Newbie 1717: Newbies Through the Looking Glass (Game Over)

[Simoyd]

What is PT? pre-game thread? Is there daytalk in this game?

[Postie]

Prviate Topic. And oh yeah nevermind there's no daytalk so Pants might not have posted anything there after all.

[BlankFace]

That's null at best. I forgot that snoe replaced Pants. Pants did shit for the first four pages though. It'd be too easy to fake to be a town tell as scum anyways.

Just got back from some landscaping, starting the next few pages soon.

[Postie]

Why do you care whether it's a null or not and how easy it is to fake?

[BlankFace]

Because it's not a good reason to read anyone town, even as a passing thought.

[Postie]

But why does it matter to you if it's a good reason or not?

[Harkonnen97]

@Simoyd Accountant. But don't have a big reason to suspect her yet.

[Xalxe]

Titus

replaces Grace. Deadline is 72 hours from this post, or (expired on 2016-06-25 22:32:17). Deadline will have no further extensions.

[Titus]

Hi.

Alright, 3 days. Let's crack this shit.

[Titus]

Vote Count 1.10

I don't think--
- Then you shouldn't talk.

Accountant

(3): Postie, RadiantCowbells, Simoyd

snoe

(3): Accountant, Harkonnen97, Lycanfire

Postie

(1): snoe

Lycanfire

(1): innocentvillager

Not Voting

: Grace

Deadline

: (expired on 2016-06-24 07:25:57)

*sigh*

Seeking replacements for both

Grace

and

snoe

, who requested replacement for personal reasons. Deadline is suspended until replacements are found.

Is this VC accurate but for the names?

[Simoyd]

yes

[Xalxe]

As far as I know, yes, unless you've spotted an error.

[Titus]

yes

Case on accountant in your own words?

[Harkonnen97]

Welcome Titus

[innocentvillager]

Before I write my catch up post:

because I know I'm town and you don't

Okay, if thjs isn't a scumslip, I don't know what is.

VOTE: Lycanfire

I'm not moving my vote for the rest of day unless I hear something damn fucking good.

[RadiantCowbells]

that's not a scumslip?

[innocentvillager]

that's not a scumslip?

Really? If he's town, how would he know that I don't know that he's town? He didn't scumread or townread me really at the end of his post. This is slipping that he knows I'm town.

[Simoyd]

Case on accountant in your own words?

I don't like her reads. I don't like her defence of IV early on, although I'm not sure IV is scum right now, but it still speaks to accountant knowing IV is town. I don't like her smug defence of herself, not just with the conclusion paragraph, but of her flaky reasoning throughout the entire game. Hasn't done any scum hunting at all in the last 10 pages or more: Only clarification questions and answers to other's questions. Her last question was to ask about my case which is just an interest in her own well being. I'm not happy with the answers provided to my first wall: just because I debated things that were debatable, doesn't mean that her explanations of of the things I didn't question weren't suspicious. I suggest everyone go back and read her responses again (124) if you're really concerned about it. I'm only really okay with 2 maybe 3 of those responses tops... The rest is total garbage that she should have just admitted was garbage instead of making up stuff to explain it.

Now, she said snoe looked scummy, but only after everyone else jumped on that, and she didn't scum hunt there at all... not that I did either though... But both snoe and blank are doing some kind of odd befriending of accountant, so there's definately some association there, and I think that gives us more reason to find out what it is

[Simoyd]

@lycan: Who is your second scum pick after snoe?

[Titus]

that's not a scumslip?

Really? If he's town, how would he know that I don't know that he's town? He didn't scumread or townread me really at the end of his post. This is slipping that he knows I'm town.

That's not a slip unless he claimed to scumread you.

[innocentvillager]

that's not a scumslip?

Really? If he's town, how would he know that I don't know that he's town? He didn't scumread or townread me really at the end of his post. This is slipping that he knows I'm town.

That's not a slip unless he claimed to scumread you.

Explain please.

Also I know you just replaced in, but he's been scumreading/tunneling on me basically this entire game, and only in that post did he finally put me at null.

[Simoyd]

That's not a slip unless he claimed to scumread you.

which is why I want to know lycan's second choice now

[Simoyd]

but he's been scumreading/tunneling on me basically this entire game

I think you've been tunneling on him, not him on you.

[Titus]

that's not a scumslip?

Really? If he's town, how would he know that I don't know that he's town? He didn't scumread or townread me really at the end of his post. This is slipping that he knows I'm town.

That's not a slip unless he claimed to scumread you.

Explain please.

Also I know you just replaced in, but he's been scumreading/tunneling on me basically this entire game, and only in that post did he finally put me at null.

And if you're at null at the time he made the statement, it's not a scumslip. It means he's consistently open about you being town regardless of who was tunnelling whom.

[Titus]

*consistently isn't the right word. I meant completely.