Mini 1805 [C'est fini!]

[Smithereens]

I can only see him doing that as scum if someone told him to.

but you see him doing it as town? when he has never done an RQS ever before

Yes, as he's often lynched D1, he should be ready when it comes to him to claim.

Links please, I suspect you're making shit up.

we already discussed this I believe. Creature and robbnva talked about Eggman's 3 games

Yeah I saw immediately following, however this question still needs to be asked. Why did he make that up?

Obviously he wasn't expecting the other players to check his claims and find him wrong, so there is clearly a motive here.

[Creature]

I thought he was lynched D1 in more games than Newbie 1703, but I still feel like he's a mislynch bait.

[Smithereens]

That assumption is nonsense, clarify it please.

[Dragon of the West]

Okay that's more the path I'd want to go down. I don't want links to those things I'd rather him defend the slip-up. There could be a motive but honestly I wouldn't put it past town!creature to white lie just to make people agree with him. I could see town!creature doing that especially after playing with him in my last game where he was town. He's very aggressive and sure of himself and his reads. Doesn't mean scum!creature wouldn't do this, I'm just saying I'm going to weigh it appropriately unless he gives it a poor defense

[Creature]

I played with him at Newbie 1703, I watched him play Micro 614 and I heard about him in Newbie 1691.

[Dragon of the West]

I don't think someone being mislynched in a few games leads them to crumb vanilla townie and I also don't think that means you can throw away scum reads on them

[Robbnva]

Why did you watch and read those other games?

The micro game he was NKd. I haven't read the game yet but NK implies not lynchbait

[Dwlee99]

You all are wrong. Creature played one game with eggman, where he sees eggman mislynched day one and therefore off his limited experience believes that eggman is mislynch bait without looking into other games. smh

[Robbnva]

But he's saying he looked at these other games.

Plus micro never even got more than 1 vote on him (based off published VCs)

[Dwlee99]

oh idk

[Creature]

From the posts I've been reading on Micro 614, there seemed to have lot of suspicion on Eggman.

[Dragon of the West]

im not fully caught up yet so I don't have opinions on a lot of people yet. Im also not one to give out all my reads either.

But dragon I'm kind of conflicted on for reasons

.

back atcha

[Smithereens]

I played with him at Newbie 1703, I watched him play Micro 614 and I heard about him in Newbie 1691.

This is not adding up.

You played with him in Newbie 1703, you saw him get mislynched. You watched him play mirco 614, you

saw him get killed on Day 3.

You heard about him in Newbie 1691, you have no idea what happened.

So where did "he's often lynched D1" come from?

Contrived defense is a contrived defense imo. Also, read your own post, you must think we're idiots.

[Smithereens]

From the posts I've been reading on Micro 614, there seemed to have lot of suspicion on Eggman.

Why are you reading 614 now? You supposedly came to this conclusion before this game even started that Eggman was mislynch bait no?

[Creature]

I thought he was actually lynched Day 3, but scum was found at the same time thus resulting in game ending.

[Creature]

From the posts I've been reading on Micro 614, there seemed to have lot of suspicion on Eggman.

Why are you reading 614 now? You supposedly came to this conclusion before this game even started that Eggman was mislynch bait no?

That was before the game started.

[atm487]

Neil Breen

[Dragon of the West]

Neil Breen

wat

[Dwlee99]

Neil Breen

same

[Creature]

And now we're discussing how much attention I was paying to Eggman's games...

[Robbnva]

Because it's relevant

[Smithereens]

Actually we're discussing it because you're ignoring the other points, such as why you decided to make up 'facts' to support your reasons in the first place. If you just reinstate your vote on Eggman it should all be fine.

[Creature]

But I feel like we've been too focused on Eggman.

[Robbnva]

Probably cause you backed off his wagon for shoddy reasoning. Your reasoning for why he was scum was much stronger.

you did a 180 and your reasoning doesn't work

[Robbnva]

I find it pretty opportunistic the way you straight supported Robbnva at "can be easily faked" (see the bolded argument).

How is it opportunistic exactly?

creature it looks like you missed this question. can you please respond?