. Again, when I go through the ISO.
lolwut
she is calling you town by process of elimination because she nailed the whole scumteam.
this is a super weird combination of Ranger defending kuroi by way of scumreading others "very, very,
very
strongly" and Kuroi turning around and distancing from Ranger
glad you quoted this post and said 'kay instead of responding to the post dedicated to you that immediately follows it in 687. hope to see that response.
I guess I didn't see that post, but I didn't list my reasons for wanting for lynch him. Are you saying that because I list my reasons, I didn't have a reason?
Also, I stand by with what I said about Ranger. I find it strange that someone is so certain fo who scum are early on in this game. If she nailed all scum, then everyone else is scum by elimination, and she only mentioned me.
What? Ranger was calling you town. What does "If she nailed all scum, then everyone else is scum by elimination, and she only mentioned me." mean?
I'm sorry, but are we speaking the same language? This is English, right? I shouldn't have to ask this, but no one is understanding my clear message.
I understand that Ranger is calling me town.
I said that I was uncomfortable. I'm uncomfortable because she was confident in this.
Now if she nailed all scum, that would mean that she got a hold of every other person not scum and called them town.
Dunnstral wrote:So you're arguing that kuroi is town because Panther and I were pushing him?
Yes. BECAUSE,
There's only 3 scum in the game.
Of ^this. There's only three. I have a very, very,
very
strong {ploben, Dunnstral, PantherPunt} scumteam. It's not just individual posts, either, it's also your buddy-buddy reactions and trivial questions to each other that you never bother to follow through on. Given that, and your push on Kuroi, it's basically impossible for him to be scum, even though his posting contains basically nothing town.
I'll be honest - I'm a bit uncomfortable knowing that you're so confident that I'm scum. Again, when I go through the ISO.
lolwut
she is calling you town by process of elimination because she nailed the whole scumteam.
this is a super weird combination of Ranger defending kuroi by way of scumreading others "very, very,
very
strongly" and Kuroi turning around and distancing from Ranger
glad you quoted this post and said 'kay instead of responding to the post dedicated to you that immediately follows it in 687. hope to see that response.
I guess I didn't see that post, but I didn't list my reasons for wanting for lynch him. Are you saying that because I list my reasons, I didn't have a reason?
Also, I stand by with what I said about Ranger. I find it strange that someone is so certain fo who scum are early on in this game. If she nailed all scum, then everyone else is scum by elimination, and she only mentioned me.
What? Ranger was calling you town. What does "If she nailed all scum, then everyone else is scum by elimination, and she only mentioned me." mean?
I'm sorry, but are we speaking the same language? This is English, right? I shouldn't have to ask this, but no one is understanding my clear message.
I understand that Ranger is calling me town.
I said that I was uncomfortable. I'm uncomfortable because she was confident in this.
Now if she nailed all scum, that would mean that she got a hold of every other person not scum and called them town.
But she did it to me, and me only.
Do you understand now?
Do you?
I think the English issue is you using scum and town wrong in both 688 and 694. Check yourself
In post 696, karnos wrote:...My reads have changed a bit. Doing that time-warping thing: as I read through, I was thinking I would change my vote of ploben. Then I saw his last two posts above and he convinced me to keep it right where it is...
...ploben - I was warming up to the idea of plobin being town, but his last few posts prior to this convinced me otherwise. He is just trying to start a new wagon to plant his vote...
I really wasn't fucking with you. I wanted you to go back and explain what you meant, and if you did that you would have seen your mistake. Instead you decided to get BM on me at which point I took the "Is this what you meant?" approach.
In post 715, KuroiXHF wrote:I've already answered that, Panther. That's how I read it.
Oh where'd you answer it?
And can you show me how you read it that way? Like which words of Shadow's made you think the reason for his Alpaca scumread were reasons of inactivity/lurking? I'm just trying to understand your thought processes and hopefully read you correctly. You want that, as town, don't you?
Your OMGUS vote switch to chip butty. Your claim that I have been talking about his town slips (please give a reference, I don't recall that at all). The continuation of the suspected scum team to never FOS each other.
In post 53, karnos wrote:I don't see the mod confirmation. Claiming a role when no reason to claim it, and claiming a role that can be mod confirmed without the mod confirm? That seems scummy as hell to me.
UNVOTE: Ranger
How so? You think mafia claims as innocent child at game start? Why is it scummy?
This ploben mini-wagon is dumb but here's a good one:
VOTE: karnos
RVS is over boys everyone vote karnos
I think proben claimed while not realizing that Innocent Child is confirmed by Mod. Mod has since checked in with a vote count and hasn't confirmed an Innocent Child in the game, much less proben being it. Conclusion: there probably isn't an Innocent Child, so proben has been caught out fakeclaiming. I see two possibilities:
1. He is scum. But this would be a dumb play because Town would surely notice the lack of Mod confirmation;
2. He is Town trying to attract the NK, but this would be a dumb play because scum would surely notice the lack of Mod confirmation.
Oh well, if RVS is over: UNVOTE: VOTE: proben
Forget my first two points. There needs to be a wagon on ChipBuddy. It's the most obvious joke claim.
Can you tell me why you thought that post warranted a wagon on ChipBuddy, but this post does not warrant you even mentioning Karnos?
It seems to me that the Karnos post commits the same fault that you found in ChipBuddy's post...it takes an "obvious joke claim" as serious enough to vote ploben over.
In post 53, karnos wrote:VOTE: Ranger
Per my usual random vote policy of voting #1 on the player list.
Except...
In post 18, ploben wrote:Also I'm confirmed (not so) Innocent (mind like a) Child.
I don't see the mod confirmation. Claiming a role when no reason to claim it, and claiming a role that can be mod confirmed without the mod confirm? That seems scummy as hell to me. UNVOTE: Ranger
Your OMGUS vote switch to chip butty. Your claim that I have been talking about his town slips (please give a reference, I don't recall that at all). The continuation of the suspected scum team to never FOS each other.
Is there any player in this game who could flip scum and clear me as town in your mind?
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
