Newbie 1715 (Game Over)

[crazycrabman]

Is tojam at I-1?

[Creature]

Nah, he's at L-2

[Creature]

I don't think we'll get cold feet to lynch tojam2, he's not trying to help himself.

[crazycrabman]

ahh ok. In that case, I cast my unofficial vote for tojam. I believe that there is a strong case against him and his lynching will provide some much-needed information. The reason I keep it unofficial is because I don't want someone to cast the hammer vote without warning.

[Dragon of the West]

so now what? wait for tojam defense and the others to contribute more?

[Dwlee99]

we're waiting for sircakez and a few others to do something useful and then we're lynching tojam.

[LicketyQuickety]

we're waiting for sircakez and a few others to do something useful and then we're lynching tojam.

If the IC is newb scum and gets lynched day 1... lawl.

[eagerSnake]

SirCakez and atm are almost as inactive as tojam

[Dwlee99]

307, that's how many posts tojam has. Tojam is still

a goon

as far as his title goes.

[LicketyQuickety]

307, that's how many posts tojam has. Tojam is still

a goon

as far as his title goes.

Yeah, and I am technically mafia scum, but I have spammed like a maniac in some games. Different levels of activity for players. Don't know what your point is. In fact, I'm going to count how many games I have on this site. I doubt its more than 10. I'm also going to try and figure out how many games tojam has played.

[eagerSnake]

Post count

Creature - 82
crazycrabman - 45
LicketyQuickety - 41

Dwlee99 - 38
Dragon of the West - 32
eagerSnake - 29

atm487 - 14
SirCakez - 13
tojam2 - 5

[Creature]

Everybody is engaged enough except atm487, SirCakez and tojam2.

[Creature]

Also, I am seeing SirCakez lurking, does it mean SirCakez is on his scum game?

[Dwlee99]

307, that's how many posts tojam has. Tojam is still

a goon

as far as his title goes.

Yeah, and I am technically mafia scum, but I have spammed like a maniac in some games. Different levels of activity for players. Don't know what your point is. In fact, I'm going to count how many games I have on this site. I doubt its more than 10. I'm also going to try and figure out how many games tojam has played.

I was responding to you being shocked if he was newbscum.

[LicketyQuickety]

Just for the LOLs.

Here is my page. I have 42 posts in this game in 4 days. That is above my average, but tbh I was away from the site for a while, so in actuallity its prolly still below average (can't be arsed to figure out all the days I posted and compare that way). I have 13 games completed (by my count). I have 74 threads I have posted in.

This is tojams page. He has 4 posts in 4 days. That is above average for him (I think). His first post was in December. tojam has 8 games completed and has less than 2 ppd. iirc he never plays in more than 2 games at a time. I am just guessing here, but I think I see that he has like <20 places he has posted.

[Dwlee99]

I was saying he isn't that experienced lol

[LicketyQuickety]

I was saying he isn't that experienced lol

TBH, I didn't like how you told creature to put his vote back on tojam in hindsight 20/20 based on knowing that tojam is both not the most experienced and doesn't usually post that much anyways.

Gives me much :///

[Dwlee99]

it isn't his activity level. It is the tone of his posts. I've played with him before in college mafia and his posts there were so much different.

[LicketyQuickety]

it isn't his activity level. It is the tone of his posts. I've played with him before in college mafia and his posts there were so much different.

Why do you think tone is a valid argument based on a single game of experience with this player? You are basically saying the same thing as Cakes (and everyone else at this point).

[Dwlee99]

it isn't his activity level. It is the tone of his posts. I've played with him before in college mafia and his posts there were so much different.

Why do you think tone is a valid argument based on a single game of experience with this player? You are basically saying the same thing as Cakes (and everyone else at this point).

I mean tbh I often don't even need to have played a game with a person to read them off of tone, it just helps.
But tojam's posts here sound super forced and faked, it is kind of hard to explain but just the way he is posting isn't genuine. When I combine that with the fact that in the game I played with him where he was town he DID sound genuine, he is scum.

[LicketyQuickety]

it isn't his activity level. It is the tone of his posts. I've played with him before in college mafia and his posts there were so much different.

Why do you think tone is a valid argument based on a single game of experience with this player? You are basically saying the same thing as Cakes (and everyone else at this point).

I mean tbh I often don't even need to have played a game with a person to read them off of tone, it just helps.
But tojam's posts here sound super forced and faked, it is kind of hard to explain but just the way he is posting isn't genuine. When I combine that with the fact that in the game I played with him where he was town he DID sound genuine, he is scum.

I have him as Null for the simple fact that the guy only has 5 posts in this whole game. To put this in perspective, that is like 1/17th of the highest poster. If you can get a clear read on someone based on 5 posts then you may just be one of those players who has an uncanny ability to read people based off tone. Or you could be scum. Or you could be just plain wrong on your read on them. fwiw I read your tone as good, but I have never played with you, so I can't rely on that too much. Creature on the other hand, has a shitty tone.

[Creature]

Creature on the other hand, has a shitty tone.

I have an obvtown tone and I don't understand how you don't think that.

[Dwlee99]

you may just be one of those players who has an uncanny ability to read people based off tone.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=65521
I am in a hydra with titus (Night Hunters)
Pretty much all of my reads were accurate that game iirc mostly based on tone reading.

[LicketyQuickety]

Creature on the other hand, has a shitty tone.

I have an obvtown tone and I don't understand how you don't think that.

No, you have a sneaky tone. I can honestly say if you are town you are a detriment to town. Here's some reasons why:

Your reaction tests:
Your first one was out of this world terrible, which is reason to suspect you on its own.
Reaction tests are suppose to be subtly, not blatantly ridiculous.

Your contradictions:
Saying you are confident in your read on tojam who had like 3(?) 4 posts at the time and then later saying "yeah, not really sure on tojam."

Your Wifom potential:
The way you are going about it does absolutely nothing to advance town, it just creates confusion. So Even if you are just doing reaction test after reaction test, it gets town nowhere because even if you are town and even if you have good reads, unless you actually stick to those reads, people never know if they should take your reads serious or not.

An updated reads list would be nice right about now.

[Dwlee99]

Thor gives me bad vibes. :I

-Dad

Idk what it is but the tone of your posts seems kinda off.

-Dad

fire is town though
-dad

Read his ISO. If that isnt town tone idk what is.

just a few examples, sircakez can confirm as well since he was in the game.