Newbie 1717: Newbies Through the Looking Glass (Game Over)

[innocentvillager]

Simoyd/Postie looks pretty compelling if you go back through their ISOs/interactions of day 1, but if you go with the Postie as scum theory just about anyone that isn't Blank or myself is pretty good for being her scumpartner. For instance, just about everything I could say about Simoyd/Postie I could say about you, RC, except rather than Simoyd sheeping Postie at one point, Postie has been sheeping you instead. IV wouldn't have this in his case, but of the four possible scum partners I'd consider, he was the most rigid in his scumpool, matching Postie. Hark shows up and makes a good post, or a clueless one every so often so I would struggle to pin him with someone. Being the starting vote on Postie makes me the least suspicious of him.

I don't understand what you're concluding. It just sounds like you're throwing waffly accusations around.

[Lycanfire]

Try harder

[innocentvillager]

I just really hate how you have basically anyone open for a scumread. Not just this post, in previous posts too. This is fencesitting/waffling at its finest.

[innocentvillager]

Guys what if the scumteam was Me/Lycan this whole time

I'd be like FACK U BITCHES

[Lycanfire]

Maybe I should get more specific. I think Simoyd/Blank is the scum team. Everyone else is town. If Simoyd is town, Postie might be the second scum, but in the Postie/Blank theory, I'm liking her more as town the more she insists on her lynch pool.

[Lycanfire]

Guys what if the scumteam was Me/Lycan this whole time

I'd be like FACK U BITCHES

if we were the scum team i would have lynched you day 1 for sure.

[Lycanfire]

I meant Simoyd town in the Blank as scum scenario. I won't deny X/Postie, but I see no reason to take my vote off Blank, as it's my best read, while I see no reason to lynch Simoyd today, either, because a Blank lynch eliminates more partners than a Simoyd one.

[innocentvillager]

Guys what if the scumteam was Me/Lycan this whole time

I'd be like FACK U BITCHES

if we were the scum team i would have lynched you day 1 for sure.

Nah I'd get you lynched first and then take all the towncred, kill RC, ML on Accountant, kill Hark, ML on Blank, kill Titus, and beat Simoyd/Postie in lylo

[innocentvillager]

Maybe I should get more specific. I think Simoyd/Blank is the scum team. Everyone else is town. If Simoyd is town, Postie might be the second scum, but in the Postie/Blank theory, I'm liking her more as town the more she insists on her lynch pool.

You should've said this sooner. Saying it now when you're prompted to only makes you look worse.

Also, why the more she insists on her lynch pool the townier? I must admit, my reads haven't changed very much this game (which tbh is kind of scumtell), so I'm not sure what you mean

[Lycanfire]

Maybe I should get more specific. I think Simoyd/Blank is the scum team. Everyone else is town. If Simoyd is town, Postie might be the second scum, but in the Postie/Blank theory, I'm liking her more as town the more she insists on her lynch pool.

You should've said this sooner. Saying it now when you're prompted to only makes you look worse.

Also, why the more she insists on her lynch pool the townier? I must admit, my reads haven't changed very much this game (which tbh is kind of scumtell), so I'm not sure what you mean

RC asked about Simoyd/Postie, which I found annoying because I could have applied everything I found in support of Simoyd/Postie to himself/Postie. Since I didn't change my vote or say any possibility was more likely than any other, my stance should have been clear from the beginning.

I was thinking Postie was scummy, but sticking to her guns in an X/Blank scumteam looks pretty good the more I think about it. If she's scum then she knows I'm town, and has no reason to maintain her scum pool when a lynch on me isn't looking as likely as it was earlier. She has to know that there's no certainty that she could mislynch me tomorrow in a Blank lynch today. The scummier thing to do would be to loosen on her reads right now.

[Lycanfire]

OK I did say some possibilities were more likely than others, but more like Simoyd=RC>IV. What I meant to say is that no one possibility won out.

[RadiantCowbells]

Okay.

Blank/Postie/Simoyd is my current lynchpool.

I am back to wanting a Postie lynch.

VOTE: Postie

[Simoyd]

RC: Are you defending blank? Day 1 I put him at L-1 and u freaked, and today you hit postie, then lycan, then me. What is your read on Blank right now?

[Simoyd]

^disregard that.

[Simoyd]

I feel like RC is sheeping me. Postie, what do you think?

[RadiantCowbells]

How in the name of fuck am I sheeping you?

[Simoyd]

I think blank should have more votes than postie

VOTE: BlankFace

>> L-1 <<

[Simoyd]

you didn't post your reasoning on accountant until I had already posted two walls. The reasoning you specified was stuff I already said. Today I voted postie, followed by you.

In your defense you voted lycan before me, but I said I didn't think he should be lynched and now he's out of our lynch pool.

So either we think alike or you're sheeping scum. I think we will have to sort that out tomorrow

[Simoyd]

also nobody hammer without intent and claim opportunity, obviously...

[RadiantCowbells]

Yup. It's Simoyd/Postie. I can virtually guarantee it.

Don't anyone dare hammer Blank.

[Lycanfire]

UNVOTE:

[RadiantCowbells]

Lycan, do you not feel like Simoyd is trying to rush a Blank lynch?

[Lycanfire]

All I know is that I went from being for a Blank lynch to uncomfortable as hell in under 5 minutes.

[RadiantCowbells]

I want to lynch Simoyd first but Titus wanted to force feed me humble pie so I'm sorta leaning towards lynching the one of the two that was in her lynchpool.

[Lycanfire]

I already gave my reasoning against a Postie/Blank team, so if that's what Simoyd is suggesting I disagree with it. I disagree with part of his reasoning for her being scummy too, like her lynchpool. I find her

more town as a result

. Meanwhile he just flopped onto Blank from Postie the moment you pressured her, so yeah I think there was a rush, esp. since he had no pressure on himself, while Postie had some on her. He makes it clear that he's thinking about the votes on Postie when he votes Blank.