Newbie 1717: Newbies Through the Looking Glass (Game Over)

[Simoyd]

Okay, why?

I want to answer this but maybe you can be more specific? I'm not sure which part you're asking "why" to exactly.

[Simoyd]

little bit confusing.

let me know if there's anything I can help clear up

[Simoyd]

How did I all of a sudden become your second biggest scumread for pushing someone that you were scumreading?

You're not my biggest scumread. Is discussing the option bad? You're tied with Lycan for 4th/5th

[RadiantCowbells]

pretty sure that RC has never voted blank. Correct me if I'm wrong.

pretty sure that RC has never voted blank. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Where are you going with this..?

RC/Blank

That's another reason I want to lynch blank

[Simoyd]

Is there a problem with that?

[Simoyd]

also since postie is no longer L-1 (defeating the reason why harkonnen wanted me to L-1 her), and blank only has 1 vote on him (he's my preferred vote).

VOTE: BlankFace (L-2)

Spoiler: Unofficial Vote Count

BlankFace (2): innocentvillager, Simoyd
Lycanfire (1): Postie
Simoyd (1): BlankFace, RadiantCowbells
Postie (1): Harkonnen97

Not Voting: Lycanfire

[Simoyd]

I went from L-2 to L-1 and Simoyd, who clearly wants me lynched, unvotes

That is not what happened. I unvoted lycan before you went L-1, citing the getting yelled at and that I no longer thought he deserved a lynch, then I L-1'd you after postie had two votes. So what you said is backwards and wrong.

[Simoyd]

RC puts Postie to L-2 in 688 and Simoyd's immediate response is to say that RC is sheeping him [lolwat]

someone already brought this up. You parroted them, and I already described my reasoning. Let me know if you want me to repeat myself, or if you have a separate concern.

[Simoyd]

So basically, his scumpool was tied at votes, which if he was town and actually hunting would be great for him.

why is having my first choice of lynch at the same number of votes as my second choice good for town when I'm voting nothing? I would like to pressure my highest scum read, so I did.

Instead, he sees Postie put under the same pressure as me and puts me a L-1. Makes me think he's either sheeping everyone else's suspicions of Postie or is her partner. Reading over RC's posts about Simoyd rushing every lynch besides Postie, I have to agree. Happened with the Lycan vote, and conveniently now that Lycan isn't under threat of being lynched anymore he isn't suspicious of Lycan anymore, and it happened with me as well. If Simoyd was serious about me/Postie as a scum team, he would have been fine with either one of us.

I am fine with either one of you. I would prefer you though.

[Simoyd]

The only argument I see for lynching me is defending postie. Correct me if I'm wrong?

I thought pre-flip associative tells were generally considered a bad thing.

How about we lynch blank for actually being scummy himself? He jumps on my wagon with nothing but parroting and nonsense.

[RadiantCowbells]

You keep saying you're fine with either of them but only pushing for a Blank lynch and resisting a Postie lynch.

[RadiantCowbells]

Are you claiming cop with an inno on Postie?

[RadiantCowbells]

with a guilty on Blankface*

[Harkonnen97]

I think it's either Postie/Blank or Simoyd/Postie. Is there anyone else who thinks that it can be something else?

[RadiantCowbells]

DID YOU EVER CONSIDER

THAT YOU ARE SCUM WITH ME?!?!?!

[Harkonnen97]

And all of this time you have been coaching me in the Mafia day chat?

that's totally not what happened, guys and girls.

[RadiantCowbells]

psst we're good no one's onto us.

[Harkonnen97]

yea ikr these losers keep going at each other k e k

*cough*

This time, seriously please. Anyone else thinks that it can be anything else but Postie/Simoyd or Postie/Blank?

[Simoyd]

I have made no claim of any kind.

[Simoyd]

I never once resisted a postie lynch, but I do prefer a blank lynch.

[Simoyd]

I think Harkonnen is town based on the town slip earlier. I'm not getting any manipulative vibes from him, which I think I would if he was cunning enough to fake that slip.

[Postie]

Also Postie yesterday I asked you who would you kill if you were scum. Why didn't you answer?

Sorry, I was phoneposting so I skipped the non-essential stuff.

This is even more suspicious coming from you when you've made such an attempt to hide other people's tells, saying you're sure I'm town but don't want to say why, and you're sure RC is town but not saying what he does when he's scum. I think most people would value keeping their own tells secret more than keeping other people's tells secret. If you value being able to read other people's tells so much, then I would think you'd value keeping your own tells secret even more.

I didn't say anything about specific tells; I just said why I couldn't see myself making that nightkill.

What about Simoyd/Postie?

No.

I feel like RC is sheeping me. Postie, what do you think?

No.

Yup. It's Simoyd/Postie. I can virtually guarantee it.

Don't anyone dare hammer Blank.

RC what happened.

[RadiantCowbells]

Simoyd was really scummy.

We can lynch either of the two of you. If you want to vote Simoyd then we can lynch him.

[Postie]

I think the way Simoyd's L-1ing people is actually pretty town. Just the way he's being all jumpy about it feels like overly-eager newbtown.

[RadiantCowbells]

Uhm.

VOTE: Postie

You're more likely to escape so if that's what we're doing I'll vote you first.

You can't not find his behaviour weird.