Newbie 1717: Newbies Through the Looking Glass (Game Over)

[Harkonnen97]

I don't think Simoyd is trying to rush a Blank lynch specifically. He did the same to Postie earlier this day.

Someone put Postie on L-1 and let her claim please.

[Simoyd]

I'm okay with a postie lynch, but I would prefer blank.

[innocentvillager]

All I really got from that was that Blank and Simoyd are probably not a scumteam. I don't see why Blank is necessarily less scummy for this.

[Simoyd]

pretty sure that RC has never voted blank. Correct me if I'm wrong.

[innocentvillager]

I don't think Simoyd is trying to rush a Blank lynch specifically. He did the same to Postie earlier this day.

Someone put Postie on L-1 and let her claim please.

He did this to Lycan, not Postie.

[Harkonnen97]

Oh right.

Hmmnnm. I don't see Simoyd/Lycan or Simoyd/Blank scumteams. If Simoyd is scum, the only scumbuddy who I can pair him with is Postie.

[innocentvillager]

Now that I think about it, sure it's theoretically possible that Simoyd L-1'd one of his partners to deflect suspicion from their wagon, given that he's done it twice in the span like 2 IRL days.

But I still think Simoyd is probably newbtown. His posting mostly screams newbtown. Some of his actions are pretty scummy but they can all be explained plausibly under the context of newbtown.

[innocentvillager]

pretty sure that RC has never voted blank. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Where are you going with this..?

[Harkonnen97]

I agree. I think that he is playing aggresively, and when you are town and you are new, your first instinct is to play as aggresively as possible. At least that's how I was in my first town game.

[Lycanfire]

All I really got from that was that Blank and Simoyd are probably not a scumteam. I don't see why Blank is necessarily less scummy for this.

He's still the #1 partner for Blank in my eyes, so we're reading this differently.

[Simoyd]

pretty sure that RC has never voted blank. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Where are you going with this..?

RC/Blank

That's another reason I want to lynch blank

[Lycanfire]

Ok apparently we're reading it about the same now. Carry on.

[innocentvillager]

I agree. I think that he is playing aggresively, and when you are town and you are new, your first instinct is to play as aggresively as possible. At least that's how I was in my first town game.

I think this is a personality issue lol

If you look at my first game on this site... lmao I was the VI who gave shitty reads, terrible reasoning, didn't contribute, etc.

I did put the scumteam in my top 3 though on d1.

[innocentvillager]

Ok apparently we're reading it about the same now. Carry on.

huh?

Why are you the only person whose posts I fail to understand at least half the time

[RadiantCowbells]

Now that I think about it, sure it's theoretically possible that Simoyd L-1'd one of his partners to deflect suspicion from their wagon, given that he's done it twice in the span like 2 IRL days.

But I still think Simoyd is probably newbtown. His posting mostly screams newbtown. Some of his actions are pretty scummy but they can all be explained plausibly under the context of newbtown.

stop.

newbtown is very rarely newbtown. not when they're being like this.

[RadiantCowbells]

Simoyd never L-1ed Postie either.

Where did you think this happened?

[Harkonnen97]

Yesterday's wagons were Accountant and Blank. Postie was on the Accountant wagon. Blank didn't vote for anyone. To whoever said that he thinks that scum would try to distance themselves and join different wagons: there you go. Blank couldn't vote for himself, so if his scumbuddy is someone from among the Accountant wagon, the biggest distancing play he can make is to not vote at all.

(I'm saying this because I still believe it's Postie/Blank)

[RadiantCowbells]

I don't think Simoyd's trying to rush a PARTICULAR lynch so much as he's trying to rush a non-Postie lynch.

Simoyd, Postie was your second biggest scumread. How did I all of a sudden become your second biggest scumread for pushing someone that you were scumreading?

[Harkonnen97]

stop.

newbtown is very rarely newbtown. not when they're being like this.

being like what?

newbtown

?

[RadiantCowbells]

Simoyd's not being newbtown they're being a slimy manipulative fuck who is rushing every single wagon besides Postie's and changing their reads all over the place to try to defend her.

[Simoyd]

Now that I think about it, sure it's theoretically possible that Simoyd L-1'd one of his partners to deflect suspicion from their wagon, given that he's done it twice in the span like 2 IRL days.

But I still think Simoyd is probably newbtown. His posting mostly screams newbtown. Some of his actions are pretty scummy but they can all be explained plausibly under the context of newbtown.

stop.

newbtown is very rarely newbtown. not when they're being like this.

OK how about this: You tell me what you guys think I've done that's newbtown, I'll explain the reasoning behind my actions and we talk it out? All I've heard (in both my games) is the word "newbtown" over and over with no reasoning...

[Simoyd]

to try to defend her.

all my day 2 posts on postie have been attacking her I'm pretty sure, right? Which ones do you think are defending her?

[Simoyd]

I don't think I'm rushing lynches. I'm putting people at L-1.

[RadiantCowbells]

When you put someone who is generally scumread to L-1 TWICE when wagons start up on her and chainsaw defend her by discrediting me when I start trying to lynch her again, yeah you're defending her.

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Lycanfire

>> L-1 <<

*hands innocentvillager the hammer*

Your dream just came true

HI I PUT SOMEONE TO L-1 LOUDLY AND LITERALLY ASKED SOMEONE ELSE TO HAMMER AS WELL.

YEAH, THAT'S TOTALLY NOT RUSHING ANY LYNCHES OVER THERE BUD. AND ON SOMEONE YOU NEVER REALLY CLAIMED TO SCUMREAD.