Mini 1805 [C'est fini!]

[Eggman]

That was the intent, yes.

[Eggman]

don't you just love when you're writing a big post then accidentally delete the tab
i'm rereading the game closely
also i only just understood dwlee's 167. VOTE: smithereens

[Creature]

VOTE: MarioManiac4

Let's go here, his play here is WAY different than his town play I know.

[Creature]

Mod

Can you prod Robbnva, MarioManiac4 and stelo?

[Sméagol]

Stelo has already been prodded. I'll give Mario until I get back. Robb mentioned he would be VLA for a day.

[Robbnva]

Yeah I've been sick the past couple of days. Had some sort of weird reaction and my eye swoled shut. Now I've got a rash all I've my arms and legs. Doctor thinks I somehow got poison ivy in my eye.

Il try and catchup soonish. I thought about replacing out cause that's easier than catching up but I'm getting bored so I'll suck it up. Gonna pop some Benadryl and take a nap and I'll read up starting tonight

[Creature]

Okay.

[Creature]

I've been ISOing everybody and:
- Eggman has crumbed VT, which I find very unlikely he'd do that as scum.
- There are 6 players scum reading him excluding me.

So I am no longer scumreading Eggman.

[F-oh-ex]

I've been ISOing everybody and:
- Eggman has crumbed VT, which I find very unlikely he'd do that as scum.
- There are 6 players scum reading him excluding me.

So I am no longer scumreading Eggman.

Could you point where Eggman crumbed VT? I fail to see it, unless you mean "I don't know how to scumhunt" as a means of implying that he's not a power role. Which is terrible-ish.

[F-oh-ex]

Note: Creature was the first one to have voted Eggman, now we switched to MM4. He also confirmed what Eggman said about crumbing immediately.

[MarioManiac4]

VOTE: MarioManiac4

Let's go here, his play here is WAY different than his town play I know.

Shocker; I don't play the same way every game.
The last game was blitz, so I wanted to get the ball rolling- and I saw something I could do it with. Here, we had two weeks.
I think you'll find most of my games are like this, but I guess you just want to base your meta off very few games!

[Creature]

PEDIT: VT. It's why I did the RQS: "vanilla" ice cream

General question: what's your favorite dessert?

[Dwlee99]

he never said his favorite dessert was vanilla ice cream tho

[F-oh-ex]

^This. He claiemed he actually closed the tab and his post did't send out.

[F-oh-ex]

Also, scum crumbing isn't so uncommon from what I read. After all, scum can just abandon the crumb and not point it out if they change their mind.

[Creature]

But I don't think Egg is the kind of player that does that.

[F-oh-ex]

You'll understand if I find that argument unconvincing.

[crazycrabman]

I think that the "what's your favorite desert question" was definitely on purpose. I don't know what way that points eggman, though.

[Dragon of the West]

The dessert question can be totally on purpose, but doesn't prove anything. He could do that to crumb vanilla townie but...it's kind of a weak crumb and vanilla townie is probably the role least likely to crumb because they have the easiest role to claim with an impossibility of a counterclaim. Also, what was already mentioned holds true, scum crumb as well so that they have something to point to later if they need to claim before a lynch

[Eggman]

^This. He claiemed he actually closed the tab and his post did't send out.

No, I claimed I was rereading the game and pointing out things I missed before and closed that tab in the middle of writing it. You're deliberately misinterpreting that post.

[Eggman]

I also hold the belief that a VT claim is incredibly useless, so crumbing my role in the form of that RQS would lend a little bit more credence.

[Dragon of the West]

But I don't think Egg is the kind of player that does that.

but why would he crumb vanilla townie in the first place? someone pointed out early on he never has done an RQS in any of his games before. regardless of alignment

[Dragon of the West]

I also hold the belief that a VT claim is incredibly useless, so crumbing my role in the form of that RQS would lend a little bit more credence.

I think the claim of VT in itself is fairly useless, but a realistic one. Especially early on before anything has been revealed, it's good for scum because it isn't prone to counterclaim and even better if you can fake a crumb towards that claim

[Dragon of the West]

But I don't think Egg is the kind of player that does that.

in all of your "vast" experience with eggman, he cannot be a player that fakes a crumb?

[Derek12]

OK listen, so I have been inactive lately because I have had alot on my mind and some stuff happened, but listen. I know for a fact creature is town, his posts are very revealing and if he's playing scum, he very good, if not, then he is very good at town too, rooting out the obvious people that have been active, for now, I would like to re-review all the posts and wait a little before voting, because many of us have been active and I am having a hard time deciding who to vote for, my apologies

>I know for a fact
Creature's posts are muddy and his reads are all over the place, often with little explanation. Let me ISO him and get back to you.

Is this still happening?

also i only just understood dwlee's 167. VOTE: smithereens

Weren't you scumreading me more then smithereens? Why put your vote on him instead of me, assuming I'm still your strongest scumread?